Tag: writing

  • The Academic Vacuum: Why Test Scores Aren’t Enough to Save Our Children

    In my fifty years in education, I have watched the pendulum of school reform swing back and forth with dizzying speed. We have seen the rise of the “knowledge-rich” curriculum and a laser-like focus on the “core” subjects of English, Maths, and Science. On paper, the UK is a success story; our performance in international league tables has markedly improved.
    But as I look out across the landscape of 2025, I am deeply troubled. We have traded the soul of our schools for a set of metrics. While we have been busy passing tests, we have left a vacuum in the lives of our young people—and that vacuum is being filled by something far more sinister than a poor grade.

    The Missing “Outlets”
    The rise in youth misogyny and the “Manosphere” is not in doubt. But its causes are far more widespread than a failure of schools to “instruct” boys on how to behave.
    Education is about building pride—the kind of pride that comes from knowing you can lead a choir, command a stage in a drama production, hold your own on a muddy rugby pitch or stay at the helm when the wind blows so strongly. When we narrow the curriculum to meet testing targets, we strip away these “outlets.”
    For boys, this creates an identity vacuum. If a young man doesn’t find status and belonging within the school gates—through the arts, public speaking, or sport—he will look for it elsewhere. He finds it in the aggressive, individualistic “alpha” rhetoric of the online world. He isn’t looking for hate; he’s looking for a way to feel significant.

    The Internalized Crisis for Girls
    The damage to our girls is equally profound, though it often wears a different mask. In our “attainment-focused” culture, girls are increasingly internalizing the pressure to be perfect. Without the “safe failure” provided by a creative performance or the communal resilience built in team sports, we are seeing a crisis of confidence. National data shows that girls’ enjoyment of physical activity drops by a staggering 30% as they transition to secondary school. Why? Because the school has become an “attainment factory” where there is no space for the messy, joyful growth that happens in a choir or on a sports field.

    Understand there is Crossover

    However, we must be careful not to paint with too broad a brush. In the Venn diagram of character building, the needs of our students often overlap in vital ways. Just as we see boys who internalize their anxieties and retreat into isolation, we see many girls who desperately need the overt, public validation of success that only the arts or sports can provide. For these girls, a “gold star” on a maths paper isn’t enough to build an identity; they need the tangible thrill of a standing ovation the visceral pride of a last-minute goal or stroking the quad to victory to feel truly seen. When we cut these programs, we don’t just lose “extracurriculars”—we lose the primary mirrors in which these young women see their own strength and capability reflected. As the header to this post highlights, the ‘high’ that can be achieved when 33 rowers, boys and girls, row in unison to a collective override to ‘exhaustion’ really is worth the effort!

    ​A Different Path: The Claires Court Model

    People often ask why schools like Claires Court maintain such a formidable reputation, not just for academic success, but for the character of their alumni. The answer isn’t a secret formula; it’s a commitment to the whole child.

    ​We have always believed that a “broad and balanced” education isn’t a luxury—it is a necessity.

    • ​We protect the Arts because they build empathy and emotional literacy.
    • ​We champion Sport because it teaches the “social contract” of loyalty and respect.
    • We prioritize Oracy because a child who can speak with confidence is a child who can navigate a complex world without falling prey to extremist ideologies.
    • Above all, we stand by the strongest set of values, that include and set a bar strong enough to hold when times get rough: Responsibility for ourselves, Respect for others, Loyalty to our school (and family) and Integrity above all.

    ​The Role of the Alumni

    When I look at our alumni, I don’t just see people with good A-Levels or vocational BTecs. I see individuals who make a meaningful contribution to wider society. They do this because their education was a rehearsal for life, not just an exercise in memorization. They learned to build pride in what they can do, not just what they can test for.After five decades in this profession, my conviction has only grown stronger: It won’t come from just the academic.

    ​We must restore the “holistic heart” of our schools. We need to give our children back their voices, their creative outlets, and their communal spaces. If we don’t, we shouldn’t be surprised when they find their sense of purpose in the darker corners of the internet.

  • #MakingHistoryEveryDay

    When the school was emerging from #lockdown, it was very evident that everyone’s ‘engines’ needed a metaphorical service, to check that all the moving parts were suitably free-running, that the ‘satnav’ switched on and the future direction of travel calibrated. At most of the following assemblies I ran at Senior Boys, and on the other sites as appropriate, I included the  hashtag “MakingHistoryEveryDay” and used the current achievements (of anyone, it must be said) to illustrate the point. And it worked. Creating aspiration is one of the key strengths headteachers need, yet often that staircase of hope does need some easy risers to get going. It’s also true that not every aspiration will be met, as my childhod ambition to play open-side flanker for England testifies!

    During last week and this week, we’ve seen rainbows over the schools, a metaphor for the evidence in front of our eyes that, despite the rain, the sun will shine once more. We know though that the physical elements will continue to forge and shape our future, as will the changes in humanity itself affect the ongoing direction of our enterprises. School is a small microcosm of this; over the past 20 years, we’ve worked hard to provide for all sites access to all-weather pitches (to combat the rain) and progress the various pathways (academic, art, choral, drama, music, sports) to support the separate growth of these talents towards the best they can be. The long arc of history of our school includes developing a reputation for the quality of our fencing and judo; sadly, however noble and athletic those Olympic disciplines are, times moved on, and student interest refocused on so many other sports, activities, and interests.

    The recruitment of Sixth Former Lily Gater by Iowa University into their ‘Hawks’ boat club went viral over Instagram this week, pleased as punch that the University would be in capturing a world-class sculler for their squad and as an international academic student for their faculty. Yes, that’s another example of a student making history, yet worth highlighting that Lily joined us in the Sixth Form for the known reputation we have for the strength we have in the sport of rowing and also because of the strength and breadth of our Sixth Form teaching programme. My banner headline does try to highlight just how proud we are of Lily and her achievements, which are to have both the academic and sporting achievements to win this pick by the ‘Hawks’.

    For Christians, it was Jesus Christ who highlighted just how difficult it is for a person to be a prophet in their own land. This proverbial saying inevitably impacts not just a human, but also schools and colleges. Whilst I do spend most of my time on my feet in school, both last week and this I’ve had the opportunity to attend major gatherings during which heads and those in the wider business of education have come together to focus on the future for schools and their purpose, last at the Institute of Directors venturing further into where AI is taking teaching and learning, this with Mr Richards at the ISA Autumn Study conference, where our art work won deserved praise, and the school highly commended for the Innovation we bring to our curriculum and purpose.

    As I write, it seems our 2025 School Inspection report remains unpublished, a simple issue of delay by the final piece of editing. Without the accolades within, it’s difficult to ensure that our future audience of prospective parents appreciate just how successful our school is at achieving its aims and live to our core values. As current parents can see from the school’s App and Instagram blog, the achievements, accolades and actions of our athletes carry on in all areas. Our U14 netball girls beat Wellington College on their way to becoming Berkshire Champions, and the boys’ rugby teams carry on scoring tries and tackling hard, and of course Hockey is striking the right notes too.

    At Claires Court Juniors, today the staff held a quiet commemorative birthday lunch for our former colleague, Bridie Gravett, who passed away this July. Her husband, Dan, is now back at work, in school, and I know just how thankful he is to be back at work and supported by the school as a whole. Some history is not about success at all, but to note the event, understand its importance and take the opportunity to include, remember and reflect. That combined well with the broader reach of the week for Remembrance, with assemblies and silences across the sites to remember those who gave their lives in battles so we could enjoy the peace we now experience.

    Claires Court CCF assembles outside the Maidenhead Town Hall on Sunday 9 November 2025

    5 weeks of school at Claires Court lie ahead for us all. My efforts will continue as both headteacher and Academic Principal to (where possible) make more history and encourage my colleagues, children and young people to do so too. These weeks include many opportunities for our community to come together in many ways, and I’ll welcome all conversations that add elements to the hopes we have for our children ahead. We are always told that life is too complex, but the answer is ‘to never to give in, focus on the important and what needs to be done’, and #simples, you too could be Making History Every Day.

  • “Comfortable Fictions – why it’s easier to make some stuff up rather than go by the evidence!”

    This week’s blog explains why it’s easier to make some stuff up rather than go by the evidence!,” discusses the prevalence of educational myths, contrasts them with evidence-based approaches, and features the career insights of World champion & Olympic bronze medallist Mark Richardson, Claires Court Headboy in 1987-1988.

    As a professional teacher, growing up through more than the average number of decades than most, I’ve seen a ‘Heinz variety’ of Edu-myths, promoted to be kind to adults and children, on why perhaps their ‘intelligences’ were maybe different to others in the same context, and how perhaps they might be better attuned to learn differently.

    The graphic below shows categories of intelligence types, yet have no scientific basis whatsoever:

    Howard Gardner started this ‘Goldrush’ in the early 1980s with his ‘multiple intelligences’ model, which grew up alongside the much-promoted concept of ‘learning styles’. Other myths include the VARK model, that learning is better in bite-sized chunks, that left-brain/right-brain dominance dictates how people learn, and that a specific amount of learning (20% in this case) is lost when ‘students’ sleep. As the graphic above shows, it makes such good points that ‘surely it must be true?’ Sadly not, there’s no golden ticket to the future, just the bitter Northern Irish truth that ‘Life is hard and then you die’, perhaps even better illustrated by American Science Fiction writer David Gerrold, who wrote:

    “Life is hard. Then you die. Then they throw dirt in your face. Then the worms eat you. Be grateful it happens in that order”

    Our first visitor in our Speaker series this year was the athlete Mark Richardson (1983-88), Olympic medallist and World Champion and last Friday night, his 45 minute or so unscripted talk highlighted much about his development as a teenager into adulthood and his learning as an elite athlete that rang so true of what I remember about Mark in the 5 years he was at Claires Court. To an audience of parents and their sporty offspring, Mark’s presentation included his development from wannabe runner through the 1990’s culminating in his ‘greatest race’, winning the 1998 400m against Michael Johnson, world champion at the time. 

    In the 1997 World Championsips, Mark ran the anchor leg of the 4x400m relay, and initially won the Silver medal behind the USA quartet, subsequently upgraded to Gold when one of the American runners admitted to doping offences. Mark was asked whether he minded having to wait until this July to receive his medal, with the other 4 involved, Jamie Baulch, Roger Black, Iwan Thomas and heat runner Mark Hylton.

    Mark’s reply was simply wonderful. “Not at all. This time, in the London stadium, my daughters were present. So for them, Dad wasn’t just somebody who’d been an athlete long ago, before they were born. To have my medal presented to me and the team, whilst their mum and they watched was a magical moment’.

    After his athletics career, and a period of self-doubt and reflection, Mark commenced on a career in business. 

    “ I now consult with organisations and I take a lot from being an athlete and setting performance goals, deconstructing things into thinking about what it is you’re trying to achieve, thinking about those performance milestones, those key performance indicators, and then breaking it down into bite-sized chunks that you can be doing, day in and day out. 

    I’m a big believer in that. I learned that skill as an athlete – and the ability to compartmentalise as well. There are loads of things I probably didn’t realise that I was doing 30 years ago as an athlete, but I’ve got the benefit of really strong knowledge about performance psychology now.”

    What Mark made abundantly clear to us is that, to reach the very top, you need to have that as the goal, and you have to believe in yourself and your capabilities to improve. It is best not to spend any time dwelling on what others do, but to look after your own ambitions and then break them down into clear, compartmentalised goals, each of what are supported by specific tasks to do and changes in training so achieve them. He highlighted the many setbacks he faced throughout his running career, most notably that overtraining led to burnout and viral illness. During the audience’s opportunity to question Mark, they asked whether he ever ran that fast in training. Somewhat disarmingly, he answered, “I’m quite a lazy trainer and I’d never try that hard in training, just jog around, sort of faking it!”

    All the signs are that, for whatever learning and skill acquisition needs to be completed, the support that fails is that of undeserved praise. Rather than suggesting someone is brilliant, what is much more effective is to check on what went well, highlight possible next steps and allow for feedback and goal setting.

    I conclude this blog by quoting from a very recent article by Professor Carl Hendrick, formally an English teacher locally, and fellow researcher into what works best in learning: “The comfort of myth crowds out the discipline of truth (even amongst teachers):

    This is not science. It is not even good pedagogy. It is moral theatre, performed for an audience of educators who want to believe they are doing the right thing without having to prove it. And the applause comes not from improved student outcomes, but from the warm glow of shared moral conviction.

    The great danger of comfortable fictions is not that they are wrong, but that they make us feel right. They provide the satisfaction of moral certainty without the inconvenience of empirical accountability. They allow us to believe we are helping when we may be harming, to think we are progressive when we may be perpetuating the very inequalities we claim to oppose.”

  • Founders’ Day and the dynamism of a Family school

    Thursday 18 September saw the 2025 scholars and their families presented with their awards, for academic excellence, for the Arts and Sports and for those who are excellent in the round. Those present included new entry and long-serving families to the schools, covering in the main Years 7 to 9. In the address I gave to the 48 scholars and accompanying adults, I highlighted of course the success the young people had achieved in winning the scholarship, yet that it meant something more to them and the school. I quote verbatim below:

    ”Now to business – Scholarship is a word that is rarely used, and perhaps often misunderstood. 

    What this means at Claires Court is this:

    Scholarships are awarded based on merit, such as academic achievement, artistic or sporting talent, or specific subject potential. Please note that for you young people, it’s not a REWARD – in a sense, you haven’t done anything yet! We have every expectation that, whatever your award, you recognise that you have entered a performance pathway that will, no doubt accelerate your knowledge and skill acquisition. As we celebrate with Holly Hatch and Gareth Wellen at the close of today’s celebration, our leading GCSE students now moving on from Year 11 into A level studies, they have been a major influence on the other students in their Year and the school more generally, and we hope you will have the same extraordinary effect on the school as you move through as Claires Court Scholars.”

    This week, for both Senior School open days, Steve Richards presented to over 100 families in attendance that Claires Court was founded by my parents, that my brother Hugh and I are still fully involved in the school, but that in addition, our prospective parents would see on their tour around the school, young people who really were proud of their school, aware of the myriad of opportunities available to them every day, and clearly perhaps very conscious that they were already achieving so much more than they could ever have imagined prior to entry.

    Of course at some point in the future, the 2 founding pupils (Hugh and I) will no longer be around, yet the school will be, with its ongoing aims and values being retained because of their fundamental value in what makes Claires Court the school it is. Yet the school has to be pioneering in its approach for education all the time, as what works now will certainly hit ‘cracks and potholes’ in the way ahead, a route for the ‘futures’ as yet unknown to us all.

    The headteachers and I are really proud of the close relationships we build both with the children and young people in our care, but also with the parents & guardians that support their sons and daughters and our wider school community so strongly. One great recent example has been the enthusiasm and determination of our younger families to ensure their primary age children enjoy a SMARTphone-free childhood. Hosting the inaugural group of 60+ heads from RBWM at our Junior school highlighted that ‘Now was the time to act’, and it’s so good to see that message proliferate not just in our local authority but across the country as a major groundswell of parental opinion covering the next few years of their families lives so well.

    For older students and us adults, the world of the SMART phone cannot be ignored, providing as it does a route to so many services required in life, and not just because we are now a cash-free society. Prime Minister Starmer announced today the need to have a digital identity card for citizens permitted to work in this country, and frankly since I no longer have a bank locally and need to access NHS services via an App, the reality of their universal use is evident to us all.

    I’ve received the video released this week by the SMARTphone free pressure group in the USA. It’s a powerful message to us all; whatever the benefits of our digital economy, our children need the best protection they can get from the families they live amongst. Here’s an example of just how dynamic famly attention needs to be to the dangers let loose when young children are presented with such a device. 

    And finally, very many thanks to Marliyn Hawes, Freedom from Abuse for her powerful and hard-hitting presentation on the wider challenges that now exist in navigating young people through the turbulent waters of adolescence. What makes the difference between the childhoods of parents and those older generations beyond and the young of 2025 is the the sheer mobility of society and immediacy of access to knowledge and experiences that were usually ring fenced by geography and community. 

    In my family history there are ancestors from Essex/East End who were transported to Australia for criminal activity, but kept local and out of sight from the rest of the country. As a boy, I remember seeing the appalling photos of children in flames during the Vietnam war, and of the civil war of the ‘Troubles’ in Northern Ireland. Yet they weren’t sent to the screen in my hands, but arrived perhaps in a colour supplement delivered first to my parents who with some care might have talked me through the stories. That’s the major difference now, and why managing the access to the world of troubles so sharply expressed in the video above is an essential part of the dynamism that schools and families need to embrace.

    Ending on a high note about our pupils at Claires Court, whether they be the scholars winning awards last week or the wider school on show yesterday and today, they clearly just love that the continuity between schools is welcomed, and gives them the skills to express their voice, support their school and enjoy so many of the opportunities around them, very much beyond my wildest dreams from 1960, when I first started at Claires Court!

  • Making Sense of the World of Marginal Gains…

    Most of the readers of my blog will be very well aware that things get better step by step. My first car bought whilst I was at Leicester University, in the summer of 1972 was a Ford Popular 100E (1960 model as in photo below), replacing my Honda 75 motor scooter. Travelling the 100 miles each way to Uni to get home on the Honda, open to the elements in a dreadful winter was no fun at all, so replacing that with a car, with some heating and room for 3 friends was life changing. The ‘Pop’ was by all measures a dreadful car, not capable of going faster than the scooter, and when travelling up hill, the windscreen wipers would crawl to a halt, running as they did on the air intake manifold. As for acceleration, 0-60 mph was only possible downhill, and over 30 seconds. Where GB car ownership now is beyond any recognition of those times, who knows what we will be in 50 years from now, yet it’s likely to be approximately the same space and size for 4 or 5 humans to use.

    The same can be said of so many sports; in my times, GB sports have moved from participation to world leading, and these improvements have not occurred by luck, but through the careful and systematic research, starting with the question ‘Why?’ David Brailsford ‘reinventing the wheel’ is nicely described in this Harvard Business Review , in which he explains how the ‘podium principles’ for success were broken down into strategy, human performance and continuous improvement. In Bounce (2010), Matthew Syed gives so many examples on why practice makes perfect, not least by repeating the mantra practice makes perfect! Because GB sport has learned these lessons, in almost all areas of sporting endeavour we are right up there, hence our place as number 2 in the Olympics.

    You won’t be surprised to hear that critics of the classroom suggest that it has not changed over the past 200 years’ designed as it was for the industrial age to create automatons for the factory floor. Images of the Victorian classroom are placed alongside those of the 21st-century classroom, where now in the AI age it is suggested that little is to be learned by gathering knowledge; what we need are the many and various transferable skills to meet the multiple challenges of the post-industrial world, where machines will replace all of our working careers. Such ideas are worth exploring, testing and indeed seem enticing. At the time of my graduating, us new young things were enticed by the idea that our improving wealth would give us more leisure time, happy families and a world of ‘perfect’. So we know how that’s worked out – not!

    Certainly, at my school, we’ve adopted all the podium principles suggested by Brailsford, embraced most of Syed’s psychological and philosophical standpoints, and in every area of our school lives, we’ve seen the marginal gains arise for the children. We’ve learned the lessons of too much screen time; we know that children must learn how to be bored, how to build resilience by failing and enjoyed/admire hugely seeing the extraordinary successes of 18 Ukrainian refugees over 3 years, with little knowledge of the Roman alphabet and spoken English on arrival to the UK, be able to graduate to secondary school, sixth forms and Universities with academic results that most families would say ‘I’d take that!’

    I was intrigued this week when watching a short BBC news clip on Otters, once considered vermin and almost exterminated by vicars and game keepers up to the time I was at Uni. Now they are welcomed back into rivers across the countryside, with some care of course, because they’ll eat you out of fish House and Home in a trice. As with humans, otter pups are intensely curious, and they need be stimulated and enabled to roam, through which they learn all the necessary skills for successful adulthood. It’s just the same for children. Before the age of 5 or 6, learning happens most successfully by play, in a cohort, working together and learning how to socialise. You check out Maslow’s hierarchy of needs to see how success starts, understand the steps taken here, each won through marginal gains. From then onwards, the way we organise our higher thinking skills requires some formalised teaching, not least to keep the child’s emotional development in harness with their intellect – see Bloom’s taxonomy for more on this. Originally shown as a pyramid, I prefer Bloom’s intellectual development in the shape of a 20th-century light bulb because when working with others, we know when our own or their light bulb moment happens – a marginal gain switching on the ‘wow’ and ‘wonder’ and ‘I get it’ moments!

    Whether Bloom, Brailsford, Maslow or Otters, it’s clear the adult coach has their place to steer improvement to happen Yet necessary to that struggle is peer group socialisation, intervention when that’s not going right, teaching to lift the child over the knowledge and skills barriers that are counter-intuitive, ‘parenting not friending’ when managing the household and above all, not putting one’s brain on the shelf and letting others, including AI, carry the load and not bother learning the skills ourselves. I’m intrigued by the latest research that highlights that children need to learn to write physically before using a modern keyboard and computer. Back in the day, whether using paper & pen or typewriter, you had to think about your writing before hardcopy simply because, whether be ink from the pen or the ribbon, once on the paper the mark was permanent. Now, you don’t need to trouble yourself because the screen is a friend to correction. Using such a modern screen, it seems the child can’t remember what they wrote 2 or 3 sentences before, and within about 10 minutes after the work is complete, the work done has been completely forgotten.

    Taking the time to do things well encourages the world of marginal gains, and such practice makes perfect, and after much repetition, practice makes permanent. From brain surgery, through cycling to table tennis, it turns out it’s never about talent (5%), it’s perspiration (95%) – fired of course by curiosity and the desire to improve one’s own performances and seeking, if not a podium finish, at least the self-actualisation of a job done well. And most of the time, that needs a peer group of about 20, of people of about the same age and interests. As indeed the ancient Syrians knew 9 centuries ago, as we’ve discovered from the archaeologists uncovering the ruins of their towns, they found classrooms. And that clearing of the dirt to reveal the evidence beneath can only be done, brush stroke by brush stroke, with common purpose and understanding, that classrooms were just big enough to house a teacher and 20 learners. Well, who knew that?

  • “Our doubts are traitors and make us lose the good we oft might win by fearing to attempt.” William Shakespeare – Measure for Measure.

    26 June 2025

    As we reach the conclusion of this academic year, I’m writing 3 blogs to summarise all the joys, fears, pains and hopes that have populated  my world of work as Academic Principal. This first is largely a wrapper around an email I wrote this week to our 3 local MPs in Maidenhead (Lib Dem), High Wycombe (Labour) and Beaconsfield (Conservative). As you can read here – https://schl.cc:443/gZ – I’ve highlighted to all 3 that our local education ecosystem (state, private & otherwise), built up over the past 7 decades is now facing extraordinary if not existential threats from the government. I’ll leave you to read the detail, but  I feel I have tried to place in the hands of our local MPs some facts and realities that might help arm them when speaking in Parliament to those that have forgotten how to tell the truth. I’ve already had one ‘holding’ reply, but positive in terms of reaching out to the Secretary of State for Education, Bridget Philipson. Bridget is already aware of my concerns and multiple offers to help, but has declined to engage to date.

    Education works when those involved, whether teacher or learner, feel confident that the process being pursued  is worth it. Claires Court Athletes learn how to run, how to challenge, how to believe and so dip their head as they cross the line, even when they’re 8! It’s Sports Day season, I’ve seen enough already to know it’s true. Change the sport, use a hard or soft ball, racquet or bat, blade or rudder and we are still there at the top of the game. Yet none of this is possible unless we try.

    It’s post GCSE (Wednesday ) and A level (Thursday) Prom week, a thing that did not exist when I was young. Friendship’s hard, they need work, effort, and having a common aim has encouraged pretty much the whole 2 cohorts to join in making a celebration happen, the assessment ‘job’ done. Meeting on the 2 evenings in question (Moor Hall, Cookham & Wycombe Heights GC respectively), I’m seeing young people and their teachers aggregate with all full respect for each other, and display a mutual, perhaps extraordinary gratitude for travelling in company with such success.

    The current Year 11 cohort’s secondary education commenced in #lockdown, an impossible time yet of course normal for them “doesn’t everyone start secondary school this way” normalising perhaps the absurdity of the uniqueness of the event. In both groups I met with both young men and women who had joined 3 years ago from Ukraine, knowing not our language, culture or even alphabet. Now, academically strong, they can look forward to settling into Sixth Forms or University. “Surrey” sparkled one, “the offer is BCC and I’m on for AABB”. A leader of our tennis squad in Year 13, having won his match up on day 2 of 4, this taking our squad into the semifinals of the UK schools LTA cup was down to celebrate with his friends, facing an early Uber tomorrow at 5.30am. His face shone “Sir, if we win tomorrow, we get to go to Brazil for the World Finals!” Oh but to dream this big!

    As Oompah, I enjoy all the benefits of the grandchildren, but can give them back at the end of the day. I’m immensely grateful for the pioneering work of younger parents and Mrs Kirby, Head of Juniors and my colleagues there, who’ve not just braved the concept of creating the possibility of a SMARTphone-free childhood, but pioneered the use of AI in the classroom too. It seems a paradox to unite both ideas, but we must. Born of a generation that watched their families smoke themselves to death, I never wanted that for mine. As Sam Altman (CEO, ChatGPT) makes clear, “It’s weird that even knowing ChatGPT, Gemini etc. exist has created blind trust in AI , and that’s what is causing it to grow so fast – People want fast answers, even if they’re wrong!”

    Like many very experienced educators, I’ve seen the cohorts of adults over time go through ‘school’. I was one of the ‘baby-boomers’, my teaching began with the ‘latchkey’ generation, my children now perhaps sit as core ‘millenials’ as they were taught by me and lately of course we’ve seen the start of GenZ looking at nursery. Whilst the entire group may share a common love of say Robbie Williams and “Angels”, there’s likely to be staggeringly different views over drinks, foods, medias and technologies. There always has been such differences, such as those in my childhood not allowed a telly, but they’re nothing like as polarising as they are now. ‘Schooling’ by its  very name describes that growing up requires conforming to a norm, not pick’n’mix. ‘Helicopter’ parenting shifts the dial and the arrival of ‘Snowploughs’ is already creating havoc ‘Stateside’, and the exam boards in the UK report growing disputes over the ‘fair’ interpretation of their access arrangement rules.

    William Shakespeare would be 461 if he was still alive. In his works, almost every ill of the present day can be found, and whether comedy or tragedy, that old man continues to inspire the generations to come. In ‘Measure for Measure’, the synopsis makes Angelo rule as a religious tyrant, try to manipulate a nun to sleep with him, is foiled, and ultimately punished. It sounds a tragedy, is a comedy, and has an epic series of moral conclusions that bear study in 2025. Those in current political life across the world would do well to check out the Bard. As the quote makes clear, if we can speak truth, build and give trust, the likelihood is that fear and anxiety will truly ease. I’ll conclude with a poem by another man, John Donne writing during the same time as William:

    No man is an island,
    Entire of itself,
    Every man is a piece of the continent,
    A part of the main.
    If a clod be washed away by the sea,
    Europe is the less.
    As well as if a promontory were.
    As well as if a manor of thy friend’s
    Or of thine own were:
    Any man’s death diminishes me,
    Because I am involved in mankind,
    And therefore never send to know for whom the bell tolls;
    It tolls for thee.

  • “The day that changed my life” – Andrew Watson

    It’s Friday afternoon, 21 February 2025. Eight days ago, I attended Andrew Watson’s funeral service at St James the Less, Stubbings. The event was so oversubscribed that the church and parish centre (with a live broadcast) were full, and there was standing room only outside. The service was a remarkable showcase of his life, not just because of the size of the congregation but also because of the incredible epitaph his sister Victoria gave that brought home to us all the remarkable impact Andrew had made in the 54 years of life spent alive with us. Since Andrew’s service and following conversations with friends at the wake and elsewhere, I feel I can add just a little more to the notes Andrew might have made of his time at CC.

    During Andrew’s time as a child, he attended Ridgeway (the name of our junior school back then) and then Claires Court Seniors, and I had the good fortune to teach him. Though he left to continue his secondary studies at Reading Bluecoat, in those days our Junior to Senior split took place at the end of Year 5, giving students the time to enjoy a full preparatory education to age 13, and thus sit and (hopefully) pass into the senior school of their choice after 3 years of separate specialist subject education. French and Latin were on the menu, where the standards required by the most demanding of schools at 13+ were close to the current curricular demands giving rise to a grade 4 at GCSE. Those 3 years of prep. school, still in grey shirts and shorts at the outset meant that the programme was demanding and left really quite a range of children unable to access the curriculum. By way of illustration, a typical longer History essay question might ask “Choose two significant events from the 20th century and explain why they were important.”

    Andrew was no slouch, and at any given stage during his education with us, he would always show he was often the best amongst equals. That’s not the point of my writing this blog, no, not at all. The thing with Andrew is that there was always something more going on in the lesson than just his attention to the demands of the teacher. Some 25 years later, I came across the research “The Hidden Lives of Learners” written by Graham Nuthall and published in 2007. It’s a highly influential book in education, based on Nuthall’s extensive research into how students learn in the classroom. In short, Nuthall’s research suggests that teachers are often unaware of a significant portion of what’s happening in their classrooms from the perspective of the children within. Put bluntly, we only know the 5%, the rest is beyond our ken. While the “5%” figure is a popular takeaway message, it’s more of a powerful illustration of the gap between teacher perception and student experience than a precise measurement.

    Nuthall’s work emphasizes that students are constantly constructing their own understanding, engaging in complex social interactions, and experiencing a range of emotions that teachers may not fully perceive. This “hidden life” of the learner encompasses their thoughts, feelings, motivations, and interpretations of the learning environment. Because of this, teachers might only be consciously aware of a small fraction of what each student is experiencing. This realization that there’s a vast and often unseen world within the classroom, comprised of the individual and collective experiences of the children as a group. Ross Morrison McGill highlights the 3 worlds Nuthall uncovered really well in this short video:

    Working with classes 4 to 6 (now Years 6 to 8) back in the ’80s, boys like Andrew made it abundantly clear to us all that far more was going on than we considered in our adult vision. I remember one particular occasion when Kenelm England, Latin teacher and of a similar age to me lost his temper with his class. Known as Eggy to all, it was that day that Andrew suggested ‘Eggy had cracked his shell!’ Andrew’s theatre was the schoolyard, where umpteen different games and sports were invented to pass the time of day. When one game palled’ another would be invented to renew the competition.

    Whilst during our adult lives, our paths rarely converged, I became very aware of Andrew’s impact on the family, company and sporting life. I hope to share with a wider readership Victoria’s Eulogy to her brother, but for now, I ask you to jump over to Andrew’s own blog, Watto’sWords. Andrew and his brother Nicholas who followed his steps into Claires Court, suffered from Cystic Fibrosis, a genetic disorder that sadly and inevitably leads to a premature death. Despite the ever-present threat that lungs could fail, Andrew lived a life that daily brimmed to overflowing.

    In his diary entry, The day that changed my life! By Andrew Watson | May 18, 2018, Andrew highlights and celebrates the day when he was given a life-saving lung transplant. The entry makes compelling reading, perhaps a little more sombre now that, just under 7 years on, in early January this year, Andrew suffered from a relapse to his health, and died shortly afterwards 18/19 January. His parents Allen & Laraine Watson were incredibly supportive of our school whilst their boys passed through our hands, and we’ve stayed in touch professionally too, because Allen’s skills as a surveyor have assisted us in making a variety of planning applications thereafter.

    A day in early May 2017………………….

    It was early morning and the first intravenous drugs of the day were already making their way into my veins, when there was a knock on the door. It was unusual for another knock so soon; it was too early. I knew the routine as I had been in this solitary hospital room for ten weeks. Please read on…

  • The Penny Dreadful, the Ha’penny Dreadfuller – will we ever learn?

    One of the education blogs I follow is that of Alex Quigley, Hunting English. He, like me, read today’s headlines on the BBC website and in the Guardian about a new English A level syllabus being steered to approval, involving some modern populist writing: “Today the newspapers were awash with stories to make our great British population wince with embarrassment and raise a fist in fury. Our hallowed tradition of literature is apparently under threat of being sullied by the dumbing down of a new A level qualifications. It is sure to send our nation spiralling into inexorable decline. Shakespeare and Austen paired with Dizzy Rascal and Russell Brand. Oh, the horror, the horror!”

    The original Guardian article is here, and started as follows:

    “A-level students will study Russell Brand‘s views on drugs and Caitlin Moran’s Twitter feed alongside more conventional literature in a new A-level that was immediately denounced as “rubbish” by sources at the Department for Education.

    The OCR exam board said it had teamed up with an educational charity, the English and Media Centre, to develop the A-level in English language and literature to study unorthodox texts, such as a BBC Newsnight interview with rapper Dizzee Rascal and the work of former Guardian columnist the Secret Footballer.

    OCR said the exam – a separate course from English or English literature – would include an anthology which included extracts from Brand’s testimony on drug use to a parliamentary committee and tweets by Times journalist Caitlin Moran, as well as more conventional fare such as Samuel Pepys’s diary entries.

    But the education department launched a scathing attack. A senior DfE source said: “Schools should be aware that if they offer this rubbish in place of a proper A-level, then pupils may not get into good universities. We will expect other exam boards to do better.

    “It is immensely patronising to young people to claim that they will only engage with English language and literature through celebrities such as Russell Brand.”

    Comment

    My younger son studied English at the University of Leicester last decade, read from Old English’s Beowulf to 20th century slang and everything inbetween. His writing and examination covered Literature, Language and Linguistics too. Have you ever tried reading Old English? I remember Ed bringing a facsimile of BeoWulf home during a reading week, throwing the tome onto the sofa and in pure frustration demanding that the graduate home team of parent/teachers provide some genuine academic support. “I can’t make head or tale of it” he almost wept! Because his mother and father loved him, we picked up the book, opened the pages and in turn each read the first stanza or two. “Nope, makes no sense to us either!” we both declared, “It’s your degree, son, yours to earn”.

    Later on, when his third year collaborative project was coming to an end, he shared with me his 10-author modern slang dictionary of 2000 words. “Complete rubbish” I declared, ” I don’t know 90% of these, you’ve made them up”.

    Now, he is a highly successful Business Analyst working in the Digital insurance space, having to make sense of other peoples needs, ambitions and perhaps business gibberish, then to translate in such a way that in-house programmers can deliver a business platform that showcases on screens around the world a specific company’s insurance products in an interactive and adaptive manner. Now that’s a job in an industry that simply did not exist when he started his degree. What his education provided, starting at our school and continuing through University to the present day, was the encouragement to be diligent, learn how to organise work effectively, persevere, propose and  explore ideas with independence and confidence. Success comes through being able to collaborate effectively, and access to diverse opportunities to show initiative, think critically and express oneself both creatively and convincingly.

    That’s not to say that I would advocate reading Dizzee Rascal or Russell Brand, any more than I would similar ‘populist writing of previous eras. ‘Chacun à son goût‘ as the French might say. The Penny Dreadfuls of the Victorian era introduced an adolescent peer group of new, emerging male readers to lurid tales of daring do and worse; and the educated classes of the time railed at the very idea of the illiterate working man learning to read and finding entertainment in trash, serial fiction. I quote from Wikipedia “The term “dreadful” was originally assumed to express societal anxiety or moral alarm over the new profitable innovation directed at the youth. In reality, the serial novels were over-dramatic and sensational, but generally harmless. If anything, the penny dreadfuls, although obviously not the most enlightening or inspiring of literary selections, resulted in increasingly literate youth in the Industrial period. The wide circulation of this sensationalist literature, however, contributed to an ever greater fear of crime in mid-Victorian Britain”. Yep, you’ve got it, Crime, Sex and Sensation sold papers.

    The Guardian costs today £1.60. Taking the paper digitally does not cost me quite so much, but actually digital papers were not around in the 19th century. Given the paper has 80 pages, that makes each page 2 pence. If the Guardian article covered half of a page, could we not suggest that Richard Adams’s article worthy of the title ‘Penny dreadful’? The growing volume of incredibly lazy journalism around tiny chunks of non-news providing lurid stories in serial form is certainly worth the title. Unless of course, only a quarter of a page was covered, in which case we have the halfpenny dreadfuller. The target audience over a hundred years ago was adolescent. I wonder now whether the audience that responds to this trite rubbish is any the wiser? As Alex Quigley comments back in the 21st Century, the formula has move on; “Celebrity sells and Educational decline sells. Put them together and you spark 1000 comments!“

    Trash populist literature of the 19th century spawned the emergence of a literate working class, the heartbeat and muscle, imagination and perspiration that led the world’s Industrial Revolution here in the UK. I might be stretching my point a little, but could not the same be said of 21st century populist writing, be that by musicians or comedians, Twitter feed or Blog post? Is not the study of such diverse variety of the written and spoken word  likely to assist in developing the skills and intelligence to harness the post-industrial revolution in our favour. For one young Wilding in London, it certainly seems to have done just that.

  • It is the best of times, it is the worst of times…

    to quote the first dozen words of Charles Dickens’ great novel, A Tale of Two Cities, though moved to the present rather than the past. The actual paragraph reads:

    It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness, it was the epoch of belief, it was the epoch of incredulity, it was the season of Light, it was the season of Darkness, it was the spring of hope, it was the winter of despair, we had everything before us, we had nothing before us, we were all going direct to heaven, we were all going direct the other way – in short, the period was so far like the present period, that some of its noisiest authorities insisted on its being received, for good or for evil, in the superlative degree of comparison only.

    Whether your are in the early 1800s or 200 years later in the early 21st Century, his description of the paradox that is life is absolutely spot on.  Despite many of us feeling the pinch in 2012, we can smile because we are not in Athens, where the minimum wage has just been cut and the unemployment rate in UK equivalence terms has just spiked through 7 million!  And much the same is true in Education; yesterday saw the publication of interim grades in GCSE and A level modules; personally for most of our students here, the delights was plain to see on their faces – hard work being rewarded by good results.  At the same time, lots of other results of educational activities in schools and outside are being published, and the picture is totally different. I’ll return to Dickens shortly, but I must say I am enjoying the discomfort many modern pedagogues must be feeling at the moment, as their adjustment of what is taught in schools to bring examination advantage at the expense of actual education is shown up to be the folly it always was, by published research.  For example, OfSTED have just pointed out the main problem with national music lessons is that there just isn’t enough music in them! A recent survey by Opinion research highlights that secondary school pupils are so scared of looking stupid in maths lessons they will not tell their teachers if they do not understand. And it’s not just about progress in schools in Maths – the pressure group ‘National Numeracy’ quotes from research suggesting weak maths skills are linked with an array of poor life outcomes such as prison, unemployment, exclusion from school, poverty and long-term illness.  The National Trust has also reported that children are being denied the enjoyment of the outdoors and nature with obvious consequences for their health, yet few primary schools it seems genuinely give 2 hours over to sport.

    I say enjoy because in my own school we really come to work each day to teach the whole child, academically, socially, spiritually, morally, athletically, culturally and then some. This last seven days or so have seen us involved in ‘world everything days’, from Maths, Books, Science, Blogging, Doodling and then some. Our sailors came third in the national two boat sailing championships, (and the second best school behind Magdalen College Oxford), our Under 16s won the national ISA Under 16 7s title up in Leamington Spa, our Year 7s have been romping in the fields with the Sheep and their Lambs and so it goes on.  Today (Friday) we are building our BBC school report activities for next Thursday by interviewing the Home Secretary, Theresa May at the senior boys school.  Apparently we are informal this year in our approach to TM; a ‘conversation with’ rather than ‘stilted questions’ of!

    And to see the support of our parent teacher association at work this week has been the highlight – it is all about play with their outdoor castle installation at Ridgeway, both a physical construction that provides for new play space, but also with effective use of shape and colour, allowance for the child’s imagination to run riot. When schools get it right, the whole community is enhanced; children have their wildest dreams realised, teachers have their dedication rewarded by outstanding learning and parents have their own concerns for the present and future supported by the most amazing network of like-minded individuals – a Dickens story of success without the dark side!

    So back to Dickens; what he was amazing at was creating an atmosphere that felt real in a story that gripped from beginning to end.  As one critic writes “Dickens’s novels combine brutality with fairy-tale fantasy; sharp, realistic, concrete detail with romance, farce, and melodrama.; the ordinary with the strange. They range through the comic, tender, dramatic, sentimental, grotesque, melodramatic, horrible, eccentric, mysterious, violent, romantic, and morally earnest”. Now Dickens was all about writing for money, he was the most famous author in the world of his time, and he benefited too from touring the States as well as the UK.  But he also write for moral purpose, to critique current policy and through his moral tales show his adoring public how the best could be achieved, even by the dissolute. The Tale of Two cities ends when the dubious Sydney Carton sacrifices himself for the honourable Charles Darnay, and ends his life on the guillotine with the words “It is a far, far better thing that I do, than I have ever done; it is a far, far better rest that I go to than I have ever known.“