Tag: schools

  • The High Court decision on the TAX change by the Government (part 2)

    Claires Court is one of over 1400 private schools who form part of the Independent Schools Council.

    The ISC Board met on Wednesday, 18 June. Below is the statement that was issued by ISC to all schools at 12 noon the next day. As you can see, the ISC Board has voted not to appeal against the judgment. You can find their explanation below my next 5 paragraphs of commentary.

    My view is that the change in Tax treatment for Tuition fees makes no sense to the parents now having their fees increased, to the school finance offices that now have their work made perhaps 30% more complex so as to treat all the different shades of tax exemption and tax at 0% in order to calculate the tax to be paid to the VAT man and how much to claw back or indeed to the wider education sector that;s not going to see any of the money raised come their way.

    The tax change is causing some great, historic schools to close, and where there are not local state sector alternatives, so the education authority concerned (and there are several) have to work out how they are to fill the gaps. The acceleration in closures has come, 4 last week, and this means that adults and communities have lost work, presence, pride in what they do and loss to local providers, retail and services. Many local authorities have no places for the displaced secondary children, and it was the local authorities that initially begged the government not to impose VAT too early that have to clear up their mess. And that’s more to clear up in addition to the incredible crisis in Special Educational Needs and Education Welfare services.

    The government know that they may have won the specific case but not the deeper argument. There’s no crowing from the specific politicians concerned. 6,500 new teachers are not coming into the state sector, the significant transfer of pupils from private to state means the net cost of education to the government has grown and the madness of suggesting instead that it’s going to help the state to build lots more houses by the Prime Minister makes him look even more foolish.

    For the past 10 years and more, the country has cried out for stable, sensible leadership from the government of the day. Instead, they gave us NHS and Education reform, they gave us Brexit, they’ve even tried to modernise the armed forces and build HS2. I look back to the successes of the London Olympics in 2012, and thanks to the Sutton Trust, we know that 24 of Team GB’s 65 medalists, or 37%, were educated at private schools. We can smile too that Queen Elizabeth (home education), Danny Boyle (Direct Grant) and Daniel Craig (Sixth Form Grammar) all were educated too in a manner this Education Secretary abhors. It’s the very success of the diversity in Education that the United Kingdom offers that has made our education sought after across the world – but sadly, one lesson this government is unlikely ever to learn.

    The judgment in the High Court case, backed by the Independent Schools Council, was handed down last Friday. As you will know by now, the three judges ultimately dismissed the case, alongside two other cases brought by Education Not Discrimination and Christian Concern.

    Since the judgment, the ISC Board has been considering its next steps carefully. There are grounds for appeal, though the advice received by lawyers has been that this would be an uphill battle.

    After careful consideration, the ISC Board has decided against supporting an appeal.

    We felt it was right that this unprecedented tax on education had its compatibility with human rights law tested. However, having now made our arguments in court, we did not wish to put further resource into an appeal that would, in general terms, tread the same ground. Our focus remains on supporting children, families and schools – something we are more easily able to do without the constraints of protracted court proceedings.

    Although the outcome last week was not what had been hoped for, there were nevertheless many positives that ISC will be carrying forward from the judgment, both in public messaging and behind-the-scenes lobbying.

    Independent education is protected

    During the court hearings, government lawyers argued that human rights law did not stop the government from abolishing independent education in its entirety if it wished to (although there was no suggestion this was a current policy position). This assertion was firmly rejected in the judgment, which was clear that human rights law protected the freedom to establish independent schools.

    Children’s rights were affected

    The judgment reaffirmed that the right to independent education is protected under the European Convention on Human Rights (Article 2 Protocol 1), as is the right to non-discrimination (Article 14). It also affirmed that changes to the structure or cost of education can engage these rights. In the case of VAT, the Court found that the policy did interfere with the rights of pupils and, on the face of it,had a discriminatory impact on certain cohorts of pupils. Having reached that conclusion, however, it was ruled that such interference was lawful as it was within the “margin of discretion” that Parliament enjoys when making such policies.

    Challenging inaccurate rhetoric

    Throughout its submissions, the government repeatedly referred to the decision to levy VAT on fees as the abolition of a “tax break”. The High Court described this as more of a slogan than a legal description and chose instead to describe the measure as a “tax change”. This more neutral language strips away what the court described as “presentational” labels, with the focus instead on the substance of the measure and the impact on children and families.

    An acknowledgment of diversity within the sector

    The case considered the circumstances of a wide variety of claimants in different types of independent schools and with very different backgrounds. Two areas of particular concern – provision for children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) and the impact on Charedi Jewish schools – were given serious attention by the judges. Even though the Court did not mandate an exemption for these vulnerable groups, its acknowledgement of them, added to its highlighting of the systemic failures within SEND, validates what many in the sector have been saying for years.

    A framework for holding the government to account

    While the Court accepted that the government’s revenue forecast of £1.5 billion annually was based on a rational process involving the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), it did not delve into whether that analysis was comprehensive as well as rational. ISC will continue to hold the government to account – both publicly and privately – on the claims politicians have made and to challenge them where the rhetoric is not being matched by reality, action or funding.

  • In an era of ‘fake news’ the role of trained and professional journalists has never been more important. Wes Streeting Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, MP for Ilford 

    I will have been one of many millions this week who chose to watch and listen carefully to the Chancellor’s Spring Statement on Wednesday, to glean as best I could what the near and medium term economic future for the country looks like. The pundits reporting on the success or failure of her speech span from “She didn’t spook the markets” through to “If you want to look at a recipe for disaster, that is it.”  Clearly we all wish that Rachel Reeves has got it right, though I know I have to do much more than just keep my fingers crossed!

    My headline this week highlights that, even when in power, politicians make the point about the value of political journalism and the need for some objective review by their parties of what Government says it is currently doing.

    Rather handily, and it does help me make my point quite nicely, on Wednesday our work at Claires Court featured significantly in the Daily Mail in an article written by the distinguished veteran journalist, Robert Hardman. You can read that article here, and with the online version, I also feature with Harry and Amaya, Junior Head Boy and Head Girl, on the lawn at Ridgeway. The interview was two weeks ago which seems a very long time now, given the ongoing pressures emerging as 2,500 independent schools continue to fathom as best they can the morass of consequences from the changes in taxation law, business rates and national insurance contributions streaming in, without a great deal of sense emanating from central and local government. As example of that, read here this week’s letter sent by ISBA and ISC to James Murray, Exchequer Secretary to HM Treasury, MP for Ealing and on BBC Question time last night, https://schl.cc:443/gO.

    Harman’s article is very well written, though the number of schools set to close nationally is now 22 and rising. As a journalist he meets all the criteria that Streeting lists in the quote that leads this blog. The article’s publication arrives just in time as the High Court at the Royal Palace of Justice is to hear the case against the imposition of VAT on education – and the Government’s defence of it – between 1 and 3 April in London.  The action has been lodged by the Independent Schools Council, a parent group, “Education Not Discrimination” and a third group representing faith schools.  The Government is gearing up for a fight, spending tens of thousands of pounds a day to employ four senior barristers (King’s Counsel) to defend their tax, ironically all four privately educated themselves. You can read more about the case here, written up by Tony Perry, the parent who started the battle last spring.

    I copy below some of the passage that relates to Claires Court from the news article, published in the Daily Mail on Wednesday, 26 March.  

    Britain’s longest-serving school head, James Wilding, is a mine of experience whose advice was frequently sought by previous governments of various administrations. A teacher for 50 years and head for 44, he shows me his thoughtful emails to Ms Philipson’s office both before and since the election, asking for an opportunity to explain how the private sector can work more productively with the State. He eventually received a stock ‘thank you for your correspondence’ reply but nothing more.1

    Despite the clear voice I have had on the matters of working with the incoming government for well over 18 months now, it’s not actually diverted my attention from the day job, working in school, engaging with my colleagues and students to maximise the opportunities available to them. At every level over the last 5 days, amazing achievements have occurred, not just #CCMakingHistory for the individuals but collectively and collaboratively engaging with academics, rugby sevens, football tournaments, tennis championships and perhaps above all performing Bugsy Malone at Juniors, the Senior Girl’s dance show and the music making at the Seniors’ concert too. The school’s website and app covers all these successes as the stories break, and Hardman might have actually added more than just Sailing and Tennis to the list of the best things we do! Fast on the heels of the Junior Astro Turf opening, we are seeing the rapid completion of the Sixth Form study pavilion at College in time for the start of the summer term.

    I’ve spoken before, and indeed Hardman refers to this in his article, about the importance of partnerships and collaboration. Over the past few weeks, I’ve been working in depth with the leading performing Arts school out of London, Redroofs School2 here in Maidenhead, to establish a direct link between what we offer in terms of education, and what they offer in terms of Performing Arts. We are both really excited about the possibilities we are creating for the future, and we are introducing such opportunities to start with next term, with Miss Ellie Mayling joining our staff to extend the range of LAMDA opportunities for Juniors and to support our drama and music work. Our longer term plans are to consider the establishment of both BTEC Performing Arts at Sixth Form, and if possible, a Foundation Arts programme beyond Sixth Form to help students prepare for audition for the most competitive assessments of them all – to ArtsEd, GSA, Guildhall,  Mountview and RADA.

    To be in government is clearly the greatest responsibility of them all, and beyond my aspirations certainly. What is important though, if I can misquote Wes Streeting a little, is that “In an era of ‘difficult news’ the role of trained and professional politicians has never been more important.”

    And where their training or experience might fall a little short, they need to consider taking the opportunity now, as David Blunkett, David Milliband, Estelle Morris, Charles Clarke and Ruth Kelly did during their time at the Department of Education to work with our sector. Blunkett and Millband were incredibly talented and committed politicians to the cause of Education. Many of Blunkett’s reforms are still with us, the Literacy and Numeracy hours, his focus on SureStart to raise standards for EYFS and his expansion of Higher Education recognisably attracting many of the most talented students from across the world to the UK. Now Baron Blunkett, he does admit that perhaps the Labour Party’s mistake in office in 1997 was to abolish the Assisted Places scheme, through which children whose families could not afford private school fees could nevertheless be supported by government subsidy to access the opportunities available in such schools. 

    Next week sees the Spring term close, with all the excitement that comes with the forthcoming Easter holidays beyond. The Royal Courts of Justice may spend a very busy three days hearing the arguments for and against the discrimination case brought against the government. As Parliament is sovereign, if the government loses the argument, the Court will send the matter back to Parliament to resolve, and the actions required to align two centuries and more of education legislation setting it apart from government influence (and thus exempt from taxation) will take some sorting out. In the meantime, this seasoned, trained and professional school Principal will do his best to ensure that Claires Court children and young people continue to flourish, making the most of all the opportunities they can.

    1 During the Blair-Brown years, both DfE and the Labour government genuinely lived out the ‘Education, Education, Education’ mantra. Over this 12 year period, I was regularly invited to work with the government of the day, representing ISA in my capacity from time to time as the National Chair of our Association, the Chair of Inspections and the Chair of Professional Development. We were asked to contribute in every way we could to partnerships and cross-sector collaboration, and yet despite this ‘cost’ we were given complete respect by Labour politicians then in power.

    2 Claires Court Alumni whose skills in Performing Arts were honed at Redroofs include Gary Russell (70s), Adam Stafford (80s), Lee Martin (stage name Mathieson – 90s), Allie Bastien (00s) to name but 4. 

  • Proprietorial governance in times of change

    All Independent Schools exist by permission of Parliament, and are responsible to the DfE for meeting what are known as the 8 Regulatory Standards (the regs) covered by the 2019 Guidance plus a plethora of policies for which we are to have due regard. Ultimately, individual proprietors are responsible for ensuring standards are met. Where the ‘owner’ is replaced by a Governing Body, it still remains for the new proprietor (the board) to take responsibility, an incredibly important protection for the Heads and their staff.

    As proprietors, my brother Hugh and I also choose to be key workers in the school, covering administration and academics respectively, hence the titles Administrative and Academic Principals. It is required of us to ensure that the school’s leadership has the necessary skills and resources to enable the heads and colleagues to meet both the regs AND the aims, key values and offers of the school. We choose to employ professional experts who advise the school in matters of governance covering law, accountancy, finance & pensions, alongside visiting consultants who bring their insights in academic, health & safety, safeguarding, planning & building areas to complete (and complement) the knowledge and experience the Principals have gained over their 40+ years in post.

    The evolving landscape of single-sex education in the UK is governed by DfE guidance, and where secondary schools choose to offer single-sex education because of the clear benefits for both girls and boys, we are required to provide comparable facilities and opportunities for both genders. As a consequence, the significant building investments in facilities including the refurbishment of both main secondary teaching wings, the provision of new Design & Technology, Food & Nutrition, and computer science classrooms concludes with the construction of new music and fitness centres this summer. To have completed this work within the 3-year time period has been a significant achievement for all involved.

    Regulations keep moving, and most UK readers will have seen the immense fuss being created by the increasing poor attendance in the state sector across the country. Claires Court is required to report attendance information to RBWM and then DfE, and today’s figure shows that in the year to date, we are @94.6%  which, as we’ve been midst ‘of winter bugs, Covid and all sorts’, is on target to be 95% or more (5* performance). Thank you, parents & guardians, you’ve done your bit, and well done to our nurses too for offering that professional yet sympathetic voice and diagnosis when appropriate. It is interesting too to see the public discourse on the mobile phone ‘good/bad dialogue’; the issue is well managed in many schools (handed into school for safekeeping during the day for under 15s).  Screen time on scrolling clickbait videos and interpersonal relationships connected via social media are the current generational problems after hours (and not just for teenagers). Whilst we can’t prevent phone access at home, the school’s provision of secure, protected Chromebooks for 12+ years now is a remarkable success story for CC.

    One of the advantages of my age and experience is that as well as serving on national and regional ISA Headteacher groups, I get asked to connect with some of the people with power and influence who are or may be driving public policy. Yesterday, I met up with Professor Francis Green, a social economist at UCL, whose work led to the Labour Party’s manifesto promise to levy 20% VAT on all private school fees. I spent a useful hour with the Professor, and he has taken the point that policymakers and those impacted need to meet to consider the outcomes of the policy now its negative impact on private school viability is becoming more visible. 

    Later yesterday and still in London, I met as part of the Association’s Equality, Diversity and Inclusion committee in the offices of the Independent Schools Council, a really forward-thinking group who are well ahead of the government on assessing the impact of policy and the provision of successful education in England and informed by colleagues working elsewhere in Europe and the USA. 

    A good finish to the day was to return to school to attend the Juniors Parents evening to 6 pm and then the Senior Boys event to 8 pm. Genuinely it is with great pleasure that I ‘man the tea urn’ and catch up with parents, and it’s always good to hear how we are doing, ‘what’s going well’ and ‘even better if!’ What made the day perfect was catching this video from broadcaster and commentator, Ana Boulter, whose leading mission right now is to assist the government in changing its policy on VAT, and to use the authority of senior headteachers in the country to make her case. As Boulter proposes Wilding and Birbalsingh to share the job of sorting out education for the private and state sectors, I thought, dear reader,  to draw it to your attention… 

    These are indeed times of change, yet ‘twas ever thus, and as the header, this week shows the early spring sunshine rising over Claires Court fields circa 7.45 am, we do need to look to the future and make sure our well-laid plans are realised for the benefit of pupils, parents and teachers. After half-term, I’ll be publishing the outcomes from the Parents Questionnaire 2025, and of course, will be inviting parents and guardians to offer their insights to aid our direction for 2026-2030. We couldn’t possibly have guessed Covid 19, Austerity and a Labour Government this time 5 years ago – does anyone have a crystal ball that works a bit better now?

  • Academic Principal’s notes – 31 January 2025 

    In my closing messages at the end of last term, I was delighted to share with you the Principal’s Court Report, covering the last two years formally highlighting some key milestones and achievements. If you missed the link to the digital report, you can find that here, and if you would like a hard copy, please pick one up from the school office or the check-in desks at any of the forthcoming parents’ evenings. 

    I also wrote the following:

    If there is One Thing you can do for Claires Court over the break…It’s to pass on in your friendship groups and communication channels just how positive our school remains about the future ahead for our children. The Carol services at the end of term were true celebrations of how we collaborate and how musical and choral scholarship continues to grow across the years. All the many plans we continue to develop have your children at the heart of why we come to work and what we do. As we highlighted in our previous communication, we will continue to work on business efficiencies, develop further our existing relationships and work on new out-of-school partnerships to bring additional revenue in too. 

    Firstly, thank you for your ongoing recommendations and introductions of new families and pupils to the school; we have welcomed many new joiners from Juniors to Seniors last term and have registered more to join in the summer term and beyond.   

    Taking into account the increased pupil numbers , together with the scheduled business efficiencies we continue to make and plan for the future, , the Principals do not want to increase fees for September 2025. However, whilst we intend to offer the current school fees for September 2025, we have to remain very cautious.   -One of the elements to consider when evaluating is that the Chancellor of the Exchequer gave no prior warning to business about the tax hikes she introduced at her last budget; the current media speculation is that further tax changes are inevitable.  The Chancellor is set to make her Spring Statement on 26 March and we will update you further over the Easter break. 

    We do draw heart though that the Law Lords have decided that an early hearing of the legal challenge to the Government’s VAT on fees policy is required. This will take place in the High Court between 1 and 3 April. Lord Pannick KC, representing the six families who brought the claim, supported by the Independent Schools Council (our trade body), will claim the introduction of the tax on fees impedes access to education at independent schools and is incompatible with the right to education as per Article 2 of the First Protocol of the European Convention on Human Rights. Lord Pannick will also argue the policy infringes Article 14 of the Convention because it causes unnecessary and discriminatory harm to certain categories of children. Throughout the country, state and independent schools are providing the evidence Lord Pannick needs to support the case being presented, made even stronger by the bizarre benefit (announced this week) being given to the US military to benefit from VAT-free fees, but not permitted to our own military or those European families choosing to use their own nations’ schools based in the UK. 

    As Academic Principal, I have remained at the forefront of the campaign ‘Education not Taxation’ group. I find the rhetoric regarding the fact that schools enjoyed a tax loophole disingenuous. The imposition of VAT is a new tax levied on private schools and state further education colleges. In addition, all charity schools are affected by the additional loss of 80% business rates relief, though as Claires Court already pays both corporation tax and full business rates, we’ve factored these into our costs previously. These changes, coupled with the increase in employers’ National Insurance contributions are clearly causing considerable damage across the private school sector, and we can but feel great sympathy for the families of schools now forced to close, such as Highfield Prep School here in Maidenhead and its sister in Belsize Park, The Village School for Girls. These changes have also seriously impacted both Eton End School in Datchet and High March School in Gerrards Cross, which have changed ownership structures as a consequence. 

    Through this active work, I’ve connected with Ana Boulter, BBC presenter through her active campaigning against the new tax. If you have not discovered Ana’s channel, please do check her out here – https://www.youtube.com/@anaboulterTV.. Next week I am working in the ISC buildings with our Association on allied matters, and also meeting with one of the Labour Party’s strongest supporters of this policy, Professor Frances Green, UCL. It’s only by working such hard yards that we can seek to open up the Government to discuss more openly the negative aspects of this policy. Parliament is alive with discussions in both Houses, and our sector is getting much more cross-party support for the great work we do for education in the UK and worldwide. 

    And finally – looking forwards… Monday 3 February Building works commence for the installation of a new pavilion to provide the central examination space for the Sixth Form during public examinations from May to July, as well as a recreation and study area for their use from September onwards. The schematic below shows the artist impression of the building view from the playing field:

    February Half-term Our official sign-off of the new Food Technology facility by Modual Aspects takes place, with their attention switching to the installation of the new Music School scheduled for Summer 2025. 

    Friday 7 March Save the Date – the Claires Court PTA AGM followed by the Official Opening of our MUGA at CCJ – timings to follow.

    Our PTA President, Phyllis Avery MBE will be leading the AGM during the school lunch break, sandwiches for all attendees, with reports from the various sections and elections for next year’s officers. After the AGM, we are delighted that our various talented sports stars across the school are to demonstrate their skills to the full, officiated by Steve Rider, Sports Commentator and great friend of  ours.

    I  hope parents and guardians are able to join us for the PTA AGM, to learn of the major new projects we have received contributions to commence, and to celebrate the amazing support our Trustees and PTA Chairs bring to these fundraising efforts for the school. 

    Dolly Parton is not perhaps the most likely person I should quote when completing my notes to parents, but “The magic is inside you, there ain’t no crystal ball” hits the consciousness smack between the eyes. When I see what’s happening all around the school and beyond and through the magic of the school‘s App, Claires Court’s students and staff are showing their magic everywhere, in the classroom, on the playing fields and on the water, in the wider community and at international conferences and presentations. If you don’t have the App yet, please download it – there’s a reminder by the hour of us #CCMakingHistory.

  • “The longer I live, the more convinced am I that this planet is used by other planets as a lunatic asylum.” – George Bernard Shaw

    A NotebookLM discussion on this blog can be found here: https://schl.cc:443/gz

    The header picture this week shows the ‘beautiful disaster’ that was the Musk SpaceX Starship coming down over the Gulf of Mexico America last Thursday. Characterising any weekly blog by a suitable title that captures the news headlines of the moment and translates for a local audience is really difficult, made especially so the declaration of a ceasefire in Gaza over the weekend, then Monday commencing as it did with the spectacular show that was Donald Trump’s inauguration and the week progressing with the local politics of Britain and Europe being as fractious as ever. It’s a wonder that the Universe has actually tried to remind us that seeking some alignment across the world of humanity’s problems might be a good idea, and so has given us the night sky spectacular of a 6 ‘planetary parade’ as a reminder.

    So down to Education business this week. Leaving aside the immediate and ongoing dispute between the Government’s imposition of an unfair new tax being imposed on private school tuition fees, I bring to the fore the parliamentary work commencing around the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill, introduced on 17 December, now being examined by parliamentary committee since Tuesday, and it’s quite clear from every point of view that the bill is not going down well. Headteacher Katherine Birbalsingh’s letter in the Observer summed-up the problem from her state-side position brilliantly, with each section including the question “What problem were you trying to solve”. You can read the whole 4 pages of her letter here, in which she highlights the genuine good news available in schools that the government could be celebrating, yet it chooses to legislate against.

    In summary, funding special opportunities in state schools to study Latin is a great idea, as is establishing ‘Computing hubs’ so why cut the funding halfway through the academic year and close the courses. Giving state schools the freedom to tweak the curriculum to encourage diversity and creativity to suit their intake works really well, so why forbid that and impose a strict, universal diet on all? Across England, we are currently working through and embedding the curriculum changes implemented 5 years ago, at a great cost in time and money. As a consequence, we’ve seen our primary and secondary outcomes rise up the international league tables and for reading literacy the English lead the Western world. Why spend precious energy, political capital and parliamentary time on destroying the reforms that led to this success? Across the country, the government programmes to recruit graduates into the teaching profession are failing, yet the school-based programmes have been a great success, so why forbid them to continue or try to reduce teacher pay? We know state school attendance has become a real problem, but the best schools use uniforms, badges, ties and kits to create a sense of belonging and value – why forbid such well-understood strategies, used so well by sports teams etc.?

    Regular readers of my Blog know I’ve been offering the Secretary of State help for 18 months now, even when she was in opposition. Phillipson apparently has booked now an opportunity for KB to meet at the DfE, but that’s a ‘show reaction’ to the bad press she’s received in recent weeks. For the government, the press is only going to get worse, with Secretary of State for Health, Wes Sweeting wishing to shut down SEND funding for children with both physical and learning differences, and the HMRC insisting on taxing SEND tuition fees as shown on invoices, with Local Authorities in return refusing to repay schools for the ‘tax lost’, because they’ve already gone down the route of giving personal budgets to parents, which of course were always ‘without VAT’. Because I know that no-one in government will read letters, I’ve taken to ‘vlogging’, my latest on this issue can be found below:

    The Rt Hon Bridget Phillipson MP attended BETT2025 this week on Wednesday, at the same time as my colleague Jawad Laouira, Deputy Head Academic at Juniors, where Meryln Mind (an American AI company that Claires Court has been working with for 3 years) were showcasing their latest offering, Merlyn Origin, for which Jawad and ICTteacher/school photographer, Chris Rowan created this intro film. Well, the film was incredibly well received and a packed Tech-in-Action audience of educators from many different countries were able to question Jawad and the rest of the panel, including VP Merlyn Jason Mayland and UK Partner, Ian Nairn. The message that the panel shared was that there is a real depth of Learning Science behind what Merlyn is helping teachers achieve in their classrooms and in addition Merlyn saves teachers circa 15% of time every lesson. We’ve also found our children are able to interact directly by voice with Merlyn, and as a consequence, we are seeing a direct improvement in the accuracy of their oral questioning. Wins all round.

    My closing message to this blog is pretty obvious really. When GBS originally wrote of the Lunatics, that was well before I was born. I can’t find a precise date, but we are talking about the time of the rise of the fascist dictators in Europe and the chaos that brought. Despite all, humans managed to develop antibiotics, modern conveniences such as the Hoover, the motor car, and above all of course, Sliced Bread, packaged and promoted in the UK as early as 1928! I’ve loved watching the latest series of ‘Inside the Factory’ on BBCTV, with Paddy McGuiness. The Warburton’s loaf factory in which he used to clean the machines at the start of his employment packs 1.4 million loaves a year. That’s progress for sure, and as a nation, our food is secure through major companies doing what they know best. Paddy like me worries about his children, and I just wish Bridget would work with major schools like mine – of course, we are always ready to learn, but we do start from a very strong position of knowing what we do.

  • Academic Principal’s half-term report ♦ part 2

    As part 1 of the half-term report published at the start of half-term emphasised, the School has been in great heart to date, and the various activities, Holiday Club and trips away at half-term have gone really well. Whilst you can read and see the news stream on our website or via other social media, please consider loading the Claires Court app directly onto your device which carries our news as it is made. I have some immediate good news to report to our junior parents, with a temporary car park being installed on Tuesday 5 November in the overflow area by the sports hall, accompanied by regular road sweeping twice a week. Hopefully, this will keep the area clear of mud and grime.

    This week’s budget on Wednesday confirmed the imposition of VAT on private school fees from 1 January 2025. Chancellor Reeves has not minced her words, and she clearly doesn’t care what people think of her policy choices. Since every business has been affected in some way by the major changes to taxes and national insurance imposed from January and April, I won’t plead any special cases in this update. The Independent Schools Council (ISC) and its constituent school associations have agreed to take legal action to challenge this measure, and you can read that statement here. ISC expects the case to proceed quite rapidly, initially at the King’s Bench, and will receive much press interest.

    The HM Treasury response to the recent consultation was published on Wednesday to coincide with the Budget announcement, 44 pages in all which our associations will check through over the next 4 days before publishing wider advice to schools in our sector. As of 30 October, Claires Court is one of about 2,500 schools now required to register for VAT, a process that normally takes between 6 to 8 weeks. As we cannot conduct VAT business until we have our VAT number, it’s difficult to imagine a more chaotic, ill-planned set of rule changes, expecting all to be settled down in time for 2025. If as parents, you receive any media interest about VAT and tuition fees, please let me know (jtw@clairescourt.net); most of the time I will share such commentary with Sarah Cunnane, head of comms at ISC, but you can directly email her as well sarah.cunnane@isc.co.uk.

    Having HM Treasury’s final guidance does mean we can now complete our impact and risk assessments as well as recovery plans for past and current VAT spending, as well as work through what the implementation pathway looks like for fee-paying parents, with formal publication of invoices required after 1 January 2025. Our finance department will liaise closely with parents, with information forthcoming in coming days. Please do not think that either my brother or I are complacent about this matter because we are not. As with so many other schools in the area and now wider business concerns particularly in Health, Care and Hospitality (because of the change in National Insurance contributions), we will be examining everything we can do to keep costs down.

    We find ourselves in very good company in terms of our resistance to the mendacious and deceptive approach the Labour Party has taken since forming government at the beginning of July. The diplomatic row that has erupted between the UK and other European nations whose embassy children are educated here in schools their country funds is really serious, with Prime Minister Starmer’s wish to improve relations with the EU now in jeopardy. And it is quite clear that whatever money is raised won’t feed into local state school budgets anytime soon; as the Secretary of State for Education’s email to me and all headteachers in England made clear on Friday, the crisis in SEND, school building disrepair and pay settlements is such that other developments are going to have to wait their time. Our sector genuinely wishes to play its part in the recovery and growth of the country’s economy. We contribute massively to the respect the world has for the British education system, and we do hope that even at this late stage, reason is possible.

    Further and Higher Education now find themselves in the same place as our sector, with new and unforgiving taxation further damaging their financial viability. However, it is quite clear that employers more generally and farmers in particular across the country face similar challenges. Apparently, this is the mandate the new government feels they were given at the election; there is sufficient national press coverage of business and wider societal reaction disagreeing with their judgment without my adding to the ‘noise’. In this part 2 report, I do wish nevertheless to make clear that Claires Court will continue to provide the amazing opportunities that you as our parents ask us to make available for your children.

    The many and various infrastructure improvements planned for the half-term have proceeded at pace, involving flooring, decorating, electrical and builders everywhere, and the site/cleaning teams have made particular efforts to ensure we are good to go for the next half up to Christmas. The senior boys are already making good use of the new Food Tech Studio in advance of its official opening on Monday 18 November by chef Wesley Smalley who runs the amazing Seasonality Restaurant in Queen Street. Wesley has been a familiar face at school for a while, helping with our ‘Futurechef’ activities and associated skills. With the Multi-User-Games-Area (MUGA) due to open for use to follow shortly thereafter, we’ll keep the good news flowing!

    James Wilding

    Academic Principal

    3 November 2024

  • “Doing the Right Thing Right” – There is an even greater good!

    It’s 25 years since I knew I was to lead as Chairman the Independent Schools Association, and it made me concentrate on the ‘Power of words’ spoken as “Calls for Action!” At a time when politics in the UK had stabilised, our military had positively engaged in the Balkan crisis and a new century had been born, I wondered out loud, looking ahead, how things were set to be so fair for the future. In short I had adopted the new millennium positive mindset, carried through for the next 12 years to include Danny Boyle’s great opening ceremony for the 2012 London Olympic Games.

    5 June 2024 saw Claires Court host for the 25th year in succession the ISA London West Athletics Championships at the then newly built Eton College Thames Valley Stadium, built for the use and development of public athletics development in the Thames Valley and beyond. The event has grown from 20+ schools to 32 present today, and from a few schools to many now able to provide teams that cover the entire age range from 8+ to 16+. Circa 1200 athletes participated today, and they demonstrated once again that the limits of human achievement have not yet been reached, establishing new athletic records at this regional level. Deputy Head Co-Curricular, Jo Cox started work on our preparations back in January, engaging 25 Claires Court staff and a considerable number of our own Sixth Form students plus over 100 volunteers from all the other schools so that we could both offer the opportunity to compete and to be selected for the ISA LW team for any of the 106 schools in our region.

    So, just to be clear, a private day school in the Thames Valley has chosen to run on behalf of 106 other schools in the same geographical area a day-long track and field competition, both to give any children chosen the opportunity to run, jump or thrown, and, if they are the best, then swap team shirts and represent our area against the other 6 areas in the nation.

    In 2000, under the then Labour Government, all private schools , either individually or collectively, were invited and included in local, regional and national conversations about how ‘Education, Education, Education’ could be delivered. As the incoming Chair of ISA, I then spent the next 10 years of the Labour Government as an invited and active participant member of ‘thought leadership for Education’ for the nation. ‘Bully for you’ I hear you say. I loved it, of course!

    Over the past 25 years, I have always remained committed to engaging with local, regional and national conversations on Education. If you are a subscriber to my blog, you know that anyway. Below, I describe the rules of the game, the boundaries of our operation and the ‘Faustian pact’ struck by proprietors such as I and the education environment in which we operate, at least in the memory of this headteacher whose service as a school leader is now 41 years old and counting

    Rules of Engagement for Education. Education is not a Business: here’s what Gemini has to say on the matter:

    Profit vs. Public Good: Education is seen as a public good, necessary for a functioning society. Businesses prioritise profit, which can sometimes conflict with educational goals.
    Standardization vs. Individual Needs: Businesses thrive on standardisation and efficiency. Education, however, needs to cater to individual student needs and learning styles.
    Measuring Success: A business might measure success by profit margins. Education success is trickier to define; it could be test scores, graduation rates, or a student’s ability to thrive in the future.
    While education isn’t a business, there is some overlap. For instance, some schools might use business practices for efficiency or fundraising.

    Point 1 The key takeaway is that the core purpose of education differs fundamentally from a business.

    The United Kingdom has been part of the EU from 1 January 1973 until 31 January 2020. Throughout that period, the ground rules for Education have been very clear on the matter of Value Added Tax: In 2020, certain businesses were exempt from Value Added Tax (VAT) in various countries. Here are some common examples of businesses that were VAT-exempt:

    Healthcare services: Hospitals, clinics, and other healthcare providers offering medical services were typically VAT-exempt.
    This includes services provided by doctors, nurses, midwives, physiotherapists, and other healthcare professionals.
    Financial and insurance services: Banking, lending, and other financial services were often VAT-exempt. Insurance and reinsurance services were also generally VAT-exempt.
    Education services: Schools, universities, and other educational institutions providing tuition and related services were usually VAT-exempt.
    Certain cultural and social services: Activities related to culture, sports, and entertainment provided by non-profit organizations were sometimes VAT-exempt. This could include museums, libraries, and similar cultural institutions.
    Supplies of land and buildings: The sale, rental, or leasing of residential or commercial real estate was often VAT-exempt.
    Supplies of investment gold: The supply of investment-grade gold, such as gold bars and coins, was typically VAT-exempt.

    The whole point for Services above as described is that whilst what you do as activities is regarded as non-VATable, you are not able to reclaim spent on goods and services provided for you. The landscape of EDUCATION is not BUSINESS is utterly engraved into that landscape, as is the VAT exempt rule. From 1973 to Summer 2020, that’s been the agreed framework. Honestly, there is so much more in addition embedded in the Public/Private sector shared engagement in Education over decades now, it’s difficult to list them all. Here are some examples from Education alone:

    1. SEN EHCP funding: Parents who choose with the LA and Private school that their child is best placed in the private school have to pay the Private school tuition fees, whatever they are (Element 1); the private school has to cover the first £6000 of additional EHC funding as declared in the plan (Element 2) with the LA ‘topping up’ the final Element 3, as required.
    2. Private schools winning planning permission for new buildings and facilities are required to limit their usage to a very narrow audience, usually just for the children based on the site concerned, so as to limit the use of the facilities and reduce or ameliorate their usage on surrounding neighbours and traffic infrastructure.
    3. As Private schools are not registered for VAT, then they need to ensure their business activities do not exceed £90,000 per annum.
    4. Despite the above, a whole host of activities and government initiatives invite all schools to participate, but private schools cannot benefit from the funds made available for their implementation and realisation.
    5. Whether a private school is a charity or business, it is expected and required to provide public benefit to wider society. So, please take time to properly take this in. My customers of my school, fee payers, have been expected and required to invest in the school already, despite having paid their taxes which cover the cost of a state school place for their children. AND in paying the tuition fees for their children in the school, the excess not used for covering their teaching and learning costs are also to be used for the benefit of future users, who have never invested a penny farthing in the school. Here’s an example from Sport England’s recommendation to our local authority on a small development to provide 3 tennis courts at our Junior school to be built this summer – please bear with me for labouring this point:
    6. For Clarity Sport England’s Position: Sport England raises no objection to the application because it is considered to accord with exception 5 of our Playing Fields Policy and paragraph 103 of the NPPF.
      The absence of an objection is subject to the following condition being imposed the
      local planning authority (LPA) resolve to approve the application:
      Within 6 months of the work commencing on site, a Community Use Scheme
      shall be submitted to and approved in writing by the Local Planning Authority.
      The Scheme shall include details of pricing policy, hours of use, access by nonschool users management responsibilities and include a mechanism for review.
      The approved Scheme shall be implemented upon commencement of use of the development.
      Reason: To secure well managed safe community access to the sports facility,
      to ensure sufficient benefit to the development of sport and to accord with
      RSS/UDP/LP/LDF Policy **
      If the LPA is minded to approve the application without imposing the above conditions
      then Sport England objects to the application as it is not considered to accord with any
      of the exceptions to our Playing Fields Policy or paragraph 103 of the NPPF.

    June 2024 is election month in the UK (as it seems to be for 50% of the world). The Party most likely according to Pollsters to win the election is the Labour Party, whose manifesto makes it quite clear they wish to move the status of Tuition Fees from exempt to 20%. For everyone in our sector, whether placed by National, Regional or Local Authorities or indeed privately, their fees are to be taxed at 20%. The newspapers and gossip columns have filled their pages with huge volumes of writing, BBC Question time etc. filled the air waves and the latest podcast this last Tuesday afternoon from ‘When it hits the Fan’, led by David Yelland, former editor of the Sun and Simon Lewis, former trouble-shooter for the Queen and Gordon Brown,

    Almost all that written, spoken or broadcast seems to carry copy of the laziest and incompetent kind, not least shaping the sector as being the sole preserve of the elite. There are 2,400 private schools in the UK, with many including membership of the 11,000 day nurseries that cover the Early years Foundation stage. Almost every parent makes use of day nurseries, their places funded by government for some of the hours those parents need. here’s what the DayNurseriesUk had to say in their state of the nation report this April.

    “Nurseries across the UK have faced financial difficulties for some time. A lack of government funding and the Covid pandemic meant that many were forced to close their doors for good. For the nurseries continuing to operate, they continue to face multiple hardships. “the increase in interest rates and 9% inflation predicted for the coming months could spell disaster for many nurseries and childcare providers. Recently released government reports show that last year, half of providers were already only breaking even or making a loss while our research with providers suggests it could be much higher. They suggest that the only way for nurseries to withstand these times is to continue to increase their fees, otherwise they face permanent closure. As the government provides the majority of the funding for early years childcare through funded places for those eligible, nurseries are dependent on the government to increase this funding price to allow for rising costs.“

    The situation for private nurseries is then dire, and whilst there is no chance that the VAT proposed for Private schools will affect the under 4 age range, as most private schools in the 4-11 age range have a nursery, it doesn’t take a genius to work out why Junior schools are unlikely to cope with the imposition of a 20% tax on their tuition fees. Rudi Lockhart, CEO of ISA schools (660 all private, 50% charity, 50% commercial) wrote the following letter to the Times yesterday:

    Point 2. The Labour party’s proposals to imposee VAT on Private education suggest there is the low hanging fruit of easy pickings available, from Wealthy Families who have enjoyed a tax break they don’t deserve and Elite Public Schools whose endowments will ‘mind the gap’ with ease. The reality is that the majority of independent schools number 200 pupils or less, with a nursery that is largely sustained by the ‘whole school’ wrapper that benefits the children across the younger age range. We don’t have anything like enough nursery provision already, nor do we have the spaces in the public sector to readily handle the transition of 50,000 children swapping sectors, and finally nor has the legal landscape been cleared to permit private schools to share their facilities and resources more actively with their communities to raise the missing funds, as planning permissions/development controls have always been allied to the school’s Education status, not that of commercial business.

    The greater good all of us in our sector propose is to ensure the incoming government of whatever hue recommences dialogue with our sector. We have know-how, talent and expertise in abundance; choose to use it as the Blair Government did, and Education, Education, Education will thrive once more.

  • “I’ve got a feeling we’re not in Kansas anymore.” – Dorothy to Toto in the Wizard of Oz

    One of the most brilliant films I saw early in my childhood was the re-released film “The Wizard of Oz” (originally 1939). Put simply, in a world that was still largely black and white, TV absolutely and a lot of film too, the extraordinary and lavish nature of Oz was something else and genuinely transported us all into a mystical world, in which it must be said, not all was good.

    The phrase “I’ve got a feeling we’re not in Kansas anymore” has developed a different meaning since Oz has become a universal feature of life, a way in which we as adults can fret a little that the world we were born and brought up in doesn’t actually make sense. That helpful utility Quora says it straight:

    As this is a blog with an educational slant, I’ll fess up that it was receipt of an urgent email from the DfE on Monday last directing me to check a host of ‘Do Now’ activities to ensure school was ready to return to work this summer term that has moved me to go political. Now the email was not personal to CC but a generic message to the whole of the School Sector – “Update to all education and childcare settings and providers”. You can read that here if you want to see what I mean. Please don’t though, because I am just using this penultimate message received last week to illustrate the point that “The DfE does not run schools”! 4 days later, another message from DfE arrived, a start of term card from the Secretary of State for Education, the Rt Hon Gillian Keegan highlighting the need for schools to improve attendance, celebrated the arrival of additional nursery places for 2 year olds, invited all Headteachers to join her for a live broadcast chat last Wednesday and finally, highlighting the need for Headteachers to remember ‘Thank a Teacher’ day.

    Call me an old cynic if you like, but the reality 2 weeks later is that Independent Schools simply are not permitted to comply with the government’s wishes to share attendance data, the video link to Gillian’s Keegan was unwilling to be found as were the funds for the additional nursery places and finally, I really don’t know of a headteacher that doesn’t thank their teachers every day – we need to do just that, as the profession is under incredible pressure over the country because the teaching role has expanded so massively to include almost full wrap-around responsibility for everything to do with children plus engagement with a bureaucracy imposed on schools by the government over the past 14 years which has exploded beyond reason. It’s almost impossible to overstate just how complex the public exam system has become; Claires Court has 3 senior school centres to run, covering both GCSEs and A levels, to stretch over 8 weeks this summer, occupying of course all of our big halls in College Ave and Ray Mill Road East. Our Deputy Head Curriculum and her exam manager and 2 additional officers have to start the planning for the Summer term from 1 January, 20+ additional independent adults recruited to support all of the exams including Art to keep teachers out of temptation.

    It’s not just education that faces this explosion of bureaucracy; everyone now suffers from the local planning system that has gone the same way. When we applied for our new sports hall, with associated roadway and car park at Ridgeway 21 years ago in 2003, the application to approval time took exactly 3 months and required 3 documents, attracted a correspondence summary and a 5th paper to document approval. Our current application to install a small multi user all weather surface covering 3 tennis courts has attracted 28 documents to include multiple specialist reports to date and still counting, and almost 6 months later still no approval confirmed. I won’t go on any more…

    A successful, democratic system needs stable government but also stable and reasonable expectations that education, health and care can be delivered in a well coordinated matter. There is nothing visible any time soon that suggests national government will bring these matters under control, and the last thing Education needs is the continuous on-going creep of the DfE to take charge of everything over in our state schools, the complete antithesis of the freedoms the Thatcher, Major and Blair reforms brought for them from the previous 30 years. Access to children and Adolescent care services and funding has never been so rationed, almost certainly linked to the impossibly tight control the government has placed on funding for the training for future professionals in education, health, care and above all, public service in the emergency services and the military.

    I’ve worked since the age of 18, including before and during my student years. At that time, we faced the 3 day week, strikes and a time of similar despair on the failure of national government to get its house in order, but we knew then that the disruption to normal was just that. My wife and I could buy a 2 bed flat as soon as we started work, and opportunities quickly opened up in the years that followed. Now, I don’t see that landscape at all, nor do the alternative Politicians waiting expectantly to take over offer anything like that, just more of the same. The Labour Party’s position to introduce a 20% tax on our tuition fees is completely unreasonable, runs in the face of all other Western democracies and will have a huge and disproportionate impact on over 100,000 children whose parents have chosen our sector because their special needs cannot be met by the state, Much the same is the case for boarding schools; of course it seems that for some families they used boarding to buy access to privilege, but in the main, parents seek residential placements for their children’ schooling because it meets those other needs that the children or parents might have, such as expert coaching in Academic disciplines, Performing Arts, Music and Sports (which cannot be delivered in a day school) or safe care for children whose parents are in the military or work abroad for UKPLC to further support our interests overseas.

    Dorothy didn’t recognise Kansas, after she and her pet dog Toto had been swept over in to the magical land of Oz. Fortunately, as the story unfolds, and with the help of her 4 friends, the scarecrow, the tin woodman, the lion and the wizard, they defeat the wicked witch of the West. We too have been swept into a political landscape we no longer recognise; those that lead our country lied to us about the benefits of austerity, compounded the felony by taking us out of Europe fueled by further lies, have failed in their stewardship of our water, transport and energy services and above all in choosing to grab central control of the finances for education, health and care destroyed the local government’s powers to make a difference for the better. Strong public investment is essential to resolve the issues I have highlighted – you can’t rely on the market to return us back to ‘Kansas’; trickle down economics might eventually repave our roads and rebuild our hospitals, but it’s the investment in will, time and intellect to reduce again the waiting list for everything back from years to months to weeks and as soon as possible to days. That way we might get back to Kansas after all!