Graft and Craft: Turning Back to the Right Road

Dateline: 20 November 2026

In Mere Christianity, C.S. Lewis defined progress in a way that every education minister ought to have pinned above the desk, preferably with a drawing pin that goes into the thumb. Progress, he said, is getting nearer to where you want to be. Take a wrong turning and going forward gets you no nearer; you do an about-turn and walk back to the right road, and the person who turns back soonest is the most progressive of all. Lewis was writing about something loftier than the Department for Education, but I suspect he would forgive the loan.

Between 2015 and 2017, Dame Christine Ryan, then Chief Inspector of the Independent Schools Inspectorate, foresaw the dangers of implementing Michael Gove’s overhaul of every tier of the examined curriculum in England from 2017 onwards, from the primary key stages right through to GCSEs and A levels, and she gave a quiet but pointed warning. Changing a whole architecture in one go was a gamble, she cautioned, and we should not expect to judge it for five years or so. Add two more for the pandemic, and the longitudinal evidence has now been gathered and the reckoning arrives squarely where we stand today, in 2025 and 2026. Five years is a convenient length of time, I notice, since it is usually enough for the people who made the decision to have moved on.

The ledger is a mixed one. England’s climb in the PISA rankings is real, and ministers are entitled to the credit. But in our single-minded pursuit of academic rigour we threw out the baby with the bathwater, and nowhere more plainly than with the sixteen-year-old who missed a standard pass in GCSE English and mathematics and was marched straight back onto the same examination treadmill. Most could see no point in it, and the great majority failed all over again, which will have surprised nobody except possibly the exam boards, who were presumably looking forward to the sequel.

Alan Milburn’s report on young people and work came out on Tuesday, and he deserves our thanks for setting out the scale and causes of the NEET problem. He does not flinch from childhood poverty, poor health and regional deprivation, which between them leave more than a million young people outside education, employment or training. The government’s accompanying decision to loosen the post-sixteen resit rules concedes, rather late in the day, that a square peg goes into a round hole no more easily at seventeen than at sixteen, and that all you get for the effort is humiliation.

My quarrel is with treating the whole business as an administrative and labour-market problem to be engineered away at sixteen or eighteen. By the time a young person turns up at a Jobcentre or a training scheme, the loss happened years earlier. A society that narrows its schools to a single academic corridor loses its poorest children long before their sixteenth birthdays. The ability was there all along. What was missing was a handhold, offered at the right age.

A narrow curriculum has one cruel feature, which is that nobody is allowed to step back. In a generous education, stepping back is how a growing mind finds its bearings. A child tries the workshop bench, the studio, the music room, the sports field, the stage or the keyboard, and if one avenue proves barren, they can withdraw with dignity, take stock and try another until they find the terrain where their natural grain catches. Strip schooling down to a march towards written terminal exams and there is nowhere left to step back to. The child who stumbles cannot fall back on practical competence and rebuild some self-belief there. They fail where they stand, year after year, until switching off becomes the sensible form of self-defence.

Breadth is not simply a matter of timetabling other subjects. It also needs teachers with the time to be with their pupils in other settings, away from the relentless cycle of lesson preparation and marking. My good colleague Pip Bowen, who recently retired as Designated Safeguarding Lead at Claires Court, the independent school I led for forty-five years, often reflects that his own success in teaching began because others saw good in him that he never knew was there. He went on to become something of a horse whisperer among our pupils, with an instinct for spotting and admiring skills in boys and girls that sat entirely outside the formal curriculum. (To my knowledge, no pupil was ever bridled.)

I think often of an eleven-year-old boy we taught who could identify every train passing down the nearby railway track purely by the sound it made. There is no GCSE in that, which I suppose is the point, and in a system obsessed with exam metrics the gift might have been written off as an eccentric distraction. Thirty years on, he holds two degrees in engineering and transport, honed his knowledge and skills on the Indian Railways, and is now one of the leading transport managers in the world. Someone noticed what he could do at eleven, said so, and gave him room to grow into it.

What young people need, and what disadvantaged children need most urgently because their families cannot buy enrichment outside the school gates, is a school culture with both graft and craft in it. Craft is the business of making, fixing, designing and performing, and the discovery that your own hands, ears and judgement can shape something worthwhile. Graft is the sustained effort that follows once you have tasted that competence. Nobody grafts for long at work that only confirms their own inadequacy. People put in the hours where effort produces fruit that others respect.

Before any sixteen-year-old can become the resilient, work-ready adult Milburn wants to see, they need space at eight, eleven and thirteen, and adults with the time to notice them, to answer two questions: what am I good at, and, following from that, what am I good for? Walking back from a decade of curricular narrowness lowers no standards. It is Lewis’s about-turn, and whoever makes it soonest is, by his reckoning, the most progressive of all. I would be glad to see an education secretary go for the title.

Comments

Leave a Reply