Tag: labour-party

  • My Week: “Any name in the headlines” as told to Claires Court SchoolTV

    This blog is all about the brilliant support work that our SchoolTV service provides. But I can’t help include in these introductory 3 paragraphs that some of the headline leaders in the Press have been having a right go at Sir Kier Starmer, his wife Lady Victoria, Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves and Deputy Leader Angela Rayner, because of the ‘Freebie culture’ they seem all to have been enjoying recently. All have children, lots of them, all of school age. I can’t imagine the difference a few weeks have made to the life of these 3 and other lead politicians, but the dramatic change in their presence in the ‘Public Eye’ will certainly have impacted upon their home life. I suspect the PM remembers speaking about how come Friday nights, he’ll put the government iPad down at 6pm, and get on with having a nice night in. Honestly, as if!!! Apart from facing a barrage of criticism on the salary levels of his top staff, on the way to the Labour Party conference, no doubt with some jet setting across the pond to deliver his first Speech to the UN stuck into his diary at the last minute.

    The Times newspaper writes a lovely weekly diary, lampooning the latest ‘star’ caught in the headlights, Sir Kier and Donald Trump being the most recent targets for journalist Hugo Rifkind’s acid wit. Last week’s diary spoke of Sir Kier’s Monday as follows: “Monday: I’ve just finished brushing my teeth with the toothbrush bought for me by Lord Alli, then rinsing my mouth out with the enamel mug bought for me by Lord Alli, when I pick up the iPhone bought for me by Lord Alli and give him a call. “Listen,” I say. “I’m off to Italy in a minute. But first we need to talk about all these silly stories that you’re giving me loads of free stuff.” “No need to ring,” he says, striding into the bathroom. “Because I haven’t given back my Downing Street pass.” And then we go into the kitchen and use the coffee machine he bought us to make a couple of flat whites. “It’s just a smear,” says my wife Vic, who is here, too. “All this. We’ve done nothing wrong.”

    Now I am just running the school as Academic Principal, rather than also covering the day job of leading Senior Boys, it’s fair to say my week could not have been busier, though in a nice way, because it’s been filled with leadership work, across the sites and the last 2 days at a major conference ISPN South, working with Independent school leaders from across the country. We will not be giving the PM or his team any credit for their first 2 months in office. Announcing that 20% VAT was to be added to private school fees from January 2024 on 29 July meant that most of us had to cancel our holiday plans and renew the fire fighting. You can read the Independent Schools Council submission to HM Treasury’s VAT consultation here: it’s a fabulous read and covers the whole spectrum of schools in our sector. Quite how our PM can speak at the United Nations this week about how his government is bringing back “Britain’s return to responsible global leadership”, whilst choosing to dismantle one of the fundamental tenets of the UN, Article 26 of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights is a grave example of such Labour party hypocrisy on steroids.

    Back to the present – what Claires Court SchoolTV offers is a very sane, sensible set of directions to adults and for adults to investigate concerns they might have about family life and school. I’ve added this week the module on Respectful Relationships (I can only imagine what the kids are saying to their parents as the adults return from Liverpool and the Labour Party conference, but if my house was anything to go by when my 2 were at home, it would have been a genuine mix of concern and leg-pulling. Whatever happens at work, for stable family life’, it’s probably best to leave the workplace at the front door if you can. CC Past pupil Will Ballntyne runs an excellent local set of brilliant offices here in Maidenhead, MyWorkPlace, busier than ever because whilst work can of course take place anywhere, being able to separate work from home is essential.

    Here’s the link to the Claires Court SchoolTV Positive Parenting Series. Id recommend you to check out the particular Topic on ‘Respectful Relationships’, covering as it does some great groundwork, if you’re unfamiliar with the subject. The copy is written by experts from the UK and Australia, and I capture some below to give you a flavour of its common sense approach:

    Teaching children to respect themselves and others will open up avenues for both personal growth and academic achievement. Fostering an environment where respect is not just a word, but a practiced behaviour, will empower young people with essential life skills. Effective communication, active listening, and the art of compromise, will provide your child with a solid foundation that will transcend family interactions and help them collaborate effectively with peers, teachers and the broader community.

    The point is with SchoolTV is that’s it’s not a good read – it’s made up of a series of great video clips which can be watched or listened to, quickly and simply – because it is copyright protected, I can’t show clip embedded in my blog, BUT do go look and check out what it has to offer. The worldwide team from SchoolTV are coming to visit us at Claires Court in a week or so. As with so many of the resources we fund and share, such as Going to the Cloud with Google in 2012 or Investing in AI 3 years ago for a safe school-based tool, being early adopters means the lessons we help a service provider gain assists everyone in the longer term. In short, CC knows stuff and we are always keen to share that.

    After the party conferences, Parliament returns and on Tuesday morning, 8 October, James Wilding will be back in Parliament Square, queueing with the Education not Taxation pressure group to attend the House of Commons debate on the same Topic as the Lords 2 weeks ago. All the leaders of the Independent Schools groups have to be very circumspect in dealing with government.politicians, particularly in Parliament can be as rude as they like, but if we ever chose to disrepect a government department, you can be very certain they would not speak to us again! Some groups were very rude when the last government swapped in 2010, only to wait in the Abyss for 14 years before being able to ‘jaw-jaw’ once more. That’s why of course I’ve checked in with SchoolTV on ‘Respectful Relationships‘ – you should do so too!!!

  • Principled views on the Election 4 July 2024

    Following yesterday’s ballot, a Labour government has been elected. As Principals, my brother, Hugh and I know that the result will understandably cause uncertainty for all independent schools directly, and of course for our parents who have placed their children with us at Claires Court. For some time, Labour’s stated intention has been to remove “tax breaks” for our sector by imposing VAT on school fees and, as has already happened in Scotland and Wales, removing mandatory business rates relief from independent schools with charitable status. Because Claires Court does not have charitable status, we pay full business rates so the loss of this relief is already covered. Many independent schools nationally will not be so fortunate.


    I copy below the message sent from Rudi Elliot Lockhart, CEO of the Independent Schools Association (ISA) to all 674 headteachers within ISA, the largest of the associations covering such schools in England.

    “We have a new Government. As we know, it is the stated policy of the Government to impose VAT on school fees and to end business rates relief for schools with charitable status.
    This has been the predominant political issue for the independent sector for a good while and has taken up much of ISA’s work in recent times. Nothing changes in this regard, other than we now have the certainty of a Labour government.

    We will continue to make a positive case for all our schools and the independent sector more widely. We will continue to point out that we believe the Government’s VAT policy is misguided with damaging consequences for many of our schools and their pupils.
    ISA is open to working with whoever is in power. We hope to have a constructive dialogue with the new Government to secure the best educational outcomes for our schools. We are working closely with the Independent Schools Council (ISC) our umbrella organisation, which is also in communication with heads, sharing the work it has done on behalf of the independent sector and its immediate plans.”

    The new Labour government now has to publish the details of their outline proposals, including their consideration of the many unintended consequences to be worked through, together with a timetable for implementation. The King’s Speech on 19 July will contain an outline but the incoming new Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, has said that the policy will be announced in her first Budget (expected in the autumn), and media briefings have suggested implementation is likely to be later in 2025, either aligned to the new tax year (April) or school year (September). In the meantime, whilst ISA and ISC will be directly engaging with the incoming government over the summer period, the Principals and staff at Claires Court will work extremely hard to make sure we mitigate as best we can the harmful effects as they emerge from Labour’s proposals. As best we can, our Principals’ letter to parents at the end of this term next week will cover more in this area should the new government provide further clarity on this matter before then.

  • Out of the frying pan…

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak called the next general election on Wednesday 24 May 2024, circa 16:26 after a day filled with rumour beforehand. Am I a great fan of the current administration? No. Have I confidence in our current Member of Parliament, Theresa May? Yes, but she is standing down, and we have no idea who is to take her place as MP, because she’s be the only one Maidenhead has ever had. What competition do the Conservatives have in Maidenhead? Well, the Conservatives are in the minority, with the local council being run by a mix of Lib-Dems and Independents. And there’s a thing, because the leadership just made application to the Treasury for exceptional financial support. In short, RBWM is bankrupt, and needs bailing out by central government.

    The council’s perilous position is best described by the local paper, the Maidenhead Advertiser. “The Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead council has been forced to seek ‘exceptional financial support’ from central government to rescue it from its perilous situation, ‘due in large part to historical local and national decisions’ going back many years. Year-on-year reductions to council tax for a period of six years from 2010 have left the council’s budget £30 million lower than if council tax had risen in line with average increases across the country. At the same time, the council’s debt increased from £58.7 million in 2014 to £204 million by March 2023, during the time when Government funding to local authorities was cut by 30 per cent. Reserves in April 2023 were at an un-audited £10m – the lowest known reserves of any unitary authority.“

    There is much I like about local government; suffice it to say that much decision-making is located near where the choices made will have an impact. The trouble is that local government needs to avoid ‘aping’ national government, and that’s where RBWM got things really wrong over time. When George Osborne became Chancellor of the Exchequer in 2010, he called for austerity measures in a country seeking to recover from the 2008 financial crisis. Sadly, both local council leaders, Simon Dudley (2016-19) and his successor Andrew Johnston (2019-2023) chose to pursue a minimalist policy for local rates, keeping the cash costs to local residents for council services at a rock bottom rate. And guess what, if you don’t keep the cash coming in, services suffer and eventually the council can’t actually pay for the minimum services required of it by local people and national government. It’s petty to talk about the loss of our flower-baskets and local gardening services to keep the Town Hall flower beds under control, not so trivial when local police and warden services disappear and frankly a disgrace when the audit controls discover a black hole into which previous years of un-budgeted expenses have been filed.

    By way of example, here’s Cllr Dudley writing a year ago in ‘Conservative Home’ about the unrecognised successes of his period leading RBWM, prior to their dismissal by the electorate:

    “I was a councillor here from 2007 to 2019 (Deputy Leader, Lead Member for Finance in a great team). I was Leader from 2016 to 2019. We held the council in the hard times of the Brexit stalemate of May 2019. Direct comparisons with prior elections (we won four times) are hard because we instigated a boundary review and reduced the number of councillors from 53 to 41 prior to the 2019 “all out” elections. However, in May 2019 we achieved 43 per cent of the vote and 35,999 votes for a Conservative candidate. We held the council by 22 to 19. We did this with a hugely pro-housing agenda. Developing Maidenhead Golf Club (worth around £300 million to the local taxpayer) with a proposed 1,800 new homes (30 per cent of which will be affordable) as part of a Borough Local Plan which was restarted when I became Leader and is now adopted. It would have been hard for us to be seen as less pro-housing, establishing two housebuilding joint ventures, one with Cala Homes (for the golf club) and another with Countryside for regenerating Maidenhead.”

    The reality some 12 months on are really clear to those councillors and public officials left to clear up the mess left by the Conservatives, an oxymoron if ever there was one for the behaviour of those previous politicians (now out of office). As things turn out at the Golf Club, it looks as though the council won’t benefit from the £300 million windfall any more than it did the sale of the old leisure centre to Countrywide for the price of being provided with a new one – the new Braywick Leisure centre cost some £40 million and the old site was devalued from £38 million to… £15 million and still shrinking. The Golf club sale suffers from the similar failure to ‘conserve’ the deal struck. It may be that the golf course land was worth north of £300 million pounds back when the deal was struck (or not, as the reality seems to be). I am told that the arrangements with Cala Homes permits them to claw back from that price all the additional elements that make for building a modern set of homes, schools, doctors and attendant facilities, including pumps for all, bio-net-gain, etc.

    I feel sure by now, dear reader, you’ll wonder why I have entitled this blog as ‘Out of the frying pan…’, and that’s actually because the focus on redeveloping Maidenhead’s town centre and enabling it’s repopulation with residents living ‘in town’ has had a fabulous effect on the local economy, Not only do we have a cherished new Waterside development in the town, but we have become a major attraction across the global corporate world for being a town worth investing in, what with the Elizabeth line, and as Agents Knight Frank wrote last month (22 May) “A key strength of Maidenhead as an office location is its connectivity to its surrounding areas. The transport infrastructure means that London can be reached in as little as 17 minutes via train and is easily accessible via the M4 motorway. Access to a diverse workforce is vital for occupiers and reaching key UK centres within a reasonable journey time. Lifestyle and wellbeing are another of Maidenhead’s strengths. The Chapel Arches, One Maidenhead and Tempo developments have provided the town centre with abundant usable space, including housing, retail, public spaces, food and beverage, and offices. This is key for occupiers, who need to attract and retain talent. Onward, the Nicholson Quarter regeneration will be key in continuing the momentum by providing the space for employers and employees to remain and relocate.“

    So, in short, there have been some major losses locally over the years, lots of change, much to look forward to and a sense that actually we’ve a lot now going in our favour. The pollsters are having a field day, and the changes seen locally last year in the democratic landscape look as though they are to happen across the country too. And it’s not all one way, because Scotland, Nothern Ireland and Wales are also facing seismic change, led as they have been by parties of different hues too. But, it does look as though the mead party next Friday in the Palace of Westminster/House of Commons will be Labour, so here perhaps is the ‘frying pan’.., to watch out for.

    What I fear most from an incoming government under the Labour Party of course is the suggested implementation of a 20% VAT hike on private school tuition fees. With close to a thousand children in my school, the direct impact of such a hike on parents being able to afford us will be considerable. We are a business established for the purpose of offering independent schooling for children aged 2 to 18, we receive no benefits as conferred by charitable status, we pay business rates on our properties and corporation tax on our profit. Those schools that are charities in England are clearly fearful because already taking place in Scotland (2022) has been the removal of rate relief.

    Our parents already pay for education through the taxes they pay, and for many families, we provide only part of the mix they need, where their local state schools can’t offer the benefits we do. What’s so very evident too is that no party of government can translate their promises into the direct action they publish in their manifesto; finding more teachers and doctors in principle sounds easy, but directing them to work in harsh, unmanageable conditions is quite something else.

    School Proprietors remain politically neutral because the education service we offer must provide access to a balanced range of opinions and serve the needs not just of the present, but also ensure we reflect suitably on the past (that covers everything pretty much) and look to the future (almost certainly for most of us, the ‘unknown’). I know that schools are seen as places for fostering critical thinking and exposure to a variety of viewpoints. Such political neutrality helps ensure the curriculum focuses on facts and different perspectives, rather than promoting a specific party line. Moreover, children and young people come from families with diverse political views. Our neutral environment avoids alienating students or creating a sense of pressure to conform to a particular ideology. Parents entrust us with the education of their children. Political neutrality helps ensure that the school’s focus is on academic development, not indoctrination!

    It’s important to note that neutrality doesn’t mean shying away from discussing current events or politics altogether. Our school playgrounds and events can still hold conversations about government, elections, and different political philosophies. Having studied 3 years of Ecology at University, I know how important the environment is, and I also know just how committed some young people have become to resisting climate change. However, my focus as a school academic leader should be on critical analysis and fostering independent thinking, not promoting a specific viewpoint. I’m watching as much of the political discourse in open debates on the TV as time and report reading permits, and I have been more stuck than ever that no-body from any party actually seems to answer the questions posed by the audience.

    There is an old quip, attributed to George Bernard Shaw, that if all the economists were laid end to end, they’d never reach a conclusion. Actually, most economists do think alike as do the neutral public figures I’ve seen on TV and heard on radio – they are asking for the same things, including at the core the rebuilding of trust in our politicians and that they will do the right thing – please read last week’s blog because that’s absolutely the point. Whoever wins next week needs to unite the country, not divide us, bring a common purpose to the fore and, if change is to be wrought, take care and consider the unintended consequences of manifesto promises that actually won’t deliver the benefits suggested!