Tag: intelligence

  • Principal for the Day – my work through the eyes of a boy aged 13 and three-quarters…

    It is a well know fact that the Headteachers within Claires Court have on occasion had their ‘lives’ auctioned to the highest bidder at the PTA Summer Ball; and my esteemed colleagues have then returned to the ranks whilst their ‘Headteacher for the Day’ has ruled the roost. To be frank, nothing as yet has gone wrong; the displaced headteacher has stayed close to the new incumbent, and made sure that only good things have happened as outcomes from their tenure.

    For the first time in June 2015, the role of Academic Principal was also in the Auction room, and pleasingly (for my ego at least) it sold really well. The winning bid was for Nathan, aged 13 and three-quarters, and on Tuesday 29 September, Nathan was able to take up his role for the day. Nathan visited all three of our sites and all divisions; it was most noticeable that he felt most at home with the Year 9 girls, who captured him at lunchtime and squirrelled him into a Biology lesson for the afternoon. I must confirm that at no stage during my career have Year 9 girls, or indeed any other group of children captured me for an afternoon, so more power to them for their powers of persuasion.

    The day commenced at Senior Boys, with Nathan (AP4D) acquiring a suitable ‘Voldemort’ style Gown to give him a sense of my normal ‘noble and dignified air’ (ahem), prior to travelling across Maidenhead to present to Mr Rowan at CCJB a case of Samsung tablets for his work with computing and digital literacy. AP4D then worked with Year 6 as they practiced their manoeuvres prior to acting as Open Day guides, before returning to SB to take part in a video morning with the team from Discovery Education. Pleasingly Discovery Education were content to video me asking of the AP4D his views on the role, as well as his use of digital technologies. I hope to post a clip of the interview once it has been processed by their crew.

    We then ‘teleported’ via my iQ to College, where Year 5 girls awaited to share with the AP4D their practice for Harvest Festival for Thursday and of course Lunch. Meanwhile, I was sent back to SB with some female Discovery ambassadors so they could be interviewed, so I am less aware perhaps of the antics  of my ‘doppelganger’.  In my absence it appears AP4T was persuaded to award the Head of Sixth Form and his team substantial pay rises, and to command that a regular commemorative day off named in Nathan’s honour was to be founded.

    The AP4D then encountered my brother Hugh, Administrative Principal at Claires Court, and both enjoyed a photocall.  At the end of the day, I ‘chauffeured’ Nathan home to meet with his proud parents, who had not in their wildest hopes for Nathan seen him appointed as a headteacher at such a tender age.  Actually, that’s why they bid for the ‘placement’ at the Summer Ball in the first place.

    A short film of Nathan’s day can be found here – a mash-up from the real APs camera!

    P.S. Sadly for the Head of Sixth Form, those salary changes were reversed the next morning, and AP4D’s annual holiday has been permanently rained off.

    Short video of Nathan, Academic Principal for the Day

  • Nutrition, Diet Fads and Tablets – a take on virtual learning.

    ‘If Music be the food of love, play on’ spoke Duke Orsino in Twelfth  Night. His courtship for the Countess Olivia is not going well, and he rather hopes that an overdose would perhaps cure him of his  appetite.  The play is full of mistaken identities and misplaced trusts, but all works out in the end for the lovers (x 3 sets) and Music gets to take a back seat after all.

    I recall much of the plot of  Twelfth  Night as if it were yesterday, partly because I studied it as my set text for O’Level and partly because I have seen it quite a few times since on stage. As a fourteen year old, I was given a much read and  previously  annotated edition of the play in hardback copy, and we worked through the set text for some 3 months with our teacher, the venerable Father Dunstan, whose myopic eyesight required pebble-sized glasses but whose grasp of the set text and his student audience was pretty tight.

    In recent years, I have chosen to grapple positively with learning in the digital age, and pleasingly received some attention, support, recognition and such like for my efforts. Just now, as I type this article into WordPress’ frame, I have a wide variety of tablets (Apple and Android), laptops & chrome-books nearby, as I rehearse for new teacher induction how best our soon-to-be employed staff can make use of our Google Apps for Edu and Google Classroom environment. I know I need to do this preparation, for my new colleagues will in the main have no idea at all how collaborative documents and paperless assignments work. 

    As I browse the Internet looking at world research and corporate bravado, it’s quite clear that for many schools the pressure is on to go digital, move paperless, use Apps and be seen to be 21st century learners.  But rules for what actually works in this brave new world are not that easily found, and frankly might work on day 1 or 2, because it is all new and bright and shiny, but into the second term and beyond might be found  wanting.  As a school, we have been truly digital for 30 months now, and yes our A level results are certainly better than we might have expected, but the positive difference is perhaps just a vanity at  this stage.  I like what the technology can bring, imediacy and intimacy of contact between teacher and taught, but of the other benefits of this internet age, I am rather more wary. 

    A recent post by Alex Quigley, Hunting English, pointed me at a research paper by Dunlosky et al, published by the  Association for  Psychological  Science, one of those groups seeking to provide evidence-based research to advise what works best in the classroom.  Here’s a couple of testers for you: what would you rather do – read through a chapter and highlight the key points, or alternatively, sit regular practice tests on the content to test your understanding and knowledge?  Which student is going to do better, the one that reads and re-reads the set-text or the one that makes summary notes of same?

    Three rules of thumb are recognisable:

    1. What is easiest to do works least effectively 

    2. Practice makes perfect

    2. Teacher-feedback makes  the difference.

    So in example 1, practice tests beats rereading for learning hands down.  In example 2, since there is no practice or teacher feedback, neither are  terribly  useful.  You can read the article here – http://goo.gl/SxowHv – and it’s a beauty.  Like much other cognitive research emerging at present, it tells us a lot more than just confirm prejudices.  It is  particularly interesting to note that approaching problems in diverse ways may actually be less effective than just nailing the problem head-on, because a variety of practice does not necessarily mean sufficient attention is spent on the memorising or the technical skills involved. 

    Imagine now that I was given not an old, well thumbed edition of a play, but a bright shiny digital artifact on my iPad screen instead.  Yes, I can see straight away I am missing  those  helpful notes written by others before me, so I have to start writing on my screen straight-away to add those memories of what the words mean. Hang-on, the pdf doesn’t allow me that choice.  Never-mind, I can quickly surf the internet, review what others think and make those thoughts my own.  That’s cool, I can rather more readily research and rework the material than perhaps I could using paper and print. But will that help me learn the lines, quote the examples I need and raise my self-awareness sufficiently to become the best student I’d like to be?

    I have developed a rule of thumb that suggests that up to 33% of work can be created in digital form, and that assignments and such like should measure up in similar manner. But more than that would take children and teachers away from the other necessary learning activities that cause real learning to occur and growth mind-sets to be established. It is  interesting  to note that recent UK research highlights that students who sit 3 A levels do better than those that sit 2, and so sixth form advisers better watch out if they slim students diet to 2 subjects so that they can do better, because the evidence is to the contrary. I’ll join this research with my own practice, highlighting perhaps that people’s cognitive engagement has got to be full-on for them to learn best.  So learning just in a virtual world will certainly not be as effective as working in a broader mixed economy to include paper, people and practice.

    We are just beginning to see the first research papers out showing the warning signs for those institutions that have gone fully paper-free, highlighting that the early successes of Tablets in the classroom can’t be maintained into the long term. As ever with such research, it’ll need some peer review and publication by APS, CEM centre and others before I’ll make it a real headline.  Real learning has to include a digital dimension, so familiar and available that the children can deploy its use as appropriate. But like TV dinners, not the diet of choice all the time.  The last thing we want is to supersize our children through a diet of easy-to-acquire information and apps-that-do-the-work into Learning Obesity, whereby excess gratuitous study & activity has accumulated in the learner an undeserved confidence to the extent that it has a negative effect on mental health, leading to reduced academic performance and/or increased health problems. It is not just about knowing how to find the information; for  Shakespeare  that was always obviously in his  completed  works. But studying, revising, forgetting and memorising takes time and energy, yet are indeed the food of learning, and need to play on for many years to come. 

  • The Penny Dreadful, the Ha’penny Dreadfuller – will we ever learn?

    One of the education blogs I follow is that of Alex Quigley, Hunting English. He, like me, read today’s headlines on the BBC website and in the Guardian about a new English A level syllabus being steered to approval, involving some modern populist writing: “Today the newspapers were awash with stories to make our great British population wince with embarrassment and raise a fist in fury. Our hallowed tradition of literature is apparently under threat of being sullied by the dumbing down of a new A level qualifications. It is sure to send our nation spiralling into inexorable decline. Shakespeare and Austen paired with Dizzy Rascal and Russell Brand. Oh, the horror, the horror!”

    The original Guardian article is here, and started as follows:

    “A-level students will study Russell Brand‘s views on drugs and Caitlin Moran’s Twitter feed alongside more conventional literature in a new A-level that was immediately denounced as “rubbish” by sources at the Department for Education.

    The OCR exam board said it had teamed up with an educational charity, the English and Media Centre, to develop the A-level in English language and literature to study unorthodox texts, such as a BBC Newsnight interview with rapper Dizzee Rascal and the work of former Guardian columnist the Secret Footballer.

    OCR said the exam – a separate course from English or English literature – would include an anthology which included extracts from Brand’s testimony on drug use to a parliamentary committee and tweets by Times journalist Caitlin Moran, as well as more conventional fare such as Samuel Pepys’s diary entries.

    But the education department launched a scathing attack. A senior DfE source said: “Schools should be aware that if they offer this rubbish in place of a proper A-level, then pupils may not get into good universities. We will expect other exam boards to do better.

    “It is immensely patronising to young people to claim that they will only engage with English language and literature through celebrities such as Russell Brand.”

    Comment

    My younger son studied English at the University of Leicester last decade, read from Old English’s Beowulf to 20th century slang and everything inbetween. His writing and examination covered Literature, Language and Linguistics too. Have you ever tried reading Old English? I remember Ed bringing a facsimile of BeoWulf home during a reading week, throwing the tome onto the sofa and in pure frustration demanding that the graduate home team of parent/teachers provide some genuine academic support. “I can’t make head or tale of it” he almost wept! Because his mother and father loved him, we picked up the book, opened the pages and in turn each read the first stanza or two. “Nope, makes no sense to us either!” we both declared, “It’s your degree, son, yours to earn”.

    Later on, when his third year collaborative project was coming to an end, he shared with me his 10-author modern slang dictionary of 2000 words. “Complete rubbish” I declared, ” I don’t know 90% of these, you’ve made them up”.

    Now, he is a highly successful Business Analyst working in the Digital insurance space, having to make sense of other peoples needs, ambitions and perhaps business gibberish, then to translate in such a way that in-house programmers can deliver a business platform that showcases on screens around the world a specific company’s insurance products in an interactive and adaptive manner. Now that’s a job in an industry that simply did not exist when he started his degree. What his education provided, starting at our school and continuing through University to the present day, was the encouragement to be diligent, learn how to organise work effectively, persevere, propose and  explore ideas with independence and confidence. Success comes through being able to collaborate effectively, and access to diverse opportunities to show initiative, think critically and express oneself both creatively and convincingly.

    That’s not to say that I would advocate reading Dizzee Rascal or Russell Brand, any more than I would similar ‘populist writing of previous eras. ‘Chacun à son goût‘ as the French might say. The Penny Dreadfuls of the Victorian era introduced an adolescent peer group of new, emerging male readers to lurid tales of daring do and worse; and the educated classes of the time railed at the very idea of the illiterate working man learning to read and finding entertainment in trash, serial fiction. I quote from Wikipedia “The term “dreadful” was originally assumed to express societal anxiety or moral alarm over the new profitable innovation directed at the youth. In reality, the serial novels were over-dramatic and sensational, but generally harmless. If anything, the penny dreadfuls, although obviously not the most enlightening or inspiring of literary selections, resulted in increasingly literate youth in the Industrial period. The wide circulation of this sensationalist literature, however, contributed to an ever greater fear of crime in mid-Victorian Britain”. Yep, you’ve got it, Crime, Sex and Sensation sold papers.

    The Guardian costs today £1.60. Taking the paper digitally does not cost me quite so much, but actually digital papers were not around in the 19th century. Given the paper has 80 pages, that makes each page 2 pence. If the Guardian article covered half of a page, could we not suggest that Richard Adams’s article worthy of the title ‘Penny dreadful’? The growing volume of incredibly lazy journalism around tiny chunks of non-news providing lurid stories in serial form is certainly worth the title. Unless of course, only a quarter of a page was covered, in which case we have the halfpenny dreadfuller. The target audience over a hundred years ago was adolescent. I wonder now whether the audience that responds to this trite rubbish is any the wiser? As Alex Quigley comments back in the 21st Century, the formula has move on; “Celebrity sells and Educational decline sells. Put them together and you spark 1000 comments!“

    Trash populist literature of the 19th century spawned the emergence of a literate working class, the heartbeat and muscle, imagination and perspiration that led the world’s Industrial Revolution here in the UK. I might be stretching my point a little, but could not the same be said of 21st century populist writing, be that by musicians or comedians, Twitter feed or Blog post? Is not the study of such diverse variety of the written and spoken word  likely to assist in developing the skills and intelligence to harness the post-industrial revolution in our favour. For one young Wilding in London, it certainly seems to have done just that.