Tag: politics

  • My Week: “Any name in the headlines” as told to Claires Court SchoolTV

    This blog is all about the brilliant support work that our SchoolTV service provides. But I can’t help include in these introductory 3 paragraphs that some of the headline leaders in the Press have been having a right go at Sir Kier Starmer, his wife Lady Victoria, Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves and Deputy Leader Angela Rayner, because of the ‘Freebie culture’ they seem all to have been enjoying recently. All have children, lots of them, all of school age. I can’t imagine the difference a few weeks have made to the life of these 3 and other lead politicians, but the dramatic change in their presence in the ‘Public Eye’ will certainly have impacted upon their home life. I suspect the PM remembers speaking about how come Friday nights, he’ll put the government iPad down at 6pm, and get on with having a nice night in. Honestly, as if!!! Apart from facing a barrage of criticism on the salary levels of his top staff, on the way to the Labour Party conference, no doubt with some jet setting across the pond to deliver his first Speech to the UN stuck into his diary at the last minute.

    The Times newspaper writes a lovely weekly diary, lampooning the latest ‘star’ caught in the headlights, Sir Kier and Donald Trump being the most recent targets for journalist Hugo Rifkind’s acid wit. Last week’s diary spoke of Sir Kier’s Monday as follows: “Monday: I’ve just finished brushing my teeth with the toothbrush bought for me by Lord Alli, then rinsing my mouth out with the enamel mug bought for me by Lord Alli, when I pick up the iPhone bought for me by Lord Alli and give him a call. “Listen,” I say. “I’m off to Italy in a minute. But first we need to talk about all these silly stories that you’re giving me loads of free stuff.” “No need to ring,” he says, striding into the bathroom. “Because I haven’t given back my Downing Street pass.” And then we go into the kitchen and use the coffee machine he bought us to make a couple of flat whites. “It’s just a smear,” says my wife Vic, who is here, too. “All this. We’ve done nothing wrong.”

    Now I am just running the school as Academic Principal, rather than also covering the day job of leading Senior Boys, it’s fair to say my week could not have been busier, though in a nice way, because it’s been filled with leadership work, across the sites and the last 2 days at a major conference ISPN South, working with Independent school leaders from across the country. We will not be giving the PM or his team any credit for their first 2 months in office. Announcing that 20% VAT was to be added to private school fees from January 2024 on 29 July meant that most of us had to cancel our holiday plans and renew the fire fighting. You can read the Independent Schools Council submission to HM Treasury’s VAT consultation here: it’s a fabulous read and covers the whole spectrum of schools in our sector. Quite how our PM can speak at the United Nations this week about how his government is bringing back “Britain’s return to responsible global leadership”, whilst choosing to dismantle one of the fundamental tenets of the UN, Article 26 of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights is a grave example of such Labour party hypocrisy on steroids.

    Back to the present – what Claires Court SchoolTV offers is a very sane, sensible set of directions to adults and for adults to investigate concerns they might have about family life and school. I’ve added this week the module on Respectful Relationships (I can only imagine what the kids are saying to their parents as the adults return from Liverpool and the Labour Party conference, but if my house was anything to go by when my 2 were at home, it would have been a genuine mix of concern and leg-pulling. Whatever happens at work, for stable family life’, it’s probably best to leave the workplace at the front door if you can. CC Past pupil Will Ballntyne runs an excellent local set of brilliant offices here in Maidenhead, MyWorkPlace, busier than ever because whilst work can of course take place anywhere, being able to separate work from home is essential.

    Here’s the link to the Claires Court SchoolTV Positive Parenting Series. Id recommend you to check out the particular Topic on ‘Respectful Relationships’, covering as it does some great groundwork, if you’re unfamiliar with the subject. The copy is written by experts from the UK and Australia, and I capture some below to give you a flavour of its common sense approach:

    Teaching children to respect themselves and others will open up avenues for both personal growth and academic achievement. Fostering an environment where respect is not just a word, but a practiced behaviour, will empower young people with essential life skills. Effective communication, active listening, and the art of compromise, will provide your child with a solid foundation that will transcend family interactions and help them collaborate effectively with peers, teachers and the broader community.

    The point is with SchoolTV is that’s it’s not a good read – it’s made up of a series of great video clips which can be watched or listened to, quickly and simply – because it is copyright protected, I can’t show clip embedded in my blog, BUT do go look and check out what it has to offer. The worldwide team from SchoolTV are coming to visit us at Claires Court in a week or so. As with so many of the resources we fund and share, such as Going to the Cloud with Google in 2012 or Investing in AI 3 years ago for a safe school-based tool, being early adopters means the lessons we help a service provider gain assists everyone in the longer term. In short, CC knows stuff and we are always keen to share that.

    After the party conferences, Parliament returns and on Tuesday morning, 8 October, James Wilding will be back in Parliament Square, queueing with the Education not Taxation pressure group to attend the House of Commons debate on the same Topic as the Lords 2 weeks ago. All the leaders of the Independent Schools groups have to be very circumspect in dealing with government.politicians, particularly in Parliament can be as rude as they like, but if we ever chose to disrepect a government department, you can be very certain they would not speak to us again! Some groups were very rude when the last government swapped in 2010, only to wait in the Abyss for 14 years before being able to ‘jaw-jaw’ once more. That’s why of course I’ve checked in with SchoolTV on ‘Respectful Relationships‘ – you should do so too!!!

  • Principled views on the Election 4 July 2024

    Following yesterday’s ballot, a Labour government has been elected. As Principals, my brother, Hugh and I know that the result will understandably cause uncertainty for all independent schools directly, and of course for our parents who have placed their children with us at Claires Court. For some time, Labour’s stated intention has been to remove “tax breaks” for our sector by imposing VAT on school fees and, as has already happened in Scotland and Wales, removing mandatory business rates relief from independent schools with charitable status. Because Claires Court does not have charitable status, we pay full business rates so the loss of this relief is already covered. Many independent schools nationally will not be so fortunate.


    I copy below the message sent from Rudi Elliot Lockhart, CEO of the Independent Schools Association (ISA) to all 674 headteachers within ISA, the largest of the associations covering such schools in England.

    “We have a new Government. As we know, it is the stated policy of the Government to impose VAT on school fees and to end business rates relief for schools with charitable status.
    This has been the predominant political issue for the independent sector for a good while and has taken up much of ISA’s work in recent times. Nothing changes in this regard, other than we now have the certainty of a Labour government.

    We will continue to make a positive case for all our schools and the independent sector more widely. We will continue to point out that we believe the Government’s VAT policy is misguided with damaging consequences for many of our schools and their pupils.
    ISA is open to working with whoever is in power. We hope to have a constructive dialogue with the new Government to secure the best educational outcomes for our schools. We are working closely with the Independent Schools Council (ISC) our umbrella organisation, which is also in communication with heads, sharing the work it has done on behalf of the independent sector and its immediate plans.”

    The new Labour government now has to publish the details of their outline proposals, including their consideration of the many unintended consequences to be worked through, together with a timetable for implementation. The King’s Speech on 19 July will contain an outline but the incoming new Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, has said that the policy will be announced in her first Budget (expected in the autumn), and media briefings have suggested implementation is likely to be later in 2025, either aligned to the new tax year (April) or school year (September). In the meantime, whilst ISA and ISC will be directly engaging with the incoming government over the summer period, the Principals and staff at Claires Court will work extremely hard to make sure we mitigate as best we can the harmful effects as they emerge from Labour’s proposals. As best we can, our Principals’ letter to parents at the end of this term next week will cover more in this area should the new government provide further clarity on this matter before then.

  • Out of the frying pan…

    Prime Minister Rishi Sunak called the next general election on Wednesday 24 May 2024, circa 16:26 after a day filled with rumour beforehand. Am I a great fan of the current administration? No. Have I confidence in our current Member of Parliament, Theresa May? Yes, but she is standing down, and we have no idea who is to take her place as MP, because she’s be the only one Maidenhead has ever had. What competition do the Conservatives have in Maidenhead? Well, the Conservatives are in the minority, with the local council being run by a mix of Lib-Dems and Independents. And there’s a thing, because the leadership just made application to the Treasury for exceptional financial support. In short, RBWM is bankrupt, and needs bailing out by central government.

    The council’s perilous position is best described by the local paper, the Maidenhead Advertiser. “The Royal Borough of Windsor and Maidenhead council has been forced to seek ‘exceptional financial support’ from central government to rescue it from its perilous situation, ‘due in large part to historical local and national decisions’ going back many years. Year-on-year reductions to council tax for a period of six years from 2010 have left the council’s budget £30 million lower than if council tax had risen in line with average increases across the country. At the same time, the council’s debt increased from £58.7 million in 2014 to £204 million by March 2023, during the time when Government funding to local authorities was cut by 30 per cent. Reserves in April 2023 were at an un-audited £10m – the lowest known reserves of any unitary authority.“

    There is much I like about local government; suffice it to say that much decision-making is located near where the choices made will have an impact. The trouble is that local government needs to avoid ‘aping’ national government, and that’s where RBWM got things really wrong over time. When George Osborne became Chancellor of the Exchequer in 2010, he called for austerity measures in a country seeking to recover from the 2008 financial crisis. Sadly, both local council leaders, Simon Dudley (2016-19) and his successor Andrew Johnston (2019-2023) chose to pursue a minimalist policy for local rates, keeping the cash costs to local residents for council services at a rock bottom rate. And guess what, if you don’t keep the cash coming in, services suffer and eventually the council can’t actually pay for the minimum services required of it by local people and national government. It’s petty to talk about the loss of our flower-baskets and local gardening services to keep the Town Hall flower beds under control, not so trivial when local police and warden services disappear and frankly a disgrace when the audit controls discover a black hole into which previous years of un-budgeted expenses have been filed.

    By way of example, here’s Cllr Dudley writing a year ago in ‘Conservative Home’ about the unrecognised successes of his period leading RBWM, prior to their dismissal by the electorate:

    “I was a councillor here from 2007 to 2019 (Deputy Leader, Lead Member for Finance in a great team). I was Leader from 2016 to 2019. We held the council in the hard times of the Brexit stalemate of May 2019. Direct comparisons with prior elections (we won four times) are hard because we instigated a boundary review and reduced the number of councillors from 53 to 41 prior to the 2019 “all out” elections. However, in May 2019 we achieved 43 per cent of the vote and 35,999 votes for a Conservative candidate. We held the council by 22 to 19. We did this with a hugely pro-housing agenda. Developing Maidenhead Golf Club (worth around £300 million to the local taxpayer) with a proposed 1,800 new homes (30 per cent of which will be affordable) as part of a Borough Local Plan which was restarted when I became Leader and is now adopted. It would have been hard for us to be seen as less pro-housing, establishing two housebuilding joint ventures, one with Cala Homes (for the golf club) and another with Countryside for regenerating Maidenhead.”

    The reality some 12 months on are really clear to those councillors and public officials left to clear up the mess left by the Conservatives, an oxymoron if ever there was one for the behaviour of those previous politicians (now out of office). As things turn out at the Golf Club, it looks as though the council won’t benefit from the £300 million windfall any more than it did the sale of the old leisure centre to Countrywide for the price of being provided with a new one – the new Braywick Leisure centre cost some £40 million and the old site was devalued from £38 million to… £15 million and still shrinking. The Golf club sale suffers from the similar failure to ‘conserve’ the deal struck. It may be that the golf course land was worth north of £300 million pounds back when the deal was struck (or not, as the reality seems to be). I am told that the arrangements with Cala Homes permits them to claw back from that price all the additional elements that make for building a modern set of homes, schools, doctors and attendant facilities, including pumps for all, bio-net-gain, etc.

    I feel sure by now, dear reader, you’ll wonder why I have entitled this blog as ‘Out of the frying pan…’, and that’s actually because the focus on redeveloping Maidenhead’s town centre and enabling it’s repopulation with residents living ‘in town’ has had a fabulous effect on the local economy, Not only do we have a cherished new Waterside development in the town, but we have become a major attraction across the global corporate world for being a town worth investing in, what with the Elizabeth line, and as Agents Knight Frank wrote last month (22 May) “A key strength of Maidenhead as an office location is its connectivity to its surrounding areas. The transport infrastructure means that London can be reached in as little as 17 minutes via train and is easily accessible via the M4 motorway. Access to a diverse workforce is vital for occupiers and reaching key UK centres within a reasonable journey time. Lifestyle and wellbeing are another of Maidenhead’s strengths. The Chapel Arches, One Maidenhead and Tempo developments have provided the town centre with abundant usable space, including housing, retail, public spaces, food and beverage, and offices. This is key for occupiers, who need to attract and retain talent. Onward, the Nicholson Quarter regeneration will be key in continuing the momentum by providing the space for employers and employees to remain and relocate.“

    So, in short, there have been some major losses locally over the years, lots of change, much to look forward to and a sense that actually we’ve a lot now going in our favour. The pollsters are having a field day, and the changes seen locally last year in the democratic landscape look as though they are to happen across the country too. And it’s not all one way, because Scotland, Nothern Ireland and Wales are also facing seismic change, led as they have been by parties of different hues too. But, it does look as though the mead party next Friday in the Palace of Westminster/House of Commons will be Labour, so here perhaps is the ‘frying pan’.., to watch out for.

    What I fear most from an incoming government under the Labour Party of course is the suggested implementation of a 20% VAT hike on private school tuition fees. With close to a thousand children in my school, the direct impact of such a hike on parents being able to afford us will be considerable. We are a business established for the purpose of offering independent schooling for children aged 2 to 18, we receive no benefits as conferred by charitable status, we pay business rates on our properties and corporation tax on our profit. Those schools that are charities in England are clearly fearful because already taking place in Scotland (2022) has been the removal of rate relief.

    Our parents already pay for education through the taxes they pay, and for many families, we provide only part of the mix they need, where their local state schools can’t offer the benefits we do. What’s so very evident too is that no party of government can translate their promises into the direct action they publish in their manifesto; finding more teachers and doctors in principle sounds easy, but directing them to work in harsh, unmanageable conditions is quite something else.

    School Proprietors remain politically neutral because the education service we offer must provide access to a balanced range of opinions and serve the needs not just of the present, but also ensure we reflect suitably on the past (that covers everything pretty much) and look to the future (almost certainly for most of us, the ‘unknown’). I know that schools are seen as places for fostering critical thinking and exposure to a variety of viewpoints. Such political neutrality helps ensure the curriculum focuses on facts and different perspectives, rather than promoting a specific party line. Moreover, children and young people come from families with diverse political views. Our neutral environment avoids alienating students or creating a sense of pressure to conform to a particular ideology. Parents entrust us with the education of their children. Political neutrality helps ensure that the school’s focus is on academic development, not indoctrination!

    It’s important to note that neutrality doesn’t mean shying away from discussing current events or politics altogether. Our school playgrounds and events can still hold conversations about government, elections, and different political philosophies. Having studied 3 years of Ecology at University, I know how important the environment is, and I also know just how committed some young people have become to resisting climate change. However, my focus as a school academic leader should be on critical analysis and fostering independent thinking, not promoting a specific viewpoint. I’m watching as much of the political discourse in open debates on the TV as time and report reading permits, and I have been more stuck than ever that no-body from any party actually seems to answer the questions posed by the audience.

    There is an old quip, attributed to George Bernard Shaw, that if all the economists were laid end to end, they’d never reach a conclusion. Actually, most economists do think alike as do the neutral public figures I’ve seen on TV and heard on radio – they are asking for the same things, including at the core the rebuilding of trust in our politicians and that they will do the right thing – please read last week’s blog because that’s absolutely the point. Whoever wins next week needs to unite the country, not divide us, bring a common purpose to the fore and, if change is to be wrought, take care and consider the unintended consequences of manifesto promises that actually won’t deliver the benefits suggested!

  • “Doing the Right Thing Right” – There is an even greater good!

    It’s 25 years since I knew I was to lead as Chairman the Independent Schools Association, and it made me concentrate on the ‘Power of words’ spoken as “Calls for Action!” At a time when politics in the UK had stabilised, our military had positively engaged in the Balkan crisis and a new century had been born, I wondered out loud, looking ahead, how things were set to be so fair for the future. In short I had adopted the new millennium positive mindset, carried through for the next 12 years to include Danny Boyle’s great opening ceremony for the 2012 London Olympic Games.

    5 June 2024 saw Claires Court host for the 25th year in succession the ISA London West Athletics Championships at the then newly built Eton College Thames Valley Stadium, built for the use and development of public athletics development in the Thames Valley and beyond. The event has grown from 20+ schools to 32 present today, and from a few schools to many now able to provide teams that cover the entire age range from 8+ to 16+. Circa 1200 athletes participated today, and they demonstrated once again that the limits of human achievement have not yet been reached, establishing new athletic records at this regional level. Deputy Head Co-Curricular, Jo Cox started work on our preparations back in January, engaging 25 Claires Court staff and a considerable number of our own Sixth Form students plus over 100 volunteers from all the other schools so that we could both offer the opportunity to compete and to be selected for the ISA LW team for any of the 106 schools in our region.

    So, just to be clear, a private day school in the Thames Valley has chosen to run on behalf of 106 other schools in the same geographical area a day-long track and field competition, both to give any children chosen the opportunity to run, jump or thrown, and, if they are the best, then swap team shirts and represent our area against the other 6 areas in the nation.

    In 2000, under the then Labour Government, all private schools , either individually or collectively, were invited and included in local, regional and national conversations about how ‘Education, Education, Education’ could be delivered. As the incoming Chair of ISA, I then spent the next 10 years of the Labour Government as an invited and active participant member of ‘thought leadership for Education’ for the nation. ‘Bully for you’ I hear you say. I loved it, of course!

    Over the past 25 years, I have always remained committed to engaging with local, regional and national conversations on Education. If you are a subscriber to my blog, you know that anyway. Below, I describe the rules of the game, the boundaries of our operation and the ‘Faustian pact’ struck by proprietors such as I and the education environment in which we operate, at least in the memory of this headteacher whose service as a school leader is now 41 years old and counting

    Rules of Engagement for Education. Education is not a Business: here’s what Gemini has to say on the matter:

    Profit vs. Public Good: Education is seen as a public good, necessary for a functioning society. Businesses prioritise profit, which can sometimes conflict with educational goals.
    Standardization vs. Individual Needs: Businesses thrive on standardisation and efficiency. Education, however, needs to cater to individual student needs and learning styles.
    Measuring Success: A business might measure success by profit margins. Education success is trickier to define; it could be test scores, graduation rates, or a student’s ability to thrive in the future.
    While education isn’t a business, there is some overlap. For instance, some schools might use business practices for efficiency or fundraising.

    Point 1 The key takeaway is that the core purpose of education differs fundamentally from a business.

    The United Kingdom has been part of the EU from 1 January 1973 until 31 January 2020. Throughout that period, the ground rules for Education have been very clear on the matter of Value Added Tax: In 2020, certain businesses were exempt from Value Added Tax (VAT) in various countries. Here are some common examples of businesses that were VAT-exempt:

    Healthcare services: Hospitals, clinics, and other healthcare providers offering medical services were typically VAT-exempt.
    This includes services provided by doctors, nurses, midwives, physiotherapists, and other healthcare professionals.
    Financial and insurance services: Banking, lending, and other financial services were often VAT-exempt. Insurance and reinsurance services were also generally VAT-exempt.
    Education services: Schools, universities, and other educational institutions providing tuition and related services were usually VAT-exempt.
    Certain cultural and social services: Activities related to culture, sports, and entertainment provided by non-profit organizations were sometimes VAT-exempt. This could include museums, libraries, and similar cultural institutions.
    Supplies of land and buildings: The sale, rental, or leasing of residential or commercial real estate was often VAT-exempt.
    Supplies of investment gold: The supply of investment-grade gold, such as gold bars and coins, was typically VAT-exempt.

    The whole point for Services above as described is that whilst what you do as activities is regarded as non-VATable, you are not able to reclaim spent on goods and services provided for you. The landscape of EDUCATION is not BUSINESS is utterly engraved into that landscape, as is the VAT exempt rule. From 1973 to Summer 2020, that’s been the agreed framework. Honestly, there is so much more in addition embedded in the Public/Private sector shared engagement in Education over decades now, it’s difficult to list them all. Here are some examples from Education alone:

    1. SEN EHCP funding: Parents who choose with the LA and Private school that their child is best placed in the private school have to pay the Private school tuition fees, whatever they are (Element 1); the private school has to cover the first £6000 of additional EHC funding as declared in the plan (Element 2) with the LA ‘topping up’ the final Element 3, as required.
    2. Private schools winning planning permission for new buildings and facilities are required to limit their usage to a very narrow audience, usually just for the children based on the site concerned, so as to limit the use of the facilities and reduce or ameliorate their usage on surrounding neighbours and traffic infrastructure.
    3. As Private schools are not registered for VAT, then they need to ensure their business activities do not exceed £90,000 per annum.
    4. Despite the above, a whole host of activities and government initiatives invite all schools to participate, but private schools cannot benefit from the funds made available for their implementation and realisation.
    5. Whether a private school is a charity or business, it is expected and required to provide public benefit to wider society. So, please take time to properly take this in. My customers of my school, fee payers, have been expected and required to invest in the school already, despite having paid their taxes which cover the cost of a state school place for their children. AND in paying the tuition fees for their children in the school, the excess not used for covering their teaching and learning costs are also to be used for the benefit of future users, who have never invested a penny farthing in the school. Here’s an example from Sport England’s recommendation to our local authority on a small development to provide 3 tennis courts at our Junior school to be built this summer – please bear with me for labouring this point:
    6. For Clarity Sport England’s Position: Sport England raises no objection to the application because it is considered to accord with exception 5 of our Playing Fields Policy and paragraph 103 of the NPPF.
      The absence of an objection is subject to the following condition being imposed the
      local planning authority (LPA) resolve to approve the application:
      Within 6 months of the work commencing on site, a Community Use Scheme
      shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority.
      The Scheme shall include details of pricing policy, hours of use, access by nonschool users management responsibilities and include a mechanism for review.
      The approved Scheme shall be implemented upon commencement of use of the development.
      Reason: To secure well managed safe community access to the sports facility,
      to ensure sufficient benefit to the development of sport and to accord with
      RSS/UDP/LP/LDF Policy **
      If the LPA is minded to approve the application without imposing the above conditions
      then Sport England objects to the application as it is not considered to accord with any
      of the exceptions to our Playing Fields Policy or paragraph 103 of the NPPF.

    June 2024 is election month in the UK (as it seems to be for 50% of the world). The Party most likely according to Pollsters to win the election is the Labour Party, whose manifesto makes it quite clear they wish to move the status of Tuition Fees from exempt to 20%. For everyone in our sector, whether placed by National, Regional or Local Authorities or indeed privately, their fees are to be taxed at 20%. The newspapers and gossip columns have filled their pages with huge volumes of writing, BBC Question time etc. filled the air waves and the latest podcast this last Tuesday afternoon from ‘When it hits the Fan’, led by David Yelland, former editor of the Sun and Simon Lewis, former trouble-shooter for the Queen and Gordon Brown,

    Almost all that written, spoken or broadcast seems to carry copy of the laziest and incompetent kind, not least shaping the sector as being the sole preserve of the elite. There are 2,400 private schools in the UK, with many including membership of the 11,000 day nurseries that cover the Early years Foundation stage. Almost every parent makes use of day nurseries, their places funded by government for some of the hours those parents need. here’s what the DayNurseriesUk had to say in their state of the nation report this April.

    “Nurseries across the UK have faced financial difficulties for some time. A lack of government funding and the Covid pandemic meant that many were forced to close their doors for good. For the nurseries continuing to operate, they continue to face multiple hardships. “the increase in interest rates and 9% inflation predicted for the coming months could spell disaster for many nurseries and childcare providers. Recently released government reports show that last year, half of providers were already only breaking even or making a loss while our research with providers suggests it could be much higher. They suggest that the only way for nurseries to withstand these times is to continue to increase their fees, otherwise they face permanent closure. As the government provides the majority of the funding for early years childcare through funded places for those eligible, nurseries are dependent on the government to increase this funding price to allow for rising costs.“

    The situation for private nurseries is then dire, and whilst there is no chance that the VAT proposed for Private schools will affect the under 4 age range, as most private schools in the 4-11 age range have a nursery, it doesn’t take a genius to work out why Junior schools are unlikely to cope with the imposition of a 20% tax on their tuition fees. Rudi Lockhart, CEO of ISA schools (660 all private, 50% charity, 50% commercial) wrote the following letter to the Times yesterday:

    Point 2. The Labour party’s proposals to imposee VAT on Private education suggest there is the low hanging fruit of easy pickings available, from Wealthy Families who have enjoyed a tax break they don’t deserve and Elite Public Schools whose endowments will ‘mind the gap’ with ease. The reality is that the majority of independent schools number 200 pupils or less, with a nursery that is largely sustained by the ‘whole school’ wrapper that benefits the children across the younger age range. We don’t have anything like enough nursery provision already, nor do we have the spaces in the public sector to readily handle the transition of 50,000 children swapping sectors, and finally nor has the legal landscape been cleared to permit private schools to share their facilities and resources more actively with their communities to raise the missing funds, as planning permissions/development controls have always been allied to the school’s Education status, not that of commercial business.

    The greater good all of us in our sector propose is to ensure the incoming government of whatever hue recommences dialogue with our sector. We have know-how, talent and expertise in abundance; choose to use it as the Blair Government did, and Education, Education, Education will thrive once more.

  • Using AI to write for my blog a call to all adults to vote in the forthcoming UK general election 4 July 2024

    Below you can read how one of the major AI engines can write on my behalf a call to adults to use their vote in the forthcoming general election. I guess I was not the only one caught out by the sudden switch on Wednesday 23 May by Rishi Sunak to call a snap general election.

    The question I asked of ChatGPT was “Using the content of JamesWilding.blog, write me 1000 words to call adults to vote in the next general election 4 July 2024”.

    Over the half-term break, I’ll review below and see what I might have added or changed, so by 31 May, I’ll have an update and some indication of alternative examples that other engines might have suggested from a corpus of work that stretches back over 14 years over the life time of the conservative administration since the demise of the Labour Party.

    On Tuesday 11 June at 12 noon, I am chairing an international discussion on the use of AI in schools, an area of huge interest to me over the past 36 months, more of which anon. Schools and Education more generally have really got to step up and move the dial on from the narrow commitment of the current state just to meet academic criteria and qualifications only. In our work with digital tools over the same period of time, we’ve been able to transform children and adults understanding on how technology can be used for the better, and at the same time, seen an explosion of interest in the co-curricular offer that benefits the growth of children’s well-being and self-confidence.

    So onwards to ‘my call to arms’ to adults to use their vote in the forthcoming general election:
    Your Voice Matters: The Importance of Voting in the July 2024 General Election

    In a democracy, the most powerful tool at your disposal is your vote. As we approach the next general election on July 4, 2024, it is crucial to understand the significance of this fundamental right and why every eligible adult should exercise it. James Wilding’s insightful perspectives on civic duty and the power of individual participation highlight the imperative need for widespread voter turnout. This election is not just another date on the calendar; it is a pivotal moment that will shape the future of our nation. Here’s why your participation is essential.

    1. Upholding Democratic Principles

    The cornerstone of a democratic society is the active participation of its citizens. Voting is not just a right; it is a responsibility that ensures the functioning of democracy. When you vote, you are contributing to the collective decision-making process that governs our lives. The legitimacy of our government is derived from the consent of the governed, and your vote is a crucial part of that consent. By casting your ballot, you affirm the democratic principle that government should be of the people, by the people, and for the people.

    2. Shaping Public Policy

    Every vote has the potential to influence public policy. The representatives we elect make decisions on critical issues such as healthcare, education, the economy, and national security. These decisions have direct impacts on our daily lives and the future of our communities. For instance, consider the policies surrounding public health in recent years. The elected officials who navigated the pandemic response were chosen by voters like you. Your vote can help steer the direction of policies that affect everything from the quality of our children’s education to the safety of our neighborhoods.

    3. Ensuring Representation

    Voting ensures that your interests and concerns are represented in government. When you abstain from voting, you forfeit your chance to influence who represents you at the local, state, and federal levels. This can lead to a disconnect between the needs of the populace and the actions of elected officials. Diverse and comprehensive representation is crucial for addressing the varied needs of our society. Your vote helps ensure that representatives are accountable to all citizens, not just a select few.

    4. Addressing Voter Apathy

    Voter apathy is a significant challenge in modern democracies. Many individuals believe their single vote does not make a difference, leading to low voter turnout. However, history is replete with examples of elections decided by narrow margins. For instance, the 2000 U.S. Presidential election was decided by just a few hundred votes in Florida. Every vote counts, and your participation can be the deciding factor in a close race. By voting, you counteract the trend of apathy and encourage others to do the same.

    5. Empowering Change

    Elections are a powerful mechanism for change. They provide an opportunity to address systemic issues and advocate for progress. If you are dissatisfied with the current state of affairs, voting is a direct way to express your desire for change. Whether it’s advocating for social justice, environmental protection, or economic reform, your vote can help elect leaders committed to these causes. Change begins at the ballot box, and your participation is essential for driving the progress you wish to see.

    6. Reflecting on Civic Responsibility

    James Wilding eloquently reminds us that civic responsibility is a cornerstone of a functioning democracy. Voting is an act of civic duty that demonstrates our commitment to the greater good. It is an expression of our engagement and concern for our community and nation. By voting, we honor the sacrifices of those who fought for this right and ensure that their legacy endures. Civic responsibility is about more than just voting; it is about staying informed, engaging in discourse, and being active members of society.

    7. Educating Future Generations

    When adults vote, they set an example for the younger generation. It teaches the importance of civic engagement and fosters a culture of participation. Young people who see their parents and community members voting are more likely to value and exercise their own right to vote when they come of age. By voting, you contribute to a legacy of active citizenship that will inspire future generations to uphold democratic principles and participate in the electoral process.

    8. Mitigating Disenfranchisement

    There are ongoing efforts in various regions to disenfranchise certain voter groups. By participating in the election, you stand against these attempts and reinforce the importance of inclusive and fair elections. Every vote is a stand against disenfranchisement and a step towards a more equitable society. Ensuring high voter turnout can mitigate the impact of restrictive voting laws and protect the integrity of the democratic process.

    9. Personal Empowerment

    Voting is a means of personal empowerment. It allows you to voice your opinions and preferences, contributing to decisions that affect your life and community. The act of voting is a reminder that you have a stake in the future and that your views matter. This sense of empowerment can inspire further civic engagement and community involvement, leading to a more vibrant and participatory society.

    10. Celebrating Freedom

    Finally, voting is a celebration of freedom. In many parts of the world, people are still fighting for the right to vote. By participating in the election, you honor the freedoms and rights that come with living in a democratic society. It is a celebration of the progress we have made and a commitment to continuing the journey towards a more just and inclusive society.

    Conclusion

    The upcoming general election on July 4, 2024, is a critical opportunity for every eligible adult to exercise their right to vote. Your participation is essential for upholding democratic principles, shaping public policy, ensuring representation, and fostering a culture of civic responsibility. By voting, you contribute to the collective decision-making process that shapes our nation’s future. Your vote is your voice, and every voice matters. Do not let this opportunity pass you by. Make a plan to vote, encourage others to do the same, and be an active participant in the democratic process. Your future, and the future of our nation, depends on it.








  • “vapid happy talk” – No, really…? Gove climb down!

    Apparently, according to a major study by the Sutton Trust reported last month, Independent School applicants for University write better personal statements than their state-sector counterparts.

    Says the BBC “The Sutton Trust says pupils from independent schools are more likely to shine in their “personal statements. It says their applications are generally better written and list more prestigious, relevant activities than those of state-school pupils”.

    This report continues to plough the very unnecessary field covering why can’t the ‘also-rans’ keep up with the ‘Jones’.  The vast majority of our great classical dancers and musicians have come through an elite talent program that lasts for 7-10 years or more, funded by government of all persuasions.  The major things most Olympians have in common are parents and families that will do their best to ensure their children are supported, irrespective of personal cost.  The average age and longevity of our successful athletes indicates this support carries on long into adulthood. At the independent school I run, throughout the child’s time with us, we look at building the personal skills, confidence, competence and considerateness that make them exceptionally well-rounded, contributing school leavers.  For many, it won’t matter what others decide (Uni, employer) because we have given them an internal engine to power their own destiny.

    But stop – just for a moment – because at a time of almost constant crisis for state education, now is not the time to compare between the two sectors.  I spend enough time with heads from both camps to know the following:

    One set (us pwivate peeps) have only to deal with the law of the market place, a raging financial crisis across our client group, but fundamentally a client group (parents as customers, children as consumers) who value us and want to come to school each day.

    The second set (out of proportionally bigger than the pps at 93%-7%) have to deal with a marketplace law that is chaotic at best and irredeemably unfair at worst, a financial and political crisis that strikes to the very heart of DfE and its senior civil servants, and a client group told almost every day that provisions compared with us ‘pwivates’ is beyond the basement worst.

    And the person telling them is their elected Secretary of State – children know nothing, exams are too easy, buildings are condemned as dilapidated, smacking is good, and after 6 months of travail, miLud has yet to determine whether those children downgraded below C are to have their initial grades reinstated.  Confidence in his probity took a further dive this last weekend, when it emerged (as published in the national press) that tax-payers money had funded the inappropriate tweeting by government advisers – read that detail here

    The last 10 days of education news has so much serious educational change highlighted over the next few years that the moving target has become a blur – either that or it has actually disappeared up the minister’s own ego.  Scrap GCSEs, A levels to change, main school curriculum to move from skills to knowledge, and the end of school sport as they know it

    Michael Gove has already said that if he is wrong, on his head be it – http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-20610137 – OK independent and state schools are as of one, as are the select committee and pretty much every university, exam board and teaching union, I feel we should urge Gove to Go, and Go now.

    A Department for Education spokeswoman said (Wednesday 6 Feb) about the new knowledge curriculum: “The core academic subjects most valued by universities and employers are those that make up the EBC. Far from being outdated, this new standard will make sure that all children have a solid foundation for the path they wish to follow.

    Where do the remaining new and fresh, inexperienced DfE people come from (fly-on-the-wall anecdotes says anyone good has long flown the nest) that spout this rubbish.  The Universities mentioned represent those that consider themselves elite, the self-determining Russell Group, and they simply don’t want the arms race to get hotter  – and anyway read what a leading headteacher thinks of that here – http://goo.gl/YwP63.

    Hilda Clarke, Headteacher of the Tiffin school makes it as clear as I could about the apparent wholesale destruction of the artistic landscape. She warned in the Independent Newspaper “if the Group did not speak out strongly – you will have presided over the death of these enriching subjects in schools, ultimately depriving a generation of this country’s young people a balanced, meaningful and fulfilling experience in their most formative years.”

    So the question dear reader is this: is the entire educational landscape that seems lined up against Mr Gove that are wrong, or is our Secretary of State for Education actually drowning in his own hyperbole?  And guess what – breaking news as this article goes to press on Thursday 6 Feb 2013, Mr Gove is cimbing down on the GCSE cancellation…http://goo.gl/4k6if – just as schools have refocussed their children on the EBC core!

    And as our own Independent school simply is even more divorced now from all this state sector nonsense, is it no surprise that our students applying for University of whatever colour actually are confident about what they want to study there and can write a compelling case to support their application?  Yes really!

  • Electing a Who?

    Throughout my adult life, I have always taken the opportunity to vote in Elections, be they local, national or European. But, it must be said, I have found it a bit difficult to find out about the elections that took place today for the new office of Police Commissioner for the Thames Valley Police.  Nothing has come through the letter box, and I have met no-one at the door or in the High street.  In short, it is one of those surprising ballots in which all the candidates are invisible.

    Well that’s no quite right of course, because I have been directed to go on-line to http://www.policeelections.com/candidates/thames-valley/so I have, and once there, I find Six candidates.  Now I am sure they are all really genuine people as well as upright citizens, so I read their short introductions with great interest.  Says the UKIP candidate: “I have absolutely no professional experience with the criminal justice system” – so that’s him out then. Imagine having someone oversee the running of something as large and complex as the TV Police with absolutely no credentials to do so.  I read on: “Regularly work with Victim Support, Probation, Prison Authorities and suspects with addiction and mental health difficulties”.  That’s more like it from the Labour candidate, I think, and yet – what’s the party politics doing here?  Policing is not one that benefits from politics getting in the way, and I feel much the same way once I have read the Tory and Lib Dem manifestos too.   Two Independents have also put themselves forward (at significant cost, £6k a head) are there too – one (the man) is a great wow – read what his blurb says ‘We’re disappointed to report that Geoff Howard has not yet provided an introductory statement to PoliceElections.com.’  Well, clearly I won’t be voting for him then, if he can’t be bothered to even write himself an electoral thumbnail.  Actually (post the event) I find there are a plethora of sites, and Geoff is on some of them.

    And finally, I reach the second Independent candidate, Patience Tayo Awe, and frankly, if I must vote, she’ll get mine, because she makes it clear her work is to be outside politics and she plans ‘to be a viable link between the police and the public’. So, all I have to do is go and vote then.  Easy.

    And yet I can’t and don’t vote.  For the first time, I choose to protest by not participating in a democratic ballot.  My reasons are simple really – since the Coalition government has come to power, it seems to have challenged pretty much every activity and status quo I know, and wobbled it good and proper. Now that might be a good thing in some cases, but to shake in every way, every public service, every well established agency involved with keeping our Society safe and healthy and by doing lower their morale to rock bottom and then some seems to have been way too harsh?  I understand the need for cost savings in these impecunious times, but why then pay £100,000 to pay 1 person to supervise something as complex as a Police Force?  Given that the new single person is to replace a quango of 17 or so previously, I actually believe that such a larger number provided more appropriate democratic links than the 1 unseen & unknown candidate we were offered this time around.  Unless the elected official is extraordinarily able,  and the Police service see the implementation to be a good thing (and they don’t), the whole concept is doomed.  After all, the Police are increasingly concentrating on working together across the regions, to share costs and resources.

    So there you have it; nothing more than a simple, straightforward desire to stand up and say that ‘since I have had not literature through my door, no contact with  a candidate, or with any tiny bit of propaganda to persuade me that this election is a good thing, I choose to vote with my inertia and do nothing’.  A pity really, because in real life I am a push-over for Democracy and all I needed was a reason to vote for something or someone that I could believe in.  Next week I’ll write about how the coalition government are replacing the entire national and local education framework with just one person and a private set of appalling prejudices about Learning. This individual actually is already elected, and of course I mean Mr Michael Gove MP.

  • #purposedu – my reason to go to work!

    I own and lead a full range all-ability school of 1000 pupils, sitting in that part of the eastern Thames Valley known as the Royal Borough of Windsor & Maidenhead. I believe the purpose of education is to provide for fully facilitated learning in all we can do. We plan and build confidence and happiness to a set of rules to guide boys and girls to share, forgive, listen, try, be honest, kind and helpful, and treat others as they would wish to be treated. The ‘Golden rules’ wash through everything we do. They form the foundation for each individual, so that they are caring, respectful, loyal, well-balanced, take responsibility and show integrity. Happiness and Self-worth are essential in the lives of both children and adults, and we try to manage that pupils, parents and staff have an exceptional experience of school, which should indeed be the happiest days of their lives.

    But dig in further and you’ll find we ‘get’ learning’; it’s not just about knowledge and problem solving, essential though these are as skills. We build confident and resilient learners who also inquire, communicate, create, collaborate, reflect, think critically and take risks. And we can’t do this if all we know are subjects, so we play great sport and go outward bound (from a very young age) on both land and water, locally and in wild country. Classrooms can be anywhere, and we have hands-on in our local community, in the great museums of the country or abroad across the globe (in person or virtually). We compete, sing, act, paint, design, dance, make music, and perform at every age level, and such work does not play ‘second fiddle’ to the exam room.

    Our children can graduate from our school at any age for other schools, primary, secondary and 6th Form, and we celebrate those successful departures as openly as we do those that leave having spent their entire lives in our learning establishment, secure in the knowledge that we have always held them as individuals at the core of the choices we helped them make so that they can become their best selves, and often achieving beyond their imaginations.

    I have worked at Claires Court for 38 years; it embodies all that I feel it should, a no-blame culture in which children are able to make imaginative and often extraordinary choices. And our past pupils are in the main the most charming, engaging, generous and successful adults you could wish to meet, and few ever worried about whether they were in a league table or measured and deemed unworthy. Sure they learned to fail, but they got back up again, had another go, gained from their mistakes, became comfortable in their skin and stayed learners far longer than one dares to hope for! I engage in the debate of the purpose of education each day I come to work, I know that perhaps my greatest influence has been to articulate that pupose by modelling the best kind of education for children.
    This Education is one fit for all, whatever their gender, ability, age or circumstance, and continues to give me ‘#purposedu’ each day, and at the age of 58, I know I am the luckiest man alive.

    You can find out more about the Purpos/ed campaign here – http://purposed.org.uk/2012/04/500words-take-2/

     

  • Berlin 2012 – building for the future.

    If things in Education work, they are likely to be repeated, and thus the CCS History department returned once again with a group of Year 11 students over the February half-term.  I have left a week or so before writing about our experiences this year, partly of course because you can read my thoughts already from 2011 – http://goo.gl/ZP3wF and – http://goo.gl/93sG9, and partly because a little bit of distance helps consolidate the lessons learned.  Firstly, you can see the video of the 2012 trip here – http://youtu.be/OU_o30IGwH0 and I’ll post as and when some extra voice-overs have been added.

    More importantly, a trip such as this offers so much, apart from the History enrichment that is so obviously the point of the visit.   I ask you the reader to watch the video and make your own mind up.  Clearly the life skills of working so hard, travelling from one side of Berlin to the other, time-travelling across the decades and dictatorships, and staying balanced on the roller-coaster of emotions generated by stories of the holocaust, cold war and 2 major European conflicts too are worthy of note.  My ‘best bit’ without doubt are the unexpected developments improving the experience, for example the upgrading of the ‘Topography of Terror‘ site from a line of wall boards in central Berlin against the foundations of a ruined building to a full blown research space and Museum gallery indoors.  The way the underground (like ours in the UK) actually does regenerate over the years; no longer the graffiti filled old crates of yesteryear (which looking  at the rest of Berlin is not a habit yet kicked by the populace) but modern, utility trains that do the job in sensible manner.

    And that’s the point of visiting Berlin; built to be a world metropolis in the 19th century, with sewers and blown-air messaging systems to beat the world at their own game, it then suffered more than any other city from the ravages of 2 world wars and a hostile occupation by the Russian military (OK, the allies were there too), and it took the fall of the wall 23 years ago to build the confidence of Western Germany in the city’s population to provoke the changes and developments now visible.  Visiting Berlin is one of the important ways we can show young students that hope can spring eternal; whatever the desperate position the fragility of  world economy now places us all in, for jobs, for prosperity and for hope in the future, there’s no doubt that the physical renewal in Berlin can inspire us all.

    That’s the point too of making films that capture the moments, however amateurishly that might be.  Younger boys and girls in the school do look to the future, are optimistic about their life chances and the way ahead, and express that clearly to us, their teachers in no small measure.  “I can’t wait until I get to go to Berlin” was the chorus that met us during last week, after they had caught up with the ‘broadcast’ on the ‘hub‘.  It is a key difference between our educational experience here for our pupils and elsewhere – over the next two weeks, our Art, History and Geography departments are back out on tour, at the great museums in London and elsewhere too, at farms seeing some happy outcomes of the lambing season as well as further afield on a residential weekend looking at environmental issues at Margham Park.

    My lasting impressions from Berlin 2012 are of the optimism of the Berliners, despite the cold and ice winds from Siberia, there is a great sense of optimism amongst its residents and its ambassadors working with us.  As our guide through the Bunkers said, speaking of the current Euro crisis; “We’ve been though so much over the last 60 years, to have created one currency is part of the great project to feel ‘European’ rather than’German’, and we are not going to let a little local difficulty with the Greek economy get in the way.” Well, I do admire their optimism, which is probably helped by the evening pilgrimage we pay to the Blue Man group, in their purpose built theatre in Potsdammer Platz, and we usually coincide with the Berlin Film festival, so the area feels even more glamorous than usual.  Anyway, if you don’t know what the Blue Man group do, then sit back and enjoy this little sample from their act – I can feel the anticipation already, and that’s certainly a way to build for the future, by putting a smile on your face.