Tag: writing

  • “Suum Cuique” – To Each His Own – and the Football

    Thursday 14 August 2026, A-Level results day; a parent quietly came up to share with me her pride at her child’s results, and to thank me, as it turns out, for giving them a chance, because no-one else had. 

    “Suum cuique”. To each his own, or her own, and I rather like that a Latin tag older than any exam board can still do more honest work than most of what gets written about results day. I came across it by way of a LinkedIn post from Dr Rosemary Taylor, responding to this year’s coverage of boys pulling ahead of girls at A-Level, and it has been sitting with me for days in the way only the genuinely well-put things do.

    Her point, as I read it, isn’t that the gap doesn’t matter. It’s that the moment we ask “why are boys ahead” we have already, without quite noticing, agreed to treat education as a race with only one finishing line. Ask instead what has actually changed — for both — and you get a much more interesting, much less tidy question, one that doesn’t resolve into a scoreboard at all. I have sat through forty-odd results days in my working life, watched the same relief and the same devastation arrive within feet of each other at the same gate, and I have never once believed that the two grades side by side told you which of those two young people had been better served by their education. Only which of them had produced a number that was easier to print.

    Which brings me, by a route I did not entirely plan, to Charlie Brown.

    Every autumn, Lucy holds the football steady on the grass and tells Charlie Brown that this year will be different. Every autumn he runs at it in good faith, and every autumn she snatches it away at the exact moment his foot arrives, and he ends up flat on his back looking at the sky, wondering what he did wrong. Schulz kept the gag running for the best part of five decades, and confessed towards the end of his life that he had never once let Charlie kick that ball, because the moment he did, the strip would have nothing left to say. Success, in Peanuts, is permanently almost. That is not a flaw in the joke. That is the entire joke.

    I have watched this play out somewhere rather less exalted than a national exam board, too: the Maidenhead Advertiser. It used to run past a hundred pages a week, and a paper that size could afford suum cuique without ever using the phrase — every team at every level got its match report, the Under 12s as faithfully as the First XV, because the advertising that paid for it depended on every household reading, not just the households whose sons made the top team. Nobody had to decide to be generous. A hundred pages simply needed filling, and filling them meant writing about everybody. Today the same paper runs to thirty-two pages and reaches a readership mostly over sixty, and something quite specific has been lost that has nothing to do with declining standards of journalism: there is no longer room for the boy who never got near the First XV but never missed a training session either, or the girl whose exam grades were unremarkable but who kept the whole sailing programme running that summer. The paper didn’t stop valuing them. It simply ran out of pages, and what got kept was whatever was easiest to justify in the space available — which is to say, the scoreboard.

    One of my idiosyncrasies as Academic Principal is that I’ve always turned up on results days. In part, because for me, it’s in the title, but much more importantly, it’s been intensely personal. For some, I’ve been responsible for their education for thirteen years since entering the Nursery. For others, Claires Court was their only option for secondary or sixth form, having been rejected by the state for not being ‘good enough’, yet we could see there were such possibilities, and results clearly validated that decision. Although I had stepped away from leading the school, the Sixth Form Vice Principal invited me in to share those moments once again.

    What Dr Taylor’s piece and Schulz’s ball have in common, oddly, is a warning about what happens when you let the scoreboard do the defining. A league table, like Lucy’s football, promises that this year the measure will finally capture what matters. It never quite does, because the things that matter most in a young person’s education — the coaching they had access to, the teacher who noticed them at exactly the right moment, the sheer bloody-minded persistence of turning up to training on a wet Tuesday when nobody was watching — are precisely the things that are hardest to put a number on, and therefore the things a scoreboard will always, quietly, leave out. We optimise for what we can measure, and then we mistake the measurement for the whole of the thing. Every institution that has ever chased a league table has learned this lesson, usually the hard way, and usually too late to matter for the cohort that taught it to them.

    I don’t think the answer is to stop measuring anything, any more than the answer to Charlie Brown’s problem is to stop playing football. Rigour matters. Grades matter, imperfect as they are, because they are still the fairest common currency we have found for comparing the incomparable. But suum cuique asks something quieter of us than a league table ever will: not who won, but what was owed to this particular child, and whether we gave it to them. That is a harder question to put in a headline. It may be the only one worth asking on the morning the envelopes go out.

    That same instinct is why, in leading a faculty for so many years, my colleagues learned my deep loathing for shouting too much from the rooftops about academic success. In part, this is because, however great our place has been for the young people receiving their grades, some won’t have made their mark in the way they had hoped that day. Learning that their chosen university or sixth form college was, after all, unwilling to offer them a place is even worse if those who celebrate seem to ignore their pain. Yet we all need joy in our hearts too; our local paper always does its best to be fair to all schools, refusing to rank-order them or fill its pages with photographs of results sheets thrown gleefully into the air.

    I think of something Steve Jobs told Apple’s staff in 1997, not long after his return, using Nike as his example. Nike, he pointed out, sells nothing more than shoes — a commodity like any other — and yet their advertising never once mentions the product. Instead, they spend their time honouring great athletes and great athletics, and let the shoe follow wherever the emotion leads. Listening to that story again, it struck me how closely it maps onto a school. We are not, in the end, in the business of manufacturing grade percentages, any more than Nike is in the business of selling rubber and leather. What we are honouring, or ought to be, is the athlete rather than the shoe — the character, the resilience, the person the certificate merely trails behind.

    A school is not an assembly line for printing certificates, and standing at the gates on results day it is easy to get swept up in the local league tables, or the temptation to declare our young people have somehow outperformed the school down the road. But raw attainment data is a fragile sort of victory, always deeply nuanced and invariably leaving someone quietly disappointed in the shadow of the headline figure. Our real work was to foster the character, resilience and integrity of the young people who walked through our doors. A town doesn’t thrive on exam percentages alone; it thrives on the calibre of the citizens who step into its civic spaces afterwards — the true measure of forty years’ work arriving some years later, in the form of a thoughtful, well-qualified adult rolling up their sleeves in the community rather than in a results-day headline.

    So what would results day look like if the local paper, and the civic leaders alongside it, celebrated the things suum cuique asks us to notice, rather than the things the league table demands — and whether anyone would have the nerve to try it first.

  • “The Tale of the Principal Emeritus”

    (after the manner of the Rime of the Ancient Mariner) & with apologies to Samuel Taylor Coleridge.

    This tale of heroic contribution, spoken on the leaving thanks after staff Inset at Claires Court Senior Boys School, commemorates the contribution made by those departing staff, aligned to the Ray Mill Road East campus.

    It is the Principal Emeritus,
    Who stoppeth one of three;
    His beard is grey, his eye is bright,
    “Come, tarry now with me.”
    “The Hall is dressed, the drinks are poured,
    The speeches soon begin;
    But ere these faithful souls depart,
    Pray let this tale sink in.

    For many a year we’ve sailed together,
    Through ISI’s storm and calm;
    With timetables, reports and boys,
    And tea to soothe each qualm.
    No albatross hung round our necks,
    Though burdens there were many;
    Yet faithful hearts and willing hands
    Outnumbered cares by plenty.
    For schools are built of flesh and blood,
    Not merely brick and stone;
    By those who quietly gave their all,
    And never sought their own.
    Now hear of those whose watch is done,
    Whose duty now is past;
    Whose names shall echo through these halls
    Long after bells have ceased their blast.

    Maggie Olivier
    First came Dame Maggie Olivier,
    High Queen of Stage and Speech;
    The Common Room her royal court,
    No soul beyond her reach.
    A parent first, then leader true,
    With wit both sharp and warm;
    She weathered every school-day gale,
    Each teenage thunderstorm.
    Yet all who gathered round the urn,
    Knew well another throne:
    The Mistress of the Biscuit Barrel—
    A kingdom all her own.
    The Custard Creams obeyed her nod,
    The Bourbons knew their place;
    No Chocolate Digestive dared
    Appear without her grace.
    And monthly came the solemn cry,
    With ledger held aloft:
    “The Common Room subscriptions, please!”
    Though spoken ever soft.
    For someone had to mind the purse,
    And someone keep us fed;
    Else hungry teachers, lacking tea,
    Would surely fall down dead.
    And oft when endings came around,
    ‘Twas Maggie’s voice we’d hear;
    To bid farewell to friends departing,
    With laughter and a tear.

    Yet now the wheel has turned once more,
    The herald takes her seat;
    The one who spoke the parting words
    Must hear them now complete.
    But not farewell—not wholly so—
    For schools are strange that way;
    We part with “Adieu” more than “Goodbye”,
    And meet another day.
    Beside poor Barry once she stood,
    In years now passed from gaze;
    Though life wrote scenes no playwright dared,
    His memory sits in the haze.

    Cherie Levi
    Then Cherie Levi, healer kind,
    The guardian of our health;
    Whose calming smile and measured words
    Were greater far than wealth.
    She bore the bag of mysteries,
    Of lotions, charts and files;
    Yet somehow soothed the fiercest boy
    With little more than smiles.
    And many feared the gleaming dart,
    The hypodermic gleam;
    “The Nurse approaches!” voices cried—
    “A most alarming dream!”
    Yet Cruella she was surely not,
    Though she liked the likeness well;
    Her purpose was not wickedness,
    As every child could tell.
    The needle served but one great cause—
    To keep disease at bay;
    To guard the young entrusted here,
    Each ordinary day.
    Then came the plague no living soul
    Had thought they’d ever see;
    When silence settled on the land
    Like some dark phantom sea.
    Through COVID’s strange and fearful years,
    When certainties grew few,
    She brought us calm and clarity,
    And always knew what to do.
    The masks, the tests, the jabs, the charts,
    The guidance changing fast—
    Yet Cherie steered the little ship
    Until the storm had passed.

    Dr Karen Loughran
    Then Dr Karen Loughran strode,
    With scholar’s measured tread;
    The Academic Deputy,
    Whose thoughts ran miles ahead.
    The Cover Lists! Great parchment scrolls!
    Known only unto few;
    If lessons stood when staff were gone,
    ‘Twas Karen saw them through.
    But deeper still the mystery lay,
    Beyond all mortal ken:
    The sacred art of Timetables—
    Unknown to other men.
    How place Set Four in Chemistry
    At half-past nine on door,
    Whilst somehow granting nursery runs
    Before the clock strikes four?
    How balance Physics, French and Games,
    And GCSE review,
    With granny needing hospital,
    And Year Eight needing you?
    Not Karen’s granny—mark me well—
    But everyone else’s kin;
    For somehow every pleading case
    Would find its way to win.
    She cut just enough slack, no more,
    With wisdom, tact and grace;
    Until impossible itself
    Found somehow time and place.
    The rest of us looked on in awe,
    And wisely did conclude:
    The timetable is witchcraft dressed
    In academic mood.

    Wendy Keaney
    Then Wendy Keaney, steadfast soul,
    Whose heart embraced us all;
    Inclusion’s champion, wise and firm,
    She answered every call.
    Yet “Deputy” ne’er told the tale,
    Nor captured all she’d done;
    For captains need no braided sleeve
    To prove that they have won.
    Across three sites and five great schools,
    Her fleet stretched far and wide;
    Yet every sailor knew her hand
    Was steady at the tide.
    The broadest charge of anyone,
    Yet closest-knit her crew;
    They knew the voyage, shared the helm,
    And always saw it through.
    When inspectors sought a shining light,
    One phrase rang clear and strong:
    “A Significant Strength” they wrote—
    Where Wendy did belong.
    The football crowds cry every year,
    “It’s coming home!” with cheer;
    For Wendy and her steadfast team
    Made those words true right here.
    Not sung from Wembley stands alone,
    Nor dreamt by hopeful men;
    But lived each day in countless acts,
    Again…and yet again.

    Pip — Philip Horatio Bowen

    Now Pip! Sir Philip Horatio!
    Long may his legend grow.
    From Scallywag in younger days
    To Justice’s measured glow.
    One-and-forty years have passed
    Since first he walked these grounds;
    As pupil, coach and master true,
    Where countless joy abounds.
    The coaches waited at his word,
    Their journeys all well planned;
    No driver feared the unknown road
    While Pip gave his command.
    Now Pip! Sir Philip Horatio!
    Long may his legend grow.
    From Scallywag in younger days
    To Justice’s measured glow.
    One-and-forty years have passed
    Since first he walked these grounds;
    As pupil, coach and master true,
    Where countless joy abounds.
    The coaches waited at his word,
    Their journeys all well planned;
    No driver feared the unknown road
    While Pip gave his command.
    Yet hear the words he leaves behind,
    More precious than applause:
    “I’ll miss the old establishment,”
    He says, then gently pauses.
    He names the friends who shaped his path,
    Too many to recount;
    Yet some deserve remembrance still,
    Whose worth no tongue can count.
    Alan Sibley, Mark Turner,
    Brian Forrester beside;
    Wendy, Paul and Huw Buckle,
    Who walked the selfsame tide.
    Charlie Bretherton, Scott Harris,
    Justin, John Rayer too;
    Each a lantern on the voyage,
    Each steadfast, wise and true.

    But one name shines with special light,
    And bids us all take heed—
    David H Course, his mentor dear,
    A master every school would need.
    Generous beyond all measure,
    Humble, wise and kind;
    A teacher who shaped other teachers,
    And countless hearts and minds.
    “It was,” says Pip, “the best of times—
    Though worst there sometimes proved:
    The ski trips and the rugby wins,
    The boys whose lives were moved.


    The visits made, the grades achieved,
    The friendships forged for life;
    The memories that outlast exams,
    Outlasting toil and strife.
    And when old boys return again,
    With children at their knee,
    You know the work was worth the while—
    As plain as plain can be.”
    And somewhere still the barbecue
    Awaits another June soon,
    With laughter rising through the dusk
    Beneath a summer moon…

    John and Pauline Carr
    Then John and Pauline, side by side,
    Long guardians of the lore;
    They mined the seams of hidden data,
    And tested evermore.
    No spreadsheet dared deceive their gaze,
    No system hid a flaw;
    For every number told a tale
    Observed by Carrian law.
    Yet John bore other gifts besides,
    Unknown to graphs and sums;
    For when the Staff Choir found its voice,
    He summoned beating drums.
    His baton danced, his eyebrows rose,
    His fingers marked the time;
    Till weary teachers somehow found
    Their voices turned sublime.
    And oft beside the Christmas tree,
    Or Speech Day’s grand parade,
    His patient hand upon the lens
    A thousand memories made.


    The films, the songs, the treasured scenes,
    Now safely kept in store;
    To warm our hearts beside the fire
    When we can teach no more.
    And Pauline too, with testing’s art,
    Kept standards straight and true;
    Though one remembered script survives,
    As legends sometimes do.
    For Amit wrote with boundless zeal,
    His verses bold and frank;
    He sought a rhyme of highest worth…
    With one outrageous prank.
    “What word,” he mused, “completes this verse?”
    The examiner looked wan.
    The answer was… perhaps unfit
    For mention after dawn!
    Yet laughter lives where kindness dwells,
    And every school must keep
    A little shelf of treasured tales
    Too good for solemn sleep.

    Andre Boulton
    Then Andre came, Lord Boulton named,
    High King of Cable and Screen;
    Whose kingdom lay where none could see—
    Behind each glowing machine.
    “Why build it fast?” the youngsters cried.
    “Why not tomorrow’s trick?”
    Andre smiled that patient smile:
    “The slow-built wall stands thick.”
    For brick by brick, and wire by wire,
    He raised a future sure;
    Not fashioned for a single term,
    But decades to endure.
    The architect of quiet things,
    Whose triumph none applaud;
    Until one morning nothing works—
    Then all invoke his God.
    Yet greater still the choice he made,
    When family called away;
    To seek a wider, stranger world,
    Beyond familiar day.
    One heart remained at Claires Court still,
    Another journeyed on;
    For every father knows at last
    His duty is not gone.
    The map unfolds before the feet,
    The road bends out of sight;
    May every mile reward the faith
    That guided such a flight.

    Jamie Odell
    Then Jamie strode—the tallest man
    To grace these ancient stones;
    Whose head seemed nearly level with
    The weather vanes and cones.
    Now City’s towers beckon him
    With figures, funds and shares;
    May merchants tremble at the sight
    Of one who climbs their stairs.
    Yet none shall quite forget the day—
    Confession now is due—
    When Burnham won by nine great wickets…
    Or so the scorebook knew.
    For Jamie, James and Simon there
    Contrived, with subtle art,
    To lose with such convincing grace
    They played the clever part.
    “Why throw the match?” the youngsters cried.
    “What madness guides the bat?”
    “Because,” quoth they, “Pip’s barbecue
    Was waiting after that!”
    The alumni gathered, stories flowed,
    Old friendships were renewed;
    Some victories are scored in runs,
    Some simply… neighbourhood.

    Louise Thomas

    Then Louise Thomas , scientist,
    Who once was Atter named;
    With logic and the chemist’s art,
    Her spirit is acclaimed.

    With Rhiannon and with Harley too,
    She watched the seasons fly;
    An Academic Lead whose care
    Was seen by every eye.

    The “Big Questions” were her special skill,
    To make the scholars think;
    To pull the truth from off the page, And forge a lasting link.


    Within the silent Exam Hall,
    Where nervous pens would fall;
    She watched the data’s hidden flow,
    Obeying Carrian law .

    With Mrs. Carr she kept the watch,
    Through hours long and still;
    Directing every student’s path,
    With firm and steady will.

    From Atter name to Thomas change,
    The journey has been long;
    By method and by theory,
    She proved her logic strong.

    The scientific method’s rule,
    She taught with clarity;
    To grant to every boy and girl
    A bright prosperity.

    Now other duties call her name,
    To fields both green and new;
    But here the “Big Questions” remain,
    In everything we do.

    Jo Andrews

    Then Jo Andrews , Geographer ,
    Whose maps were truly wide;
    She understood the turning earth,
    The wind and ocean tide.

    Across the lonely moorland heights,
    Where purple heather grows;
    She knew the language of the rocks,
    And where the river flows.

    To Iceland’s shore of ice and fire,
    The expeditions went;
    With Jo to guide the eager crew,
    On discovery intent.

    The longshores and the coastal drift,
    She tracked along the sand;
    To show how water, wind and time,
    Have carved this ancient land.

    As Captain Hope’s right hand she stood,
    A Deputy of might;
    To keep the vessel on its course,
    Through day and through the night.

    When navigation grew most hard,
    And heavy seas would roll;
    Her steady hand and quiet word,
    Provided much control.

    But new horizons call her now,
    Beyond the familiar shore;
    The compass points to other lands,
    For her to now explore.

    The open sea is bright and clear,
    The voyage is just begun;
    She leaves us with the maps she drew,
    Beneath the morning sun.

    The Guests Listen
    The Guests are hushed. They hear the tale.
    The glasses all stand still.
    The Principal Emeritus
    Has yet to speak his fill.
    He looks upon familiar faces,
    Now silvered more than gold;
    And sees not merely years gone by,
    But stories still untold.
    Then softly speaks of Dickens’ words,
    Whose truth we all have known:

    “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times; it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness; it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity; it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness; it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair.”


    “So wrote old Charles—and every school
    Has lived that selfsame page.
    For every triumph, every doubt,
    Belongs to every age.
    We’ve known inspection’s anxious tread,
    And speech days bright with pride.
    We’ve buried friends before their time,
    And watched young lives take stride.
    We’ve laughed at things no parent knows,
    Nor governor could guess.
    We’ve turned disasters into jokes,
    And chaos into success.
    For schools are curious little worlds:
    Tomorrow always comes.
    Another boy, another bell,
    Another beating drum.
    The names upon the office doors
    Are written in the sand;
    But character, once truly formed,
    Outlives the strongest hand.”


    Then rose the Principal once again,
    His final toast to give:

    “To Maggie, Cherie, Karen, Wendy,
    Pip, Pauline, John,
    André, Jamie, Louise and Jo

    May every one of you
    Know that your labour has not ended,
    Only changed its field.
    For schools are never built by Headmasters.
    Nor by Governors.
    Nor by Inspectors.
    They are built by ordinary people,
    Doing extraordinary things,

    Day after day,
    Year after year,
    Until one morning they discover
    They have become part of the place itself.
    You leave your offices today,
    But not these halls.
    Your names are written,
    Not on honours boards…

    But in the memories
    Of generations of boys,
    Of colleagues,
    Of parents,
    And of friends.”


    The tide rolls on.
    The voyage continues.
    New hands now take the helm.
    Yet every ship bears, in her timbers,
    Something of those who built her.
    So raise your glasses high.
    Not to endings—
    For schools know very few of those.
    But to adieu.


    For somewhere,
    On another Speech Day,
    At another rugby touchline,
    Around another barbecue,
    Or over another biscuit barrel,

    We shall surely meet again.”

    And all were silent for a space.


    Then someone reached for the biscuit tin. And all was well.

  • Claires Court – a partnership worth backing

    The header shows our Junior playing fields set out for Sports Day; as ever, a welcoming place for all sports, summer or winter!

    This week’s news that the Department for Education is scrapping the £320 million PE and Sport Premium in favour of a new “partnerships network” will, understandably, be met with some anxiety across the profession. No one can ever welcome a cut in funding, and school leaders are right to ask serious questions about how a scheme worth some 22 per cent less will reach every corner of the country, and whether the money will get to the frontline rather than a new layer of bureaucracy. Those are fair concerns, and I share them — not least because this cut lands on the same independent sector that has spent the past 18 months absorbing VAT on fees, a tax no other country in Europe sees fit to levy on education. I’m really disappointed that government policy currently treats independent schools as a convenient source of revenue one moment, and a partner to be quietly relied upon the next. There’s a glaring hypocrisy to tax a sector as a private luxury and lean on it as a public good in the same breath.

    But strip away the funding arithmetic for a moment, and look at the principle behind the change: schools and their local sports clubs, working together, are to be placed back at the heart of how young people get active. As Principal Emeritus of Claires Court, I take honest pride and feel a flicker of vindication. It is a model we have been quietly building in Maidenhead for well over forty years, long before it had a policy name.

    Our first formal partnership was with the Maidenhead and District Schools Sailing Association, back in 1978. Forty-eight years on, we remain proud partners of Maidenhead Sailing Club, and this week our sailing team is out at the National School Sailing Championships at Itchenor, competing against the very best schools and clubs in the country.

    The partnership with Maidenhead Rowing Club began in 1984. We row from their clubhouse on the river, while through the winter months Maidenhead Juniors train back at the school, using our rowing gallery and fitness centre. That shared investment in facilities is paying off spectacularly just now: Claires Court has three crews qualified for Henley Royal Regatta, rowing’s greatest stage, this summer, joined at Henley by crews from Maidenhead Rowing Club itself. Two clubs, one stretch of river, one clubhouse, and both on the startline at Henley: what better advertisement for what shared training facilities can achieve?

    Other partnerships have flourished in the same spirit. We work with both Maidenhead Rugby and Maidenhead Football clubs; in cricket, we partner with Boyne Hill and Maidenhead & Bray, and our Playing Fields at our Junior School at Ridgeway, now providing the home ground for Maidenhead Royals. Before long the Thicket will once again be alive with the 600 junior footballers of MUFC, back for their seasonal home at Claires Court, just as it is now for Maidenhead Nomads FC too.

    The deepest and most enduring of all these partnerships is with Phoenix Rugby Club, forged in 1984 and now extending for a further thirty years, giving the Taplow community a genuine home for adults and children alike in both rugby and cricket.

    I set all of this out not to claim any great foresight, but because it illustrates something the DfE’s new network will only succeed if it grasps: partnership cannot be conjured into being by a funding formula. It takes decades of trust, shared facilities, and people on both sides who keep turning up for each other, season after season, long after any grant has been spent. What Maidenhead has built with its schools and clubs is not a compliance exercise. It is a community habit, indeed for Claires Court “Maidenhead is our Campus”!

    And it is a habit paying dividends right now. Alongside our sailors and our Henley crews, our tennis team has reached the last sixteen of the LTA finals in Nottingham, our cricketers are preparing for the school county cricket finals, and our First XV rugby squad are about to depart on their summer tour to South Africa, playing in Johannesburg, Pretoria and Cape Town. It is, by any measure, a remarkable few weeks for young sportspeople who train, more often than not, on pitches, courts and water shared with the wider Maidenhead community.

    Claires Court does not just produce an opportunity to play; our pipeline produces more than school-age success. Old Claires Courtian Ellie Rayer recently celebrated her 150th cap for GB Hockey, a milestone built on exactly the same grounding in local, club-linked sport that today’s sailors, rowers and squads are drawing on now.

    So as Whitehall works out the mechanics of its new network, my hope is simply that it looks to towns like ours and asks what has actually worked, rather than starting from scratch. Youth sport in Maidenhead is vibrant precisely because schools and clubs stopped seeing each other as separate worlds decades ago. Claires Court is proud to be at the heart of so much of it, as an enthusiastic and, we hope, dependable partner.

    It won’t be long now until the Thicket is ringing again with the sound of football on the weekend. As a certain song has it: it’s coming home.

    The Fawley quad 2026, on the water on the ‘Stretch of the Gods’ underneath Cliveden on the River Thames between Maidenhead Lock and Cookham upstream.

  • ‘Nudge Theory’ and why schools should model rather than demand compliance to achieve success.

    When principals, teachers, parents and children turned up for work at our Junior school on Friday, two deputy heads were on welcome duty at the gate, as you can see. On the left is Mrs Lindsay King, Deputy Head and to the right is Mrs Chantal Hankin, Deputy Head Lower Juniors & Nursery. As you can see from the kit, Mrs Hanking is wearing the current England Hockey kit, ready to play in the 4 nations home internationals over the weekend. ‘Chants’ was back in school this morning, dressed more as you’d expect for a leading school teacher, but flushed with pride, because, the England team won the tournament – that’s a result, no question.

    There’s an old age that us teachers can’t bear, which is “If you can DO if you can’t TEACH!” Well in a school that has very many teachers who can absolutely DO brilliantly, and IN ADDITION choose to pass on their skills, talent and know-how, I’m moved to add to my post of 10 years ago, highlighted below.

    Thus year, I’ve done my best to challenge the government’s decision to cause irreparable damage to our sector through their decision to impose 20% VAT on independent schools. Their stated aim (albeit hugely confused by their own statements suggesting it woul also fund health, care and housing) is to employ 6,500 more teachers in state schools. As the emerging data is now clearly showing, the growing loss (last year 30,000) of children from our sector is adding to the financial burden as well as damaging the amazing diversity of choice are sector offers, which enriches our society many times over.

    On 11 June, the Education Endowment Foundation’s report on the Evolution of the Attainment Gap highlights the incredible importance of early and primary years education. https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/projects-and-evaluation/projects/growing-apart-evolution-of-disadvantage-gap. The report highlights that it’s intervention and support that’s needed, a determination powered by knowledge not bodies, and when the teacher recruitment at primary level is diminishing, and the loss of specialist staff accelerating, the disadvantage for those who are currently being failed can only get worse.

    This March, teacher Hannah Gee spoke at the TEDx Royal Tunbridge Wells on ‘Why our exams need to change https://youtu.be/M5_zj2FZ6KY?si=Z51xZZvqfUsFCpYA . As Hannah makes really clear, it’s not about diluting the challenges, but making them fairer. It’s also about permitting breadth in Education, and attracting really talented adults into the profession, so they can be the role models children need around them. The Gove reforms of the last decade are now shown to be absolutely not the solution the country needed. Narrowing the GCSE curriculum to core Maths, English, Science, 2 Humanities and an MFL drove out all the opportunities that before then could encourage those whose skills diverge from this ‘norm’.

    But most schools in our sector ignored that narrowing, provided diverse choice AND exam approaches, and as a consequence have become the beacon of excellence for the UK international sector across the globe. Indeed, even the government recognises the soft power our sector provides, and our value to the nation’s GDP. The Labour party will never recognise that the GDP our private schools create locally in our towns and countryside alike is even more vital to our communities’ success. Which is where I started…

    It is the case that school doesn’t have any alumni playing in the current World cup. But the children at Claires Court can look forward to watching Mrs Hankin play in the Hockey World Cup this Summer. Knowing that one of ours is playing for her country, and still finds time to fit in being a parent, partner, teacher and leader is inspirational indeed. Go ‘Hanks’, you’ve got this! OK, it’s more than a ‘Nudge’, more a real shove!

  • The Cracked Pot – THE HEART OF THE GAME

    The Cracked Pot* is a famous fable about a water bearer with two pots—one perfect, one cracked—who carries water daily. The cracked pot feels ashamed of leaking half its load until the bearer reveals it watered seeds planted along the path, creating beautiful flowers. It teaches that flaws can create beauty, urging acceptance of imperfections.

    One of the opportunities I have always loved about my role as a teacher ( 51 years now and counting) is the influence you can have in your classroom and on the children (or adults) therein. Of course, it’s the same as you rise up through leadership into headship on not just the people you lead but the culture of the operation in hand. If you choose to move irto other areas of life, be that for me to lead the development of Mini and Junior Rugby at Maidenhead RFC (1991-2000) onto the wider stage, if you choose, to influence, if you can, the culture and as a consequence the sense of wellbeing and success of the community you’ve joined.

    When my older son expressed an interest in joining his school friends at Maidenhead Rugby Club on a Sunday morning, we swapped church for Braywick, the club’s home. Imagine my surprise to find that there were only 28 players in the mini-section, U7 through to U12. When I asked other parents why so few were signing up, it was because Rugby at the time was beset by stories of poor coaching, poor organisation, and, above all, injuries, particularly to the head. Whilst my initial intention was to drop my son off and hop over to the driving range next door to improve my golf swing, after 2 Sundays, my son had yet to touch a rugby ball, and the age group concerned, just a couple of footballing dads without a clue.

    I’d already developed a relationship with Rhino Rugby with the school, and so I bought 72 neoprene headguards, and within the first month of the following season, every rugby player from Under 10 down was required to wear one, and by the time the third season started, the other clubs in the area began to fear Maidenhead, because of course protected by the headguard, the young players were able to be far more committed to the tackle. In that first cohort of players was a 6-year-old James Haskell, whose father Jonathan (RIP) was an inspirational chairman to work with, and clearly, as James wore such a helmet throughout his professional career for Saracens, England and the British & Irish Lions, I played my small part.

    Rugby is one of those team sports for which Coaches know they need both the perfect and the cracked pots. I recall endless quiet moments at the side of the pitch,’ horse-whispering’ the child who felt so useless because he dropped the ball which would have led to a certain try, or missed a tackle that led to defeat, not victory. Like on the sports ground, in education, manufacturing, business and service industries, as Jim Collins might say, “you’ve got the right people on the bus, you just haven’t got them in the right seat”! Make them feel valued. Sometimes it’s about helping them see that there’s an objective to share, such as the Janitor at NASA. When asked what he was doing, he replied: “I’m helping put a man on the moon!”

    Will Greenwood has just produced 5 short videos highlighting his current time at the same Club, Maidenhead, entitled “The Heart of the Game”. Will goes behind the scenes, exploring rugby’s impact beyond the pitch through powerful personal stories and voices from across the game. He recalls turning up one dreadful December training evening at Maidenhead, to find only 12 players present for the First and Second squads, and found himself wondering, “Why am I here?”. Over the course of the 5 films, we are introduced to a host of characters that make the club the success that it now is, but it was Will’s sense that the Rugby players needed to see themselves as ‘Brad Pitts’ on film, to big them up and help them see more clearly what they place was in the mission of the club. You can find those films on YouTube, the first episode here https://youtu.be/LbXF3ZjjGLM?si=wuTJB30Ow1PkcRIM

    Will Greenwood finishes the series with the conclusion that “After everything, the Truth is simple. For Rugby is People, Rugby is Community, Rugby is Belonging. It’s the small victories that feel massive; it’s the safe spaces we build for each other, it’s the laughter, the tears, the graft, the kindness, all stitched together by 80 minutes on a Saturday. And as the whistle blows on another season, and the next one begins, we are reminded once again

    THIS IS THE HEART OF THE GAME.

    And Ave to that. Whatever the enterprise, the Truth is simple. And for those who lead, keep returning to these truths, and remember that in your role, it’s good noticing that counts best. Well done the Potter, Well done the Coach, well done the President who asked the Janitor the question and well done Will Greenwood – That’s why you are of course, a World Cup Rugby Champion 2003.

    *The “Cracked Pot” story is a popular folk tale often attributed to India or China. It is a widely shared parable used to teach self-worth, highlighting how a woman/man uses a leaking pot to water flowers along a path, turning an imperfection into a source of beauty and purpose. 

  • The Engine of Character: “Show up on the BAD days

    As I write this, the air in the halls of Claires Court has shifted. It is late April 2026, and the “stratosphere” of school life feels particularly charged. For our Year 13s, the countdown has reached its final sequence. Next week, the familiar rhythm of the school bell will be replaced by the quiet, intense focus of study leave.

    I found myself standing before them this morning—joined by our Year 12s, who are watching their mentors prepare for the jump—to share a final thought together. I started with a quote that has been rattling around my mind lately: Champions aren’t made on good days; they’re made by showing up on the bad ones.1

    It’s a sentiment that rings true whether you are a world-class athlete, a student facing a daunting Further Maths paper, or a Principal navigating the “bumpy ride” of a major institutional handover. Success is easy when the sun is out and the coffee is working. But the real work—the “alchemy” of growth—happens on those Tuesday mornings when you’re tired, the mock results weren’t what you hoped, and you’d rather be anywhere else. That is where a champion is forged.

    We often treat A-Level results as the destination. In reality, they are merely a high-performance vehicle. These grades are the engine and the bodywork; they determine how fast you can go and what doors you can open. But as I told our students, even the fastest of cars is useless without a driver.

    “That driver is your Character.

    In a 2026 landscape where AI can simulate knowledge and algorithms can mimic problem-solving, your human values—our Claires Court values—are the fuel. Without them, you are just a fast car with no one at the wheel.”

    I challenged them to look at our four pillars not as school rules, but as survival gear for the world beyond our gates:

    1. Responsibility: Taking 100% ownership. Not blaming the exam board or the “bad day,” but deciding to be the operator of your own life rather than a passenger.
    2. Respect: Recognising that we are an interconnected network. In the heat of exam season, respect means being the person who calms the room rather than adding to the panic.
    3. Loyalty: Understanding that the “Family” doesn’t end at graduation. These peers are your safety net for life.
    4. Integrity: This is the cornerstone of the entire Sixth Form experience. We ask you to “Aim High, Believe in Yourself, and Make a Difference”, but those are more than just aspirational rungs on a ladder. They are a test of character. If your achievements aren’t built on a foundation of absolute honesty, the structure you’ve worked so hard to build will eventually find its own level—and usually, it collapses.

    As I readied our Year 13 for their final week of study before departing on study leave, I left them with one final biological reality check. 

    “We are built with a very specific ratio: two eyes, two ears, two nostrils, and only one mouth. The world you are stepping into is noisy. It is full of people jumping to early conclusions and shouting over the data. My advice to you, our departing seniors, is to honour that ratio. Look and listen twice as much as you speak. Breathe in the environment and see the world from all sides before you decide you have the final answer. Be the person who understands the room before they try to lead it. The results will open the doors, but your character will keep you in the room. Show up on the bad days, keep your eyes open, and go and see the world clearly.”

    “Et Omnes Unum Sunt”

    Footnote 1 UFC Featherweight and current Lightweight champion Ilia Topuria

  • Let your light shine so brightly that others can see their way out of the dark.” — Katrina Mayer

    Reflecting on the milestone year to date of 2026, I find myself looking at the long arc of my journey alongside Claires Court. Earlier this year, I shared thoughts on “Making the Magic Happen”—observing those quiet, vital moments in our classrooms. More recently, in “Fifty Years and Counting,” I looked back at the evolution of leadership and pedagogy, mindful of the foundations laid by those who came before me. My brother and I know that we have found perhaps the most significant partner in  England to secure the future of Claires Court in the Licensed Trade Charity (LTC)’ a charity of great longevity and significant service to its own community and more broadly to Education, both in school and in adult life beyond. 

    Maidenhead: A Shared Campus: My own growth is inseparable from the ecosystem of the Eastern Thames Valley. For 66 years, Claires Court has been part of the fabric of Maidenhead, and I have always viewed the town not merely as my home or a location but as a living campus. The relationships built here are a willingness of RBWM to host the paddling centre on Boulter’s Island, to the rowing and sailing clubs whose facilities I am grateful to share and the sporting clubs we helped found, with the Phoenix and Claires Court Sports Club in Taplow 43 years ago to Maidenhead Royals Cricket club, based on our lovely playing fields at Claires Court Juniors, at Ridgeway Maidenhead Thicket.

    I have been a quiet supporter of ‘The Friends of Maidenhead Waterways Trust,’ and after the previous three years of helping clear Strande Water, it is a joy to see the “flow” return. The school always looks forward to our active participation in the Waterways Fun Day in September at the Chapel Arches centre—a testament to what happens when a town thrives. I am clear that while the school is a destination for many, it is our presence as a neighbour and a partner in the town’s sporting and community life that defines our true value.

    Lessons from a “Silent Spring”: As someone deeply invested in Ecology, Psychology, and Digital Technology, I often return to the warning in Rachel Carson’s 1962 book, Silent Spring. Her work exposed the “bioaccumulation” of toxins that threatened our world, sparking a movement of awareness. Today, I feel a similar responsibility to ensure our children understand that “Their place is here.” To protect their future, I believe Education in schools must:

    Prioritise ‘Forest School’: Not as an extra-curricular, but as a fundamental way to ground children in the natural world.

    Cultivate Cognitive Capacity: To help students become critical analysts who judge by actions, not just words.

    Spark Internal Momentum: So that they may eventually find their own path to becoming changemakers.

    Turning Toward the Light: There is a simple truth in physics: when you turn toward the light, the shadows fall behind you. My intention as I move forward is to keep my focus aligned with that brightness. If I can maintain a steady, hopeful path, perhaps it helps clear the way for others to do the same, which in practice means keeping hold of the many hands that exist within our links to the town and our community partners, as well as reach out to grasp new opportunities where they exist to support the life and vitality of the area. Which is of course a great starting point, because as the Top-Ranked Vitality Index (2026 by Lambert Smith Hampton (LSH), Windsor & Maidenhead was named the top-ranked location, retaining its status from 2025 and 2022.

    I am not celebrating my own tenure; I am celebrating the opportunity to be a small part of a much larger story—one of lighting the way for the generations to come.

    “In nature, nothing exists alone.” — Rachel Carson

  • The Author, the Village, and the Paradox of Independence

    On Monday 23 February, my brother and I announced that the ownership of Claires Court Schools Ltd. had moved from the Wilding family over the the Licensed Trade Charity, a venerable organisation established in 1793 to support children and families in that trade. 10 days earlier, I had written this blog, foreseeing that event, in reflection of the 66 years the school has been created and led by our family. The post will be succeeded next Thursday; as Principal leading Claires Court into the future, I’ll be able to report further on the incredible and positive response from alumni, families and the wider education community in recognition of the school’s impact on their lives and futures. It’s been truly heartwarming.

    Back in January, I wrote about ‘Making the Magic Happen in 2026’. Since then, the weather has seemed determined to test that optimism. The rain has been relentless, and at times the year has felt more grey than glittering. But perhaps that is when magic matters most.

    Real magic is not sunshine-dependent. It is the steady confidence of a community that knows who it is and why it does what it does. If anything, these damp weeks have sharpened my conviction: the magic at Claires Court is built daily — deliberately, consistently and together. I’ve attended almost every parents’ evening over the past 3 weeks, sat through concerts, stood on the muddy touchlines, and led some assemblies, too. Indeed, so much has sparkled. 

    My commitment to leading this school is both professional and deeply personal. Founded in 1960 by my parents, David and Josephine Wilding, Claires Court has shaped my life. My brother Hugh and I were among the first 19 pupils to walk through its doors, and for over 45 years—now well into our fifth decade of leadership—we have had the privilege of guiding this community. This is not simply a role; it is a calling.

    We have not just led the school — we have lived it. Our own children were educated here before heading to university, equipped with resilience, confidence and the ability to communicate and lead. Now, as I welcome my grandchildren, that circle begins again, reinforcing my determination to preserve the “village” that sustains us.

    Yet warmth alone is not enough. Parents choose Claires Court for the uncompromising quality of our academic education. Community gives us heart; intellectual rigour gives our students their future. Whether joining at 11+, 16+, or leaving after Sixth Form, every pupil is here to develop the mastery that unlocks the next stage of life — not simply to pass tests, but to thrive beyond them.

    We also understand the “independence paradox”. As young people grow, they seek space — sometimes wishing their parents invisible at the school gate — even as academic pressures intensify. Our task is to honour that independence while ensuring no student walks alone. We provide structure, expectation and encouragement, allowing pupils to feel ownership of their success, supported quietly but firmly in the background.

    The magic lives in how we bridge childhood and adulthood. A moment on stage or on the sports field may begin in joy, but it develops discipline, courage and teamwork. Play evolves into character. By the time our students leave, they do so not only as capable scholars but as grounded young adults who carry the strength of their village with them.

    After fifteen years of blogging, one might ask what becomes of a story when its original author steps aside. At Claires Court, the answer is simple: the story was never about one pen. It lives in second-and third-generation families, among former pupils who return as parents and staff, and in values that outlast individuals.

    The rain will pass. We can only hope – next week is Half-Term!

    The magic endures — because it is written collectively, by a community that continues to shape its future, whatever the forecast.

  • Purpose, Pride, and a Few Extra Kit Bags

    Audio overview blog

    With every New Year comes hopes and aspirations, though perhaps, like the sunshine this week, they peek through a watery sky. The playing fields at Claires Court Juniors may look similar to those elsewhere in the neighbourhood, but whatever happens in January and beyond is built on the foundations of our achievements over the previous years. The most likely impact comes from the deliberate steps we have taken to move forward positively and, to slightly misquote Tom Hanks, “Turn up, know your purpose and show that you know what you are doing!”

    Perhaps the most delightful rebuttal to the “too cool for school” myth is the sheer variety of kit bags our pupils lug across those fields. It is remarkably difficult to maintain a posture of detached indifference when you are constantly switching roles—swapping muddy rugby boots for ballet shoes, trading a cross-country singlet for the quiet focus of the chess club or the studious engagement of music practice and choral singing. Our students don’t just “turn up” in the singular sense; they arrive equipped with the tools and kits required to shift their focus on demand, ready to meet whatever the day requires.

    There is a certain gritty, unselfconscious pride in an Under 15 squad that looks at a selective grammar school with 180 boys per year group and decides that our smaller, expertly tailored environment is exactly where history will be made*. As noted in our recent ISI inspection, it is this expertly tailored personal learning and specialist teaching that enables every pupil to thrive. Whether they are navigating an ambitious curriculum or preparing for the next round of a national competition, they aren’t following the “too cool” rule; they are far too busy making their own history, one kit bag at a time.

    This sense of purpose is no more evident than at the top of the school. Now that the UCAS deadline has passed, our Year 13 students are receiving offers from across the country. For them, life is both exciting and anxious in equal measure as they fine-tune their efforts ahead of A-level examinations in four months. They may eventually leave the physical kit bags of the Junior and Senior School behind, but they carry with them the versatility and initiative they have honed here, ready to step into their next chapter knowing exactly what they are doing.

    *The Under 15 Rugby XV defeated Southend High School 41-7 in the Regional final of the RFU vase on Wednesday 14 January 2026.

  • “Making the ‘Magic’ happen in 2026.”

    Link to Podcast discussion

    Claires Court Academic Faculty returned for the school-wide in-service training this week, held in the Baylis Theatre at Braywick Leisure Centre in Maidenhead. In our lead presentations and age-range-specific workshops, building relationships, resilience, and quality feedback sat at the heart of our work. Our teaching and learning initiatives have consistently been innovative and, at times, ground-breaking. Notable achievements include the implementation of cloud-based learning, Forest School, ecological renovation, and ‘Fish-hero’ technology integration. Central to our approach is the ‘Diamond School’ model. This structure underpins how we educate our students, encouraging collaborative learning while preserving the benefits of single-sex classrooms during secondary education.

    It’s encouraging to know that the Guinness Book of Records lists me as Britain’s longest-serving headteacher, leading my school since January 1981, with over 50 years in teaching and 45 years as a head/principal. I’m delighted that my advocacy for education reform and the integration of technologies such as AI in schools has earned me broader recognition. As a result, the school has become influential in promoting holistic learning, cross-sector partnerships, and innovative teaching methods, particularly within the Independent Schools sector. As a result, I will speak at a forum chaired by Emma Reynolds, MP for High Wycombe, at the Smartphone Free Childhood Meeting of Heads on 16th January 2026, as one of the schools nationally that have advocated this approach for many years.

    It might be fair to suggest that I have been ‘thinking’ about education for more years than wonderful thought leaders such as Sir Ken Robinson, Simon Sinek and Rory Sutherland, but the honest reality is that I have enjoyed it hugely to learn from their research and much wider experience in the world of work and psychology of human behaviour. Not everything they hold dearly is the only truth, so (as with AI) their suggestions for improvement may turn out to be either a contradiction in terms or not the only solution.. Every step of human progress seems to open up new challenges to be overcome, most obviously on a grand scale is how our industrial development has caused global warming. In educational terms, the arrival of the biro was considered a significant improvement over the ink pen it replaced, yet for the first 8 or so years, children learn better with a pencil.See Appendix for more on learning to write

    For many years, Rory Sutherland (whose talks are available on YouTube) has been highly influential in bridging the gap between rational business strategy and the irrational psychological drivers of human decision-making, making complex ideas engaging for a wide audience. I’ve put such ideas to good effect over time, but I am particularly enthralled by his ideas around making what we do magical!

    Rory Sutherland’s Key Educational PhilosophyChallenging “One Right Answer”: Sutherland argues that the school system misleads students into believing there is only one “right” logical answer to every question. He encourages schools to embrace questions with multiple oblique solutions and to teach students to experiment with “crazy” or counterintuitive ideas.Criticism of Academic Sorting: He characterises the current education system as “unfair” because it uses identical criteria for everyone, sorting individuals based on a single monolithic measure (such as IQ or exams) rather than valuing diverse and complementary strengths.Focus on Cooperation: Sutherland asserts that schools fail to assess or develop students’ ability to work cooperatively, noting that while academia is often solitary, the professional world is inherently social and collaborative. 

    As a consequence, our plans for the school curriculum for the next 3 years are to increase the ‘wow’ factor even more for what happens in school, without sacrificing at all the need to ensure our students lose any quality of instruction and if anything, their academic performance even more so than they do currently. The Claires Court working week encompasses a core of between 35 nd 37 hours a week, up to 44 hours if after-school clubs are taken into account, and to develop the kind of acting, musical and sporting skills needed to excel, then as with all expertise development, the more you practice, the greater the skill and the luckier you get.

    Clearly, we can’t plan to use any more of our time. As we get smarter, developing even further the positive relationships we have in school must be step 1, including the ability to bounce back from setbacks. Our curriculum is already built around content that encourages children to be curious and to collaborate on problem-solving, so scaffolding ideas and expanding the range of possible solutions is step 2. Like all who wish to make the MAGIC happen, steps 3 to 6 will have for the time being, need to remain a ‘secret’. But I certainly can give you a steer from Rory Sutherland’s address last autumn, entitled Alchemy: The Surprising Power of Ideas That Don’t Make Sense.

    Of course, we all want childhood to be magical, but that does not mean constant excitement, entertainment, or fantasy. That kind of bonanza can be enjoyed at Christmas, but it quickly becomes exhausting, undermines focus and resilience and turns learning into performance rather than growth. The psychology that creates the conditions that make childhood feel alive, meaningful, and safe is about schools seeking to cultivate wonder, play & imagination, psychological safety, and provide time to linger.  One of the causes of the disastrous reduction in childhood reading is the failure to get lost in a book; whether fact or fiction, the inner-voice that arises during reading takes at least 20 minutes to take over and for the words read to grow the child’s vocabulary.

    The deeper reason this matters is that school shapes not just what children know, but also how they relate to effort and whether learning feels like discovery or judgment. This environment significantly influences whether the world feels inviting or hostile to them. Consequently, when childhood loses its magic too early, children may still achieve academically, but this success is often accompanied by anxiety, a persistent fear of failure, and the development of instrumental thinking—constantly asking, “What’s this for?”

    So, the challenge I’ve set the team is to build on our question-based fit for the next 3 years, bearing witness to both the arrival of AI and keeping children away from screens – that magic has long since been busted. The ideal balance is not to preserve innocence indefinitely, but to allow seriousness to grow gradually as a natural progression of a child’s development. This approach introduces responsibility in a way that avoids crushing a sense of wonder, ensuring that rigour is taught through meaningful engagement rather than as a substitute for it. Ultimately, schools can successfully instil discipline without sacrificing delight, proving that academic challenge and personal joy can coexist. 

    Appendix 1 – On learning to write.

    1. Writing fluency depends on automatic motor patterns

    For fluent writing, children must automate: Letter shapes, Stroke order,
    Spacing, Pressure control

    Early on, these motor patterns are not yet stable. Pencil use supports gradual refinement because it tolerates: Over- or under-pressure, Inconsistent stroke direction, Micro-adjustments mid-stroke

    Ink, by contrast, exposes every motor error immediately, interrupting the flow needed for automation.

    1. Error correction without interruption

    Fluency improves when children can correct errors without stopping their writing rhythm.
    With a pencil: A mistake can be erased quickly, children can rewrite immediately, the motor sequence continues uninterrupted

    With ink:
    Errors require crossing out, children pause, hesitate, or restart, the rhythm of writing breaks, slowing fluency development.

    1. Reduced performance anxiety: Children are highly sensitive to permanence.

    Ink introduces:
    Fear of “getting it wrong”
    Over-monitoring of each stroke
    Slower, more cautious movements

    Pencils lower emotional stakes, allowing:
    Faster movement
    Less conscious monitoring
    More natural motor execution
    Fluency emerges when movement is confident and continuous, not careful and controlled.

    1. Pencil friction improves proprioception

    Pencils create more friction against paper than pens. This increases proprioceptive feedback—the child’s awareness of:
    Hand position
    Movement direction
    Pressure applied

    This feedback loop is essential for refining fine motor control. Ink pens glide more easily, reducing sensory information and making control harder for developing hands.

    1. Pressure calibration develops gradually as young children often:
      Press too hard
      Press too lightly
      Vary pressure within a word
      Pencils tolerate wide pressure variation while still producing a readable mark.

    Pens require precise pressure thresholds, which:
    Punish inconsistency
    Cause blotting or skipping
    Interrupt motor learning

    1. Cognitive load theory

    Children have limited working memory. Early writing already demands attention to:
    Letter formation
    Spelling
    Line orientation
    Word spacing

    Ink adds extra cognitive demands:
    “Don’t make a mistake”
    “Press just right”
    “Keep it neat”

    Pencils remove these constraints, allowing cognitive resources to focus on skill acquisition, which accelerates fluency.

    1. Developmental readiness matters

    Children typically transition successfully to ink when:

    Letter formation is automatic
    Grip and pressure are stable
    Writing speed is consistent
    Self-correction is internalised
    This varies widely, and so with schools that switch at age 11, the introduction of the use of pens in Year 5 and 6

    In essence:

    Pencils support fluency because they encourage risk-taking, support motor learning, reduce emotional and cognitive barriers and preserve writing rhythm

    Ink demands mastery; pencils build it.

    Some schools equate:

    Ink writing = neat work = good learning

    Ink produces darker, more uniform lines, which:

    Photograph and photocopy better

    Look more “finished” in exercise books

    This can lead schools to prioritise appearance over process, even when fluency is still developing. Neatness is no measure of the quality of learning taking place.

    Appendix 2 – Podcast discussion on this blog