Tag: history

  • “Christian schools win right to landmark Supreme Court appeal” dateline Friday 5 June 2026

    I have copied below the article published on the Christian Concern website, in which they give the remarkable news that the stoicism of the campaigners supported by the Christian Legal Centre has paid off. In short, the Law Lords have permitted the appeal to the Supreme Court on the matter of the blanket imposition of VAT on private school fees. Permission to appeal to the Supreme Court is limited to whether the Government’s policy strikes a fair balance (proportionality) between its objectives and the real-world harms. The schools argue the 2026 Court of Appeal gave insufficient weight to the tangible negative impacts on families and schools, while overemphasising administrative convenience and public finances.

    The case is listed as UKSC/2026/0056 (R (on the application of BYL and another) v Chancellor of the Exchequer and others). Supreme Court hearings are typically scheduled several months after permission is granted. As of now (early June 2026), the hearing has not been listed, and no specific date has been announced publicly.

    Over the last 7 days, the following list covers schools that have announced their closure at the end of the current term:

    Heathside School (Hampstead, London – Dukes Education group)
    Ruckleigh School (Solihull, West Midlands)
    St Wilfrid’s School (Exeter, Devon)
    St Michael Abbey School (Tenbury Wells, Worcestershire)
    St Gerard’s School (Bangor, Gwynedd, Wales)

    …and yesterday the news that Abbotsholme School (Uttoxeter, West Midlands) announced its immediate closure, with staff unpaid since April.

    That significant harm has been caused is beyond any doubt now. The recent Independent Schools Council (ISC) figures revealing a loss of 30,000 pupils across UK independent schools since the introduction of VAT on fees represent a stark and accelerating impact of the policy. With ISC CEO Julie Robinson making numerous media appearances this week to highlight the data, the decline — significantly greater than the government had anticipated — underscores the real-world consequences for families, schools, and the broader education sector. Far from being a simple revenue-raising measure, these numbers illustrate how the blanket VAT charge is forcing difficult choices for parents, threatening the viability of many schools (particularly mid-sized and specialist ones), and ultimately risking added pressure on already-stretched state schools as displaced pupils seek places there. This data strengthens the case for a more nuanced and proportionate approach to education policy.

    “The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom has granted permission for a group of independent Christian schools, parents and pupils to appeal the Government’s decision to impose VAT on independent school fees, ensuring that the high-profile legal challenge will now be heard by the country’s highest court. Lord Reed, Lord Hamblen and Lord Richards confirmed that permission to appeal has been granted on one of the central grounds of challenge, proportionality, recognising that this aspect of the case raises an arguable issue requiring consideration at the highest level.

    The case is supported by the Christian Legal Centre and brought by independent Christian schools across the UK, including Emmanuel School in Derby, The Branch Christian School in Yorkshire, The King’s School in Hampshire, and Wyclif Independent Christian School in South Wales, including parents and even pupils.

    They argue that the Government’s VAT policy disproportionately impacts Christian schools and the families who choose them, particularly those of modest means. While permission has been limited to “ground 4” of the appeal, this issue lies at the very heart of the case. It concerns whether the Government’s policy strikes a fair balance between its stated objectives and the real-world consequences for affected schools, parents and children.

    The schools’ lawyers contend that the 2026 Court of Appeal ruling placed insufficient weight on the tangible harms caused, including financial strain on families, disruption to children’s education, and risks to the viability of schools, while giving undue weight to administrative convenience and public finance considerations. The appeal will therefore give the Supreme Court the opportunity to examine whether the proportionality test was properly applied and whether the policy goes further than is justified.

    A key feature of the challenge is that the VAT measure applies as a blanket policy, without allowing for individual circumstances. The schools argue that this lack of flexibility fails to account for families who choose Christian education for religious reasons, those already financially stretched, pupils settled in their schools, and institutions whose sustainability is under threat.

    The case also raises wider concerns about fairness. The appellants argue that it is disproportionate to single out parents who are not using the state system, despite contributing through general taxation to state education, and then requiring them to shoulder an additional financial burden. Another significant issue is the absence of any transitional arrangements. The policy was introduced without safeguards for children already part-way through an academic year or stage of education, leading to disruption and uncertainty for families who had made long-term commitments.

    This development marks a significant step forward in a case with far-reaching implications for education, religious freedom, and parental choice across the United Kingdom. While the outcome remains to be determined, the Supreme Court’s decision confirms that the challenge raises serious and arguable questions requiring full consideration.

    Analysis reported in The Times this week highlighted that since the introduction of a 20 per cent charge on school fees, more mid-sized independent schools than usual have begun to buckle. Across the independent sector, including special educational needs schools, closures rose from 58 in 2024 to 71 in 2025. “

  • Purpose, Pride, and a Few Extra Kit Bags

    Audio overview blog

    With every New Year comes hopes and aspirations, though perhaps, like the sunshine this week, they peek through a watery sky. The playing fields at Claires Court Juniors may look similar to those elsewhere in the neighbourhood, but whatever happens in January and beyond is built on the foundations of our achievements over the previous years. The most likely impact comes from the deliberate steps we have taken to move forward positively and, to slightly misquote Tom Hanks, “Turn up, know your purpose and show that you know what you are doing!”

    Perhaps the most delightful rebuttal to the “too cool for school” myth is the sheer variety of kit bags our pupils lug across those fields. It is remarkably difficult to maintain a posture of detached indifference when you are constantly switching roles—swapping muddy rugby boots for ballet shoes, trading a cross-country singlet for the quiet focus of the chess club or the studious engagement of music practice and choral singing. Our students don’t just “turn up” in the singular sense; they arrive equipped with the tools and kits required to shift their focus on demand, ready to meet whatever the day requires.

    There is a certain gritty, unselfconscious pride in an Under 15 squad that looks at a selective grammar school with 180 boys per year group and decides that our smaller, expertly tailored environment is exactly where history will be made*. As noted in our recent ISI inspection, it is this expertly tailored personal learning and specialist teaching that enables every pupil to thrive. Whether they are navigating an ambitious curriculum or preparing for the next round of a national competition, they aren’t following the “too cool” rule; they are far too busy making their own history, one kit bag at a time.

    This sense of purpose is no more evident than at the top of the school. Now that the UCAS deadline has passed, our Year 13 students are receiving offers from across the country. For them, life is both exciting and anxious in equal measure as they fine-tune their efforts ahead of A-level examinations in four months. They may eventually leave the physical kit bags of the Junior and Senior School behind, but they carry with them the versatility and initiative they have honed here, ready to step into their next chapter knowing exactly what they are doing.

    *The Under 15 Rugby XV defeated Southend High School 41-7 in the Regional final of the RFU vase on Wednesday 14 January 2026.

  • Diplomacy – Whether to Grin & Bear it?

    Current events around the world, and with specific reference to this week’s visit of the President of the United States as well as peace talks around the Gaza crisis and the war in Ukraine, reminds us all that progress around problems (and finding their solution) can’t be made unless all parties are included in the conversation. As the general title of my blog suggests (A Principled View), should not we all call a spade a spade to remind people of the work that has to be done? Perhaps not, and that’s where Diplomacy comes in! It’s as unwise to gloss over the challenges as it is to call out that it’s a ‘bloody shovel’.

    Over my time as a headteacher, I’ve carried to staff meetings a small figurine, see below, identifying that, as often as not, someone has had to ‘suck it up’, go the hard yards and ‘Grin & Bear It’. It’s been really useful to carry this ‘GBI’ statue, some times associated with a bottle of pop or Amazon voucher, because when all said and done’, a colleague or team has stood up and carried a significant load, unexpected to either their job description or pay grade. Inevitably this is the diplomatic view to take, to appreciate the support has been given and to recognise the pain and inconvenience that came with it.

    I don’t support that King Charles and the Royal Household had too many options when last Summer the Prime Minister encouraged him to invite ‘The Donald’ for the Royal Visit just witnessed. Over the 2 days of Red Carpet, treatment, including the fly past, the parachute jump, the Castle banquet and umpteen photo calls, it’s clear that both King and President have confirmed the that the close relationship between both countries is of vital importance, and probably not just to us, but the wider world as well. Sure there were legitimate protests around the country, for some the sycophancy, for others the blind eye being turned to previous acts, to yet more the failure to act with determination to stay the hand of Putin or Netanyahu spoke of ‘empty promises, never to be fulfilled.

    Sir Winston Churchill had an alternative view on Diplomacy, highlighting that if the outcome of such discussions were to be a victory for the ‘home team’, then the work to be done had to be result-focused. The reality of our country’s situation at the time was that Neville Chamberlain glossed over the problem; after signing the Munich Agreement with Adolf Hitler, which allowed Germany to annex the Sudetenland in exchange for a promise of no further territorial expansion, Chamberlain declared “Peace for our time” on September 30, 1938, after signing the Munich Agreement with Adolf Hitler, which allowed Germany to annex the Sudetenland in exchange for a promise of no further territorial expansion. We know how that went, as a year later, the Second World War broke out! See the poster at the bottom, which expresses Churchill’s approach really well.

    In whatever life you lead, be that private or public, and wherever you are in the hierarchy of life itself, being sure your voice is heard is really important. You can measure the quality of the people you are working with by whether they are open to listening and hearing your point of view. It’s the nature of life that the parties could disagree, yet the quality of the discussion will always highlight the there has been clarity of purpose and that the respect for both parties has been maintained. Prior to the assassination of Charlie Kirk, the American political activist, in support for Trump’s MAGA campaign expressed some pretty extreme views which many would take great exception to. I’d watched his various debates with students from the Cambridge Union, exceptional short exchanges of views, from which I suspect we’d have to declare a draw when time was called. What I do respect is that Kirk was prepared all the time to debate the issues, to pursued and take the hit if he lost the argument on the day.

    Kirk’s murder was completely unacceptable, as all such crimes across the world are. The subsequent further polarisation of views clearly show we are now further away from developing a consensus around the way our collective societies should behave. I am deeply concerned by the extreme left’s Fabian views of the direction of travel they wish, that being the peaceful takeover of our values led, meritocratic, democratic society and its replacement by a socialist society, believing that all private property is theft and that we are best being ‘nationalised’ to a common view point. Their coat of arms carries a ‘Wolf in Sheep’s clothing, so we need to very afraid, because their activist sit at the heart of the current Labour government,

    Opinion polls show that more generally that the voice of the right wing is now dominant, with Reform led by Nigel Farage leading the way. The promises they bring are as likely to be as hollow as those that Labour expressed as they sought power (save the NHS and Smash the Gangs) or as they were by the Brexiteers a decade go as they sought to persuade us that leaving the EU would save us billions, to be directed to save the NHS and permit our economy to grow so much more rapidly. The reasoned middle way has ‘disappeared’ for the time being, and it seems we are returning to the potential bankrupt ideas of the 1970s and 1990s.

    So why am I writing this political take in an Academic’s blog usually reserved for Education matters? It’s quite clear that the expected nursery and school provision of services to parents and children are now hitting the ‘requirements to change’, without reasoned discussions or even inclusion of the related parties affected. Changes to VAT, funding for nurseries & Ofsted inspection reports, new education acts to renationalise state academies and review the SEN funding for those with additional needs to reduce the current spend dramatically are all taking place WITHOUt consultation. The latter are not manifesto promises, yet the DfE snowplough moves relentlessly onwards and the politicians defending them publicly defend their ‘improvements’, in the the face of the sector’s growing anxiety that the outcomes are going to be so much worse for the children in our care.

    As senior, sector professional, I will keep calling this out. At its best, the Department for Education has done and will continue to develop a system for education the envy of the world. Yet, with politicians changing the rules daily, trumpeting like Chamberlain did 60+ years ago that all is well, keep calm and carry on, to be fair, I’ll side with Winston Churchill. I just hope there is someone out there in authority that wants to listen to me.

  • “Time passes, Lives change, but Memories last forever.”  Reflections on Thank a Teacher day.

    National Thank a Teacher Day is an annual celebration of teachers and support staff across early years settings, schools and colleges. This year it will take place on Wednesday 18th June 2025. Last year over 82,000 Thank a Teacher Day personalised e-cards were sent​ and we had a media reach of 60,000,000 including national coverage on BBC, ITV, The Sunday Times, The Daily Express and The Sun​ https://thankateacher.co.uk/nationalthankateacherday/

    After our prep school years which lasted until the end of Year 8, my brother Hugh and I pursued our Senior School Education to University entrance at Douai School, Woolhampton, one of the great Benedictine monastic schools in existence in the 1960s-1990s. The plan had been for us to study much more locally at Beaumont College in Old Windsor, owned and run by the Society of Jesus, another monastic order known as the Jesuits. The school announced its closure in 1965, deciding to focus the community’s efforts on their other school in England, Stonyhurst in Lancashire. Given that Douai was in easy reach of Maidenhead Thicket via the 1/1A bus service to Woolhampton, and a 15 minute walk up the hill to Douai Abbey and its school, as well as, of course, by car, the decision to board locally was one our parents found easy to make.

    I left Douai in December 1971, having stayed back a term after A levels to take Oxford Entrance exams to Pembroke College and to play Rugby for the 1st XV. As anyone of our age will relate, a boarding education anywhere in the country was both spartan and at times, notoriously physical by way of punishment to manage behaviour. My first year at the school included ‘fagging duties’ which meant attending to the Sixth Form at meal times to serve them food, as well as cleaning the prefects’ shoes and meeting their idle needs as they felt fit. What made this apparent reincarnation of Tom Brown’s violent school days acceptable was the incredibly strong pastoral care given by my housemaster, Father Bernard Swinhoe, of Walmsley House. Throughout my time at Douai, he kept his eye on me as he did on the other 80 boys in the House, and communicated particularly well to my parents on my conduct (good or bad) in school. For example, he wrote to my parents during my O-level Christmas term that ‘Jimmy has joined a smoking gang’; this did not actually come as a surprise to my parents, both at the time habitual smokers, but it did cause me to take stock and be reminded that I was not after all quite so invisible at school as perhaps I thought. And that warning certainly caused me to avoid further physical punishment at school.

    My final 4 terms at Douai were spent even closer to Father Bernard; his seemingly massive interest in, and knowledge of, everything made him an ideal mentor for A-level General Studies; together with the Head of English, William Bell, I was scrubbed up well for the exams I needed to take for A-level and Oxford, as well as taught niceties of working in seminars via an evening dining club known as ‘Parnassus’. He took an enormous interest in my exploits on the Rugby field as open side for the 1st XV, and kept in touch with me during the 3 years at university beyond. Father Bernard’s perceptible joy at being asked to assist at my wedding during the hot summer of 1975 was perhaps his recognition of the strength of admiration I held him in. As his obituary written by a fellow monk from Douai makes clear, the way he lived his life and the way he formed relationships were indeed remarkable, and I am one of his many charges who will never forget how he made us feel, welcome and wanted. 

    The abridged version of his obituary is below, the fuller version can be found here on pages 127-129 of the Douai Magazine.

    If I were writing to Fr Bernard now, I’d add the following:

    “Dear Bernie, above all of the many happy memories you helped create for me, it was your ability to keep the tuck shop fully stocked before film night, that you ran the best ‘smokes’ during the weekday evenings when we could come together and listen to the latest LPs that we had managed to buy from the Reading record shops, and above all, not to mock me too much when I forgot where I was and called you ‘Dad’. You saw my disappointment when I received the rejection letter from Pembroke, and made it quite clear that ‘Oxford’s loss was to be Leicester’s gain’. You never met the 2 sons that Jenny and I have brought up and now grandparent for, but they would hear your stories and completely agree that ‘Jimmy’ hasn’t changed much since, interested in everything and everyone, a chip of the same block from which you seemed to have been carved!”

    We never had ‘Thank a Teacher Day’ during my childhood, and it’s a very good idea now that’s been around for 27 years. You can read more from their official website and as Michael Morpurgo makes clear,  ““For so many of us, it was someone at school who changed our lives, was at our side through hard and difficult times, lifted us up when we were down, helped us find our voice, gave us confidence when we needed it most, set us on a path that we have followed ever since.”

    Father Bernard at the Tuck shop

    Fr Bernard Swinhoe OSB, 1931-2020
    Our much-loved Father Bernard slipped away into the hands of the Lord on Maundy Thursday night. It was no surprise; he had long been failing with gentle dementia, then a two-week stay in hospital over Christmas was followed by some weeks in a care home. What a fitting, peaceful end for a gentle, kind and sensitive monk. Charles Swinhoe was born in Rochester on 20 June 1931. His father was an army colonel in India, so he spent time there as a child. He was then some years at St. Richard’s Prep School at Little Malvern. He and his sisters and younger brother lived with their mother in a number of rented houses during the war years. Family was always important to him; mother, sisters and brother mattered a lot. In 1944, he came to Douai School, where he distinguished himself in many sports, captaining the rugby and cricket teams.

    After National Service as a commissioned officer with the King’s African Rifles in Kenya, he joined the monastic community in 1952, taking the name Bernard. He was professed in 1953, obtained an English degree at Oxford and was ordained priest in 1961. He was, however, always somewhat less comfortable as a priest than as a simple monk. His mastery of English stayed with him all his life, and he loved to painstakingly hone his writing. His sermons were always beautifully crafted and elegantly delivered. One of his brethren once cheekily quipped that his university degree was in punctuation. Quintessentially a monk and full of life, Bernard was quietly self-effacing. Deeply rooted in the Douai soil, where he belonged for 67 years (or 72, including school days) he is now buried in that earth. Stabilitas loci! He was faithful to the end to the community and to the round of Divine Office, the praise of God. In his last fading months at Douai, he especially loved sharing the night prayer of Compline. He naturally accepted his final lot in hospitals and care homes, remaining ever appreciative of the nurses’ attentions.

    Bernard’s genuine self-deprecation was not false humility; rather, reticence, scrupulosity, and dissatisfaction with himself. Mindful of the dangers of self-satisfaction, to which most of us are prone, St Benedict in chapter seven of his Rule strongly insists on turning from this undermining vice. It has been said that “the secret of one person’s success is another person’s success remaining a secret; some people would not provide to be so pivotal in your life had they been more concerned with their own”. And this was Bernard’s humility, mixed as has been observed, with a measure of quiet roguishness. One remembers his merriment recounting somewhat scurrilous anecdotes heard in an august commission on which he sat. For one former pupil, Bernard “did not suggest or rely on a hierarchical relationship with us as boys, he displayed an openness both to his own uncertainties and to your possibilities”.

    Bernard had the inestimable gift of being ever available and accessible to all, boy or fellow monk. He would repair your rugby boots, fix your watch, mend your lock and make you a key, fill a gap to play double bass in the school orchestra, bind the monastery books or paint the missing oil portrait of a long-deceased abbot he had never met. His natural curiosity about everything, how many interests, his enthusiasms and skills, his practical knack and unremitting generosity remained with him until the end. He has left a mark on us all.

    Fr Bernard died quietly on 9 April, during the COVID-19 lockdown, and was buried simply in the monks’ graveyard, after a private Requiem celebrated by the community on 17 April 2020. May he rest in peace.
    Peter Bowe OSB

    To repeat, Michael Morpurgo makes clear,  ““For so many of us, it was someone at school who changed our lives, was at our side through hard and difficult times, lifted us up when we were down, helped us find our voice, gave us confidence when we needed it most, set us on a path that we have followed ever since.” I see this happening every day here at school, brilliant leading & learning relationships being forged between adults and children, and I do thank them (and my lucky stars) that I have so many teachers and support staff who have this vocation to make a difference to the lives of the children and young people they teach. If as a consequence of reading this blog, you feel moved to thank a teacher, please do so – it will really make their day!