Tag: blog

  • Making Sense of the World of Marginal Gains…

    Most of the readers of my blog will be very well aware that things get better step by step. My first car bought whilst I was at Leicester University, in the summer of 1972 was a Ford Popular 100E (1960 model as in photo below), replacing my Honda 75 motor scooter. Travelling the 100 miles each way to Uni to get home on the Honda, open to the elements in a dreadful winter was no fun at all, so replacing that with a car, with some heating and room for 3 friends was life changing. The ‘Pop’ was by all measures a dreadful car, not capable of going faster than the scooter, and when travelling up hill, the windscreen wipers would crawl to a halt, running as they did on the air intake manifold. As for acceleration, 0-60 mph was only possible downhill, and over 30 seconds. Where GB car ownership now is beyond any recognition of those times, who knows what we will be in 50 years from now, yet it’s likely to be approximately the same space and size for 4 or 5 humans to use.

    The same can be said of so many sports; in my times, GB sports have moved from participation to world leading, and these improvements have not occurred by luck, but through the careful and systematic research, starting with the question ‘Why?’ David Brailsford ‘reinventing the wheel’ is nicely described in this Harvard Business Review , in which he explains how the ‘podium principles’ for success were broken down into strategy, human performance and continuous improvement. In Bounce (2010), Matthew Syed gives so many examples on why practice makes perfect, not least by repeating the mantra practice makes perfect! Because GB sport has learned these lessons, in almost all areas of sporting endeavour we are right up there, hence our place as number 2 in the Olympics.

    You won’t be surprised to hear that critics of the classroom suggest that it has not changed over the past 200 years’ designed as it was for the industrial age to create automatons for the factory floor. Images of the Victorian classroom are placed alongside those of the 21st-century classroom, where now in the AI age it is suggested that little is to be learned by gathering knowledge; what we need are the many and various transferable skills to meet the multiple challenges of the post-industrial world, where machines will replace all of our working careers. Such ideas are worth exploring, testing and indeed seem enticing. At the time of my graduating, us new young things were enticed by the idea that our improving wealth would give us more leisure time, happy families and a world of ‘perfect’. So we know how that’s worked out – not!

    Certainly, at my school, we’ve adopted all the podium principles suggested by Brailsford, embraced most of Syed’s psychological and philosophical standpoints, and in every area of our school lives, we’ve seen the marginal gains arise for the children. We’ve learned the lessons of too much screen time; we know that children must learn how to be bored, how to build resilience by failing and enjoyed/admire hugely seeing the extraordinary successes of 18 Ukrainian refugees over 3 years, with little knowledge of the Roman alphabet and spoken English on arrival to the UK, be able to graduate to secondary school, sixth forms and Universities with academic results that most families would say ‘I’d take that!’

    I was intrigued this week when watching a short BBC news clip on Otters, once considered vermin and almost exterminated by vicars and game keepers up to the time I was at Uni. Now they are welcomed back into rivers across the countryside, with some care of course, because they’ll eat you out of fish House and Home in a trice. As with humans, otter pups are intensely curious, and they need be stimulated and enabled to roam, through which they learn all the necessary skills for successful adulthood. It’s just the same for children. Before the age of 5 or 6, learning happens most successfully by play, in a cohort, working together and learning how to socialise. You check out Maslow’s hierarchy of needs to see how success starts, understand the steps taken here, each won through marginal gains. From then onwards, the way we organise our higher thinking skills requires some formalised teaching, not least to keep the child’s emotional development in harness with their intellect – see Bloom’s taxonomy for more on this. Originally shown as a pyramid, I prefer Bloom’s intellectual development in the shape of a 20th-century light bulb because when working with others, we know when our own or their light bulb moment happens – a marginal gain switching on the ‘wow’ and ‘wonder’ and ‘I get it’ moments!

    Whether Bloom, Brailsford, Maslow or Otters, it’s clear the adult coach has their place to steer improvement to happen Yet necessary to that struggle is peer group socialisation, intervention when that’s not going right, teaching to lift the child over the knowledge and skills barriers that are counter-intuitive, ‘parenting not friending’ when managing the household and above all, not putting one’s brain on the shelf and letting others, including AI, carry the load and not bother learning the skills ourselves. I’m intrigued by the latest research that highlights that children need to learn to write physically before using a modern keyboard and computer. Back in the day, whether using paper & pen or typewriter, you had to think about your writing before hardcopy simply because, whether be ink from the pen or the ribbon, once on the paper the mark was permanent. Now, you don’t need to trouble yourself because the screen is a friend to correction. Using such a modern screen, it seems the child can’t remember what they wrote 2 or 3 sentences before, and within about 10 minutes after the work is complete, the work done has been completely forgotten.

    Taking the time to do things well encourages the world of marginal gains, and such practice makes perfect, and after much repetition, practice makes permanent. From brain surgery, through cycling to table tennis, it turns out it’s never about talent (5%), it’s perspiration (95%) – fired of course by curiosity and the desire to improve one’s own performances and seeking, if not a podium finish, at least the self-actualisation of a job done well. And most of the time, that needs a peer group of about 20, of people of about the same age and interests. As indeed the ancient Syrians knew 9 centuries ago, as we’ve discovered from the archaeologists uncovering the ruins of their towns, they found classrooms. And that clearing of the dirt to reveal the evidence beneath can only be done, brush stroke by brush stroke, with common purpose and understanding, that classrooms were just big enough to house a teacher and 20 learners. Well, who knew that?

  • “The longer I live, the more convinced am I that this planet is used by other planets as a lunatic asylum.” – George Bernard Shaw

    A NotebookLM discussion on this blog can be found here: https://schl.cc:443/gz

    The header picture this week shows the ‘beautiful disaster’ that was the Musk SpaceX Starship coming down over the Gulf of Mexico America last Thursday. Characterising any weekly blog by a suitable title that captures the news headlines of the moment and translates for a local audience is really difficult, made especially so the declaration of a ceasefire in Gaza over the weekend, then Monday commencing as it did with the spectacular show that was Donald Trump’s inauguration and the week progressing with the local politics of Britain and Europe being as fractious as ever. It’s a wonder that the Universe has actually tried to remind us that seeking some alignment across the world of humanity’s problems might be a good idea, and so has given us the night sky spectacular of a 6 ‘planetary parade’ as a reminder.

    So down to Education business this week. Leaving aside the immediate and ongoing dispute between the Government’s imposition of an unfair new tax being imposed on private school tuition fees, I bring to the fore the parliamentary work commencing around the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill, introduced on 17 December, now being examined by parliamentary committee since Tuesday, and it’s quite clear from every point of view that the bill is not going down well. Headteacher Katherine Birbalsingh’s letter in the Observer summed-up the problem from her state-side position brilliantly, with each section including the question “What problem were you trying to solve”. You can read the whole 4 pages of her letter here, in which she highlights the genuine good news available in schools that the government could be celebrating, yet it chooses to legislate against.

    In summary, funding special opportunities in state schools to study Latin is a great idea, as is establishing ‘Computing hubs’ so why cut the funding halfway through the academic year and close the courses. Giving state schools the freedom to tweak the curriculum to encourage diversity and creativity to suit their intake works really well, so why forbid that and impose a strict, universal diet on all? Across England, we are currently working through and embedding the curriculum changes implemented 5 years ago, at a great cost in time and money. As a consequence, we’ve seen our primary and secondary outcomes rise up the international league tables and for reading literacy the English lead the Western world. Why spend precious energy, political capital and parliamentary time on destroying the reforms that led to this success? Across the country, the government programmes to recruit graduates into the teaching profession are failing, yet the school-based programmes have been a great success, so why forbid them to continue or try to reduce teacher pay? We know state school attendance has become a real problem, but the best schools use uniforms, badges, ties and kits to create a sense of belonging and value – why forbid such well-understood strategies, used so well by sports teams etc.?

    Regular readers of my Blog know I’ve been offering the Secretary of State help for 18 months now, even when she was in opposition. Phillipson apparently has booked now an opportunity for KB to meet at the DfE, but that’s a ‘show reaction’ to the bad press she’s received in recent weeks. For the government, the press is only going to get worse, with Secretary of State for Health, Wes Sweeting wishing to shut down SEND funding for children with both physical and learning differences, and the HMRC insisting on taxing SEND tuition fees as shown on invoices, with Local Authorities in return refusing to repay schools for the ‘tax lost’, because they’ve already gone down the route of giving personal budgets to parents, which of course were always ‘without VAT’. Because I know that no-one in government will read letters, I’ve taken to ‘vlogging’, my latest on this issue can be found below:

    The Rt Hon Bridget Phillipson MP attended BETT2025 this week on Wednesday, at the same time as my colleague Jawad Laouira, Deputy Head Academic at Juniors, where Meryln Mind (an American AI company that Claires Court has been working with for 3 years) were showcasing their latest offering, Merlyn Origin, for which Jawad and ICTteacher/school photographer, Chris Rowan created this intro film. Well, the film was incredibly well received and a packed Tech-in-Action audience of educators from many different countries were able to question Jawad and the rest of the panel, including VP Merlyn Jason Mayland and UK Partner, Ian Nairn. The message that the panel shared was that there is a real depth of Learning Science behind what Merlyn is helping teachers achieve in their classrooms and in addition Merlyn saves teachers circa 15% of time every lesson. We’ve also found our children are able to interact directly by voice with Merlyn, and as a consequence, we are seeing a direct improvement in the accuracy of their oral questioning. Wins all round.

    My closing message to this blog is pretty obvious really. When GBS originally wrote of the Lunatics, that was well before I was born. I can’t find a precise date, but we are talking about the time of the rise of the fascist dictators in Europe and the chaos that brought. Despite all, humans managed to develop antibiotics, modern conveniences such as the Hoover, the motor car, and above all of course, Sliced Bread, packaged and promoted in the UK as early as 1928! I’ve loved watching the latest series of ‘Inside the Factory’ on BBCTV, with Paddy McGuiness. The Warburton’s loaf factory in which he used to clean the machines at the start of his employment packs 1.4 million loaves a year. That’s progress for sure, and as a nation, our food is secure through major companies doing what they know best. Paddy like me worries about his children, and I just wish Bridget would work with major schools like mine – of course, we are always ready to learn, but we do start from a very strong position of knowing what we do.