Tag: book-review

  • “The day that changed my life” – Andrew Watson

    It’s Friday afternoon, 21 February 2025. Eight days ago, I attended Andrew Watson’s funeral service at St James the Less, Stubbings. The event was so oversubscribed that the church and parish centre (with a live broadcast) were full, and there was standing room only outside. The service was a remarkable showcase of his life, not just because of the size of the congregation but also because of the incredible epitaph his sister Victoria gave that brought home to us all the remarkable impact Andrew had made in the 54 years of life spent alive with us. Since Andrew’s service and following conversations with friends at the wake and elsewhere, I feel I can add just a little more to the notes Andrew might have made of his time at CC.

    During Andrew’s time as a child, he attended Ridgeway (the name of our junior school back then) and then Claires Court Seniors, and I had the good fortune to teach him. Though he left to continue his secondary studies at Reading Bluecoat, in those days our Junior to Senior split took place at the end of Year 5, giving students the time to enjoy a full preparatory education to age 13, and thus sit and (hopefully) pass into the senior school of their choice after 3 years of separate specialist subject education. French and Latin were on the menu, where the standards required by the most demanding of schools at 13+ were close to the current curricular demands giving rise to a grade 4 at GCSE. Those 3 years of prep. school, still in grey shirts and shorts at the outset meant that the programme was demanding and left really quite a range of children unable to access the curriculum. By way of illustration, a typical longer History essay question might ask “Choose two significant events from the 20th century and explain why they were important.”

    Andrew was no slouch, and at any given stage during his education with us, he would always show he was often the best amongst equals. That’s not the point of my writing this blog, no, not at all. The thing with Andrew is that there was always something more going on in the lesson than just his attention to the demands of the teacher. Some 25 years later, I came across the research “The Hidden Lives of Learners” written by Graham Nuthall and published in 2007. It’s a highly influential book in education, based on Nuthall’s extensive research into how students learn in the classroom. In short, Nuthall’s research suggests that teachers are often unaware of a significant portion of what’s happening in their classrooms from the perspective of the children within. Put bluntly, we only know the 5%, the rest is beyond our ken. While the “5%” figure is a popular takeaway message, it’s more of a powerful illustration of the gap between teacher perception and student experience than a precise measurement.

    Nuthall’s work emphasizes that students are constantly constructing their own understanding, engaging in complex social interactions, and experiencing a range of emotions that teachers may not fully perceive. This “hidden life” of the learner encompasses their thoughts, feelings, motivations, and interpretations of the learning environment. Because of this, teachers might only be consciously aware of a small fraction of what each student is experiencing. This realization that there’s a vast and often unseen world within the classroom, comprised of the individual and collective experiences of the children as a group. Ross Morrison McGill highlights the 3 worlds Nuthall uncovered really well in this short video:

    Working with classes 4 to 6 (now Years 6 to 8) back in the ’80s, boys like Andrew made it abundantly clear to us all that far more was going on than we considered in our adult vision. I remember one particular occasion when Kenelm England, Latin teacher and of a similar age to me lost his temper with his class. Known as Eggy to all, it was that day that Andrew suggested ‘Eggy had cracked his shell!’ Andrew’s theatre was the schoolyard, where umpteen different games and sports were invented to pass the time of day. When one game palled’ another would be invented to renew the competition.

    Whilst during our adult lives, our paths rarely converged, I became very aware of Andrew’s impact on the family, company and sporting life. I hope to share with a wider readership Victoria’s Eulogy to her brother, but for now, I ask you to jump over to Andrew’s own blog, Watto’sWords. Andrew and his brother Nicholas who followed his steps into Claires Court, suffered from Cystic Fibrosis, a genetic disorder that sadly and inevitably leads to a premature death. Despite the ever-present threat that lungs could fail, Andrew lived a life that daily brimmed to overflowing.

    In his diary entry, The day that changed my life! By Andrew Watson | May 18, 2018, Andrew highlights and celebrates the day when he was given a life-saving lung transplant. The entry makes compelling reading, perhaps a little more sombre now that, just under 7 years on, in early January this year, Andrew suffered from a relapse to his health, and died shortly afterwards 18/19 January. His parents Allen & Laraine Watson were incredibly supportive of our school whilst their boys passed through our hands, and we’ve stayed in touch professionally too, because Allen’s skills as a surveyor have assisted us in making a variety of planning applications thereafter.

    A day in early May 2017………………….

    It was early morning and the first intravenous drugs of the day were already making their way into my veins, when there was a knock on the door. It was unusual for another knock so soon; it was too early. I knew the routine as I had been in this solitary hospital room for ten weeks. Please read on…

  • “What do George Bernard Shaw, Jeff Goldblum and I have in common?”

    A Notebook LLM conversation about this blog can be found here: https://schl.cc:443/gn

    Today, Monday 6 January 2025 I start my 44th year as a school head, yet another almost relentless anniversary barrier I break through when I come back to work for the new term at Claires Court. My sole place of permanent employment since September 1975 has been the school my parents first established in 1960, and who invited me back to be a teacher of Maths, Science and Sport since graduating from the University of Leicester, 2:1 BSc in Combined Sciences, double major in Biologica Sciences and Psychology. I am now 71 years of age, remain happily married, and have the responsibility for the education of my first grandson now in Year 2. I confess to starting every day with the same enthusiasm as Admiral William McRaven, whose book ‘Make Your Bed: How Little Thing Can Change Your Life” – I know by doing stuff I make a difference, and his graduation speech at UT is perhaps the best of its kind worth watching: The Power of Hope.

    Admiral McRaven is a couple of years younger than me, and his career past working for the military has been pretty stellar too. Not only has he been the Chancellor of the University of Texas, and enjoyed a career as an academic, currently a Professor of National Security at the Lyndon B. Johnson School of Public Affairs at the University of Texas in Austin and a Senior Advisor at Lazard. Moreover, being very well connected, he received $50 million from Amazon founder Jeff Bezos and his fiancé Lauren Sánchez to use for charity. McRaven intends to use this 2024 Bezos Courage and Civility Award to support the children of fallen servicemembers and advocate for veteran mental health issues and education.

    Sadly, I am not that well connected, yet I don’t have any ambition to retire; honestly, I don’t wear the ‘still working’ badge with pride, but have a wholly different mindset to my parents and their generation who could not wait to retire to get on with their lives after work. Thanks to the world of Social Media, I caught up with another celebrity speaker, celebrating his own birthday, one year older than me, actor Jeff Goldblum, reflecting on what inspires him to stay at work. Here’s Goldblum’s response, in which he quotes entirely from memory the words of George Barnard Shaw:

    “This is the true joy in life, being used for a purpose recognized by yourself as a mighty one. Being a force of nature instead of a feverish, selfish little clod of ailments and grievances, complaining that the world will not devote itself to making you happy. I am of the opinion that my life belongs to the whole community and as long as I live, it is my privilege to do for it what I can. I want to be thoroughly used up when I die, for the harder I work, the more I live. I rejoice in life for its own sake. Life is no brief candle to me. It is a sort of splendid torch which I have got hold of for the moment and I want to make it burn as brightly as possible before handing it on to future generations.”

    There’s quite a lot not to like about GBS, particularly in his final years in which he became a great supporter for both Mussolini and Stalin, but his words above resonate hugely for me too, as clearly it remains in all of our hands to make out of the honest clay from which we came the future earth onto which we choose to stride out in the years to come. Having a corporate memory for Education’s declared purpose from 1975 to the present day, I see us all still striving to ensure that every child is given the opportunity “to know, understand and can do”. The tools we were using in the 1970/80s were developed to ensure problem-solving took place in the classroom, in the labs by the way of the Nuffield Practical Science programme. Academic qualifications changed to incorporate such practical skills and measure them at the time of utilisation via coursework and viva voce assessments.

    Over recent decades, with the intervention of the Internet, handheld devices, software and now AI, discovering the knowledge component has been made far easier, proving via assessment of student understanding as problematic, and indeed what they can do now compromised by the utilities that can do it for them. Honestly, this is nothing new. As a baby scout, I was required to learn so many skills to earn badges, which still included Scouts needing to know how to carry messages, use gas masks, and handle crowds. Most of my A-level studies in Chemistry and Biology either included industrial processes defunct from the 1930s and making inaccurate drawings of embryology across the species that tested my visual and practical reasoning skills and didn’t touch the idea of genetics at all (until I entered University).

    On short, and to pick up from GBS, the torch I used to hold included Ever Ready batteries and could sit on the front of my bicycle, with a hood to use in the case of Blackout. That device has changed beyond recognition, inspires as an Olympic flame every 4 years and in the meantime now uses modern li-ion and diodic lights that seem equally at home as lasers cutting through metal or lighting my Christmas Tree to assist Santa find his way! I continue to seek out the new technologies that can illuminate what I do further, so I doff my hat off to Google, WordPress, Jetpack and all who make this purpose easier to share. Thanks to NotebookLLM, dear reader you also get their commentary on my thoughts as well. Happy New year, it’s certainly needing to be a Brave New World, but we can make that happen for sure.